emad79

Thanks for your response Eddie and i really appreciate your reconsideration of the Citadel episode.
yeah I checked the cosmic force episode with more attention and I stand corrected 😄

Regarding Dreams of Destiny, another unexpectedly brilliant touch to mix the contents! I wasn’t aware of Forces of Destiny and it captured some interesting (and in my opinion, necessary) moments. That being said I think there’s somethigng with FoD that still throws off the Tales of the Jedi episode’s tone despite your perfecct edit. It’s probably the soundtrack and the cheap-looking 2D colorful animation that doesn’t match the serious tone of the episode explaining how Ahsoka pulled off what she did in the finale. It’s just an idea, I think FoD bits would work better if they were added as post credit content to previos episodes. I think post credit scenes have grown to be more common in TV shows (peacemaker for example) and animes already did them. It works in animes too bc usually they use a cheaper art style for their post credits scenes ( take Demon Slayer and Jujutsu Kaisen for example).

Anyways thanks again for the lovely edits. MTFBWY all.

As a 25 y/o who loved Andor and decided to give other star wars media a chance, this was SUPERB and I thank you for it. As I’ve told my friends this cut is on par with the prequel trilogy and they should try it too if they liked the prequels. I powered through the original show for 3 seasons and when I reached the Citadel and Hunted arc I was sure it was gonna remain peak afterwards. Alas, I was so disappointed because of abundance of useless, less mature bits. Then I found your version (via reddit) and it helped me get through the rest of the show ❤️

here are the few notes for what I can remember:
-As for the Retribution episode: So brilliant of you to mix contents of season 1 with season 4. It fits so well!
-Dessent on Umbara episode: That scene with Krell getting stunned was one of the very few moments one could tell this was not the original cut. It could’ve had a more smooth transition to getting stunned scene.
-As mentioned above the Citadel arc is one of my favorite arcs and as originaltrilogy/Rogue One/Andor fan I got so excited for Tarkin’s first appearance in the prequels era and the events of the episode suit his personality so well and is also a better introduction for his character instead of The Forsaken. So it makes more sense to me to have it as the one of the main episodes instead of an extra one.
-I think there’s possibly too much cut from the Cosmic Force episode. I had to ask around to fully understand the concept of force ghosts and that Qui gon learned it and he later on tought Yoda as well.

Thanks again for delivering this experience. MTFBWY!