Huge congratulations on this labour of love - would love to listen to these versions, I’ve done my audiobooks to death at this point and would love to hear a fresh take
Likewise would love to see these versions, please can I have a link? Own all of the films on bluray 😃
I would love to watch these - I’ve never been able to bring myself to rewatch the last few series and would be so nice to be able to see an ending which the series deserved.
Minor update for FMA:B:R :
All 8 editorials and all 16 episodes have been finished and are now watchable. Check out my youtube channel (under the same username) for more info.
While there is still some potential improvement to be had (watch the epilogue editorial for more info), the current build is plenty watchable. Enjoy!
Thank you so much for doing this, I’ve watched the first couple of episodes and it’s really well done. Is it worth maybe considering looking at fansubs which were done and using their subs as a base for the 2003 version? Or is there some kind of software which can extract subtitle files from BD releases and convert them into a .srt? I could look into that for you if it could be helpful. Would .srt be the best format for this?
I was fortunate enough to be one of the people you shared your edits with JJ and they’re the definitive versions to me now. Whenever I see the theatrical version on TV I can always tell when there’s a deleted scene that wasn’t shown as I’m so used to watching yours now.
I can’t believe that someone would do that to you and ruin all of the hard word that you put into making these such high quality and professional quality releases. Whatever decision you make regarding releasing your work in the future I just want you to know that I have always valued your work and appreciate all of the time and effort over the years you’ve put into them. Guys like you are who make the fan-edit community such a brilliant place.
This sounds fantastic, is there a HD version being done?
Not going to lie a copy of this in 720p or 1080p would be incredible. I really hope you come back to it someday
Are you planning to do full series? I’d be very interested in seeing them
Sent a PM about this a while ago with no response, desperate to see how you’ve done it if you could send!
Half-Blood Prince has been a pain in my buttocks. The color grading has been difficult beyond belief, but I am now pretty satisfied with it. It’s taken a long time, but we’re getting there. Also, the editing process in itself has been a little hurdle because of all the different and incoherent emotions the movie is playing with. We jump all over the place with teen drama, to sinister death drama, to Voldemort backstory, and then comedy antics with Slughorn and Ron’s girlfriend; speaking of which, the all-sudden introduction of completely new and irrelevant characters (Ron’s girlfriend and Hermione’s stalker), Malfoy’s sudden introduction as a main character again after being invisible for the last three movies, and more. The movie is just everywhere.
To be honest, the original film - after having now spent a lot of time with it - is the worst out of all of them. So incoherent. And one thing I can never forgive in a film/TV franchise is when they are introducting characters to further the plot and the plot only. This film does exactly that. And I am including Ginny on this list, because we haven’t ever gotten to know her or side with her before this movie.
- Ron and Hermione’s relationship will be tested. So we introduce two characters we’ve never seen or heard of before, and give them about 20-30 minutes of runtime alongside the main cast to:
* Give Hermione a reason to become jealous, and grow closer to Harry (just as friends, for some reason)
* Give Ron a taste of love, but later realize that Hermione is the one he really want
* Create drama and tension between the three main characters
* Create comedy in what is a pretty dark movie
We also need Harry to find a love partner, so we - without barely any hints or chemistry:
- Introduce Ginny as a sort of main character.
- Make her do weird, sexual stuff like tieing Harry’s shoelaces on all fours before trying to make out with him
- Make her make choices for Harry, which somewhat means that he suddenly trusts her judgement after spending five years treating her like a child and a sister.
The film fails, miserably. And it cost us about 30-40 minutes of runtime, in the very last chapter before the end. So unforgiveable. I mean, after having spent five films with these guys - and at this one six - starting to introduce unimportant characters to serve a sideplot is the last thing I would want. I want to know more about Voldemort. I want to see Harry, Ron and Hermione starting to grow into their more adult selfs. I want to see them come to gripes with fear and insecurities. I want to see them stand up for one another. I want to see them try to make the world better. To talk with the other students we’ve come to know and love, and hear what they are feeling - and fearing - and loving - and protecting. Not spending forty minutes with sideplots, followed by comedic Liquid Luck sequences and a random dead spider encounter (Aragogg) and then some DARK, dark drama out of the very blue that kills the main freakin’ good guy, Albus Dumbledore himself. I mean, we simply went from a drama film - to a teen drama comedy - to a damn horror movie, in the span of two hours.
Either way, I’m done ranting. At least now you can guess what I’ve (tried) to change!
CHANGELIST, ONLY MAJOR PARTS:
Film is color graded to look like a film. Gone is the diarrhea-colored filter. Every single scene has been personally touched upon.
The opening bridge attack has been tied together with the reveal of Snape as a bad guy and his scenes with Bellatrix and her sister. This flows better in my opinion as we now start with the bad guys and then move on to Harry, rather than jump in-between; twice.
Removed random new character with the purpose of flirting with Harry, in the Train Staton opening. Also did a lot of thematic changes (with the help of the beautiful John Williams OST) to this opening, to make it feel more like a Harry Potter movie. Dumbledore/Hogwart’s soundtrack, Harry’s Theme/Hedwig’s Theme etc.
Shortened the scene where Dumbledore and Harry are looking for Slughorn. Removed the stupid, non-sensical “Dragion’s blood” sequence.
Removed some silly faces and expressions from Slughorn as he first sees Harry.
Removed Dumbledore’s mention of Dragon’s blood, and his “Ah, yes, but first, introductions!” - and get us to the point.
Changed the atmosphere of Diagon Alley, soundtrack and color grading. Also some happy SFX.
Removed Harry’s broken nose and Luna fixing it. It’s a cute scene, but it completely stops the movie at (another) hault.
The Great Hall sequence, that in the original is presented with a green/brown diarrhea palette and washed out lights, now actually looks like a Great Hall sequence. This required layer upon layer with different sorts of color grading, including a bunch of masking. I should’ve been paid doing this, hahaha.
Re-shuffled a lot of scenes. Make it feel more Harry Potter’y. We start with some Quidditch, then move onto potions class, from there to Malfoy’s mission and thereafter Dumbledore’s office, and then Malfoy again. Things flow better this way, as we start out cute and innocent and then slowly move a little bit into the darker aspects of the film.
and a bunch more, but I won’t bother to write nor reveal anything else. I think your viewing experience will be better off of it!
VIDEO PREVIEW #1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m1ob7G8Xg_g
Color grading. A little tease of the re-edited opening (although without the middle and end of it).
VIDEO PREVIEW #2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ak4G_KkRKnA
New Great Hall color grading. Includes before/after near the end.
This sounds like a fantastic edit, exactly what the film needs. Looking forward to seeing the final cut! On the great hall cut PV from 0.33 to 0.34 the colours become noticeably warmer and then a few seconds after that it changes back again though, just in case you’ve missed it.
Does anyone have a version of this available? Sounds so much better
Any updates on how these are going? Desperate to see the rest of your HP edits!
I’d also appreciate a PM for this, sounds intriguing
Similar to post above, if anyone has any myspleen invites or something so I could access these it would be appreciated!
Any word on the likelihood of a Crimes of Grindelwald extended edition? Even just the overlayed version which you mentioned to remove the “Deleted Scene” text in the corner would be appreciated, and the idea of adding the extra scenes to the end of Fantastic Beasts sounds amazing!
PM sent, J 0mega.
I would also appreciate a PM if possible!