Kerr's seems interesting, but for me 88 minutes seems as if too much has been cut. I've been looking at Spence's and Stankpac's edits quite a bit since they seem to remove as little as possible yet still improve upon Episode III, are either of those any good?
Well thanks for that. Since the fight is such a small section (it's only about 3/4 minutes long right?) and as mentioned before I'm not a MASSIVE follower of Star Wars, could you just give a suggestion in general as what is the best Episode III edit? The fight being there was just a preference and not really a necessity.
And thanks for those links RedFive, reading through those threads as well now.
TV's Frink said:
bouerbouer said:
I've found some a good number of edits for it, but some of them either trim things I'm a fan of, such as the Yoda vs. Palpatine duel...Sorry, I stopped reading after this.
Heh. Can you seriously explain why everybody hates that fight so much?
Hey guys, I’ve recently started getting into the world of fan edits and I love the way they add the possibility of an improved film purely because of re-editing. Anyway, as the Star Wars saga seems to be the one that’s edited the most (plus I think it’s a pretty fun franchise, not a MASSIVE fan but I respect it) I’ve started burning the best fan edits I could find for each episode to DVD. I’ve got the Phantom Edits for Epsiode I and II, Adywan’s Episode IV edit (and waiting for V) to be released, and just got Spence’s Epsidode VI edit.
I’m at a dilemna with Episode III, however. I’ve found some a good number of edits for it, but some of them either trim things I’m a fan of, such as the Yoda vs. Palpatine duel, or either trim things too much, i.e. 30 minutes plus. So in your opinion, what’s the best Episode III edit that stands alongside the Phantom Edits in terms of quality?