Few days ago I re-watched A Hobbit’s Tale, and compared to the last time I saw the movie, around 2 years ago my opinion is somehow updated.

At first, it is greatly done in the style of The Lord of the Rings, loved the few shots and voices inserted from it here and there!
Secondly, it is as the title: A tale by the hobbit, the movie is almost done thru his eyes (except for the spinoff stories).
Another honorable mention are the flashbacks (Andreas signature mark as I say). LOVED THEM! And during the singing of “Far over the Misty Mountains Cold”…you just have to watch the edit! ❤️
The pacing is greatly done for one movie structure, and the only thing I could recommend if there ever is ever a re-revision, is to extend a bit from the third movie. The story just felt very rushed at the end.

Thanks for the great work!
As always, Keep it UP! ❤️

Hello Andreas!

Since I haven’t watched the new revisited editions of the movies, I would very much like to see them, especially with the closing of the winter holidays! Unfortunately the folder of the previous editions also disappeared from the links and would appreciate a PM please!

With best regards! ❤️

The new opening is very exciting! Edit of the dream is done great, would only prefer some more SFX on the cuts, to add more of a “frightening” effect.

As Jimmy said, the color grade varies a bit in some shots. The one zooming from the clouds to the Burrow, may be for “dark movie effect”, but fills a bit “strangely pushed” from my eyes. Maybe try and to slow the darkening?

Looking forward for more!

Anjohan said:

Oh,

and here’s the updated and working Train to Hogwarts sequence:

https://streamable.com/jse6n9

Looks pretty nice! Would suggest to increase the train shots duration a bit (if footage allows it).

Looking forward for more previews and the whole edits as well!

The entry looks way better paced without all the actors choreography! Thou I do prefer a bit more music in their entry (or I am just used to the original scene).

The “Train to Hogwarts” link sadly does not work. Would love to see that as well!

Jimmy Chips said:

I like the sound of everything you’re planning for GOF!

+1 from me!
Especially from what is read in “other updates and implemented cchanges”!!!
The new train to Hogwarts scene sounds AMAZING to bring that atmosphere!

Looking forward into watching the newest releases!

Anjohan said:

I always recommend watching the new ultimate editions for the first two entries. They are, in my opinion, the superior viewing.

Agreed. The highest of the superior viewing experience of the Harry Potter universe! I think you should send a PM to Chris Columbus also, so we can see his opinion. 😄

Great, great update!

I could’t imagine the Revisited versions to become better, but you have outdone yourself and amazed me with the Ultimate edit! I really enjoyed the first movie so far! The color grading is nicely balanced with all the excess “shining” smoothed. The story is advancing in a good pace also. Bravo!

Already scheduling the second movie for a watch!

Keep it up, Andreas! ❤️

Great, great news!

I am very happy to read that you have made your Ultimate edit on the Potter movies!

As Christmas is coming soon, I am planning to do a marathon with your edits on Harry Potter! As the movies (especially the first few) have an amazing christmas spirit!

I don’t know where the other topic dissapeared but will post my comment here on the Chamber of Secrets, saying that my favourite vesion is the one(the first!?) which emphasize on the possibility that Harry is THE heir of Slytherin. There was the most epic scene which included music from Inception, and the Potter guy started questioning himself at the uttermost! Ahhh, loved that version! On the later edit, seems like that emphasize is left, and you decided to do it in a different way…or so I think. Sadly this edit is nowhere to be found in the older folders.
Would love watching that kind of “mind bubbling is-it-me” stuff in the second movie.

Anyways, keep up the great and everimproving work! ❤️

Whoa, glad to see that it is released! Bravo, Andreas!

Would love a PM!

Ahhhh, this projects looks it has a bright future!

Loved the way you got motivated by your son to finally do it after 4 years! Would love to read his reaction after the movie is done!

The color grading and sound voices are pritty good from the samples you’ve shown!

Keep it up, Andreas! +1 motivation from me! ❤️

A very good and enticing way to listen to the audiobooks and enter into the World of Hogwarts!

Definetly recommend these edits!

Bravo for the work!

