aGreatHumanBeing

Yeah, I thought that was the reason. And as I said, it just confused me bit at first, it’s really not a problem to redownload 😃

As English is not me first language, subtitles to fan edits is absolutely marvelous and not something I am spoiled with getting! So thanks again for providing them, both here and on your Rebels recut.

Acbagel said:

Hey all, just wanted to announce that Darthg00b has completed the subtitles for Book 3! Give him a big round of applause

Clap, clap!

Exciting stuff this! I got two questions about the subtitles I hope you don’t mind me asking:

Is there any reason why the subtitles is not in a separated file? No t a big problem really, I just got a little confused before I understood that I had to download the whole movie once more to get subtitles.

I can’t seem to find subtitle versions for movie 1-2. Am I missing something or do they not exist?

Thanks again, to both the editor and the “subtitlor”!

Saw the whole trilogy a few days ago and I have to agree with the latest speakers. To include som clips from the TV-series in Rogue One is truly a great idea to connect the whole thing together. If I was to nitpick, I would place the Bix scene at the very end - maybe even in a post-credit scene (even tough post-credit scenes is not very “Star