chummlargo

DM NFBisms on Fanedit if you’re a brand new member here! They’re very responsive, and the edit is excellent.

I agree with some suggestions by fellow commenters and don’t quite agree with others, but I’ll try to be concise with what I feel would be valuable for any future fan edits in the community:

1. After the end of Andor season two, the Ring of Kafrene scene feels like the appropriate opening sequence for Rogue.
2. Cassian is unfortunately a supporting character in the film. I believe the best way to affirm his co-lead status and to restructure Rogue as a continuation of Andor would be to create a Jyn centric episode, in the style of Kleya’s in 210, opening with Krennic approaching Lah’mu in the past and ending with Galen’s death in the present. This could be as simple as incorporating the flashbacks into “Stardust” rather than “Jedha.”
3. This may be controversial, but while Shamook has done great work at Lucasfilm, and the deepfakes do better resemble Cushing and Fisher, I find the Tarkin deepfake almost completely expressionless. Certainly, the original CG is over-expressive and zombie-like, but the eyes of the CG model alone feel more “alive” to me.
4. Another controversial opinion: I have no problem believing that the paranoid, rhydo-huffing Saw would use a creature like Bor Gullet and I think Whitaker’s performance is delicious.
5. I think Krennic and Vader has to stay in, if only because Krennic needs to be seen as much as possible and Mendehlson is incredible. I’m also simply a fan of “Be careful not to choke on your aspirations, Director.”
6. Absolutely believe that the Vader/Leia sequence belongs post-credits to parallel Andor season one’s post-credits.