Well did watch the new version yesterday with a friend. Second time for me and first for her (first time ever watching The Hobbit generally).

I was very impressed how the pacing went. Very much enjoyed the shortened ‘Riddles in the Dark’ and the way the ending battle was fixated upon the main characters! Plus the ending…OHH, the ending…not gonna spoil that for you folks!
Only one thing was strange enough for me, the transition between some scenes with big cuts. Example - going out of the goblin caves, running suddenly into Beorn’s home (who is chasing them). But I may have took too much from the original movies!? Anyways…

She was also very impressed, compared to the LOTR Movies which we saw together, her review was - ‘It looked very much in style like those movies!’ - Which is a great compliment for the project author Andreas!

Keep up the great work, as always! ❤️

Hello, Master Lawdog.

Theese edits sounds too interesting to be true! I would love a link to have a look (and a hear) at them!

Have you made any video cuts or add-ons so that they could match the book!?

Ah, it is amazing how you go back and reedit your projects 2-3 times, to make the bestest version of them!

Very excited and looking forward to the new updates!

Released!? And GoF 2.0 and more about to be released as well!??

So Excited! Looking forward on watching Deathly Hallows any time soon!
Can’t wait to see what originality you’ve brought to it!

Keep it real! ❤️

Such a great and wonderful edit!

Did watch it for the second time (the first being at its release, 2 years ago) and was very suprised how original it was. Loved how the story with Old Rose is gone, and the movie focuses entirely on the 1912 accident.

A very different approach from the editor on this one compared with his other movies. Definetly was very interesting to watch! And will again in the future!

Keep it up! ❤️

Just saw the trailer for DH…aaand its great! Can’t believe I have missed it!

Love how it sums up all the movies up until the last one. It’s a smart start for a finishing one!

Would love to see more info and clips from the project!

Well…watched it two times already and what can I say…

An amazing edit! It so flawlessly travels throu scenes, combining the three movies with such a great pace.
Althou second time I watched it almost fall asleep in the Riddles in the Dark scene. It seemed longer compared to the time separated for the other scenes. But as we know its an important chapter so maybe there was little to trim from!?

Overall a really great project! A fresh new take on the movies and must watch for every one who thinks of himself as a fan!

New remake of The Hobbit!? Count me in!
I remember seein the early “beta” version you had made and it was very interesting from a plot of view. But for the final release you got me very hyped!

Just last night watched the v2 of Sorcerer’s Stone and Chamber of Secrets. And compared to the v1 of your edits, the reacton was - WOW! 😮

Really the movies do seem more darker even from your first versions. Pace and consistency is significantly improved in both films (mostly in the first).
Score is very well picked, thou I must confess that I miss the “detective-ish” score from Inception in the Chamber of Secrets from v1 and the way you twisted the plot there about Harry and everyone starting to think that he is the heir of (the spoiler)…

Keep it up! Already started to make marathons with your HP edits!

Chase Adams said:

Edit:
Can someone please provide a link to the fanedit.org threads for all of these edits? I can’t find them and I suck at navigating that website! 😄

Sure thing, buddy. 😃

This is the IFDB for the Sorcerer’s Stone:
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/harry-potter-and-the-sorcerer-s-stone-revisited/
And the forum thread for the movie:
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=6599

And this is the IFDB for the Chamber of Secrets:
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/harry-potter-and-the-chamber-of-secrets-revisited/
Plus the forum discussion:
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=11082

Also you can click on the faneditor name on the IFDB pages, to check some of Anjohan’s other edits.

The first version is already too good, and now a v2!? Sounds exciting!

Hard editing on film III when you have to take into concern to shorten the serial from 10h to 3h but It ended with a good storyline.

The use of the serial OST suprised me, it did mix with the new one very thematicly.

This movie was very nicely done! With every movie your skills get better.

As I read the info and update posts it just sounds sooo amazing.

I like the way you find connection in the names of the projects with the actual story plot in them, not just randomly writing some names!

I would mention (again) that it would be lovely to hear some of the original soundtrack by Ramin Djawadi in a place or two, if not in this movie, then in the upcoming one(s).

Keep it UP, Andreas!