ascatterbrainedfool

Hey Hal, sorry to bother you again with more problems lol, but I noticed that from 50:34 to 50:38, a black line appears at the top of the frame. Once again, it was the only time I noticed it in the entire movie.

I also think the music is still a little to loud at Maz’s castle when Finn says “Where’s Rey?”, and when Han says “Where did you get that?”

Hal, I feel kinda bad for pointing this out considering you just released this new version to fix a few video bugs, but I noticed that right after Rey slices Kylo’s face at the end of their duel, there are what appear to be pieces of another scene on both the left and right sides of the frame. It’s the only time I noticed it in the entire movie, so I don’t think it’s a persistent issue.

A few more:

• At the beginning of tbe movie, the Lucasfilm logo starts appearing for a split second and then stops before the logo fully appears.
• When the First Order arrive at Maz’s castle, the music gets a little too loud when Finn asks “Where’s Rey?”, and when Han asks Maz “Where did you get that?” after she shows them the lightsaber.
• When Finn are Poe are hugging at the Resistance base, look at the x-wing moving right behind them. There’s this weird “jump” (not really sure how else to describe it) effect at the very front of the x-wing.

Hey Hal, I noticed while watching the edit that a black bar appears on the far left side of the frame many times throughout the movie, and it seems to change in size whenever it appears. For reference, look at the scene with Rey cleaning her scraps, or when Rey bypasses the compressor on the falcon.

This sounds like a fantastic edit. Can I get a link?

Hi Poppasketti, I’ve read through all the changes you’ve made, and this sounds like a great edit! Can you PM me a link to the Palpatine version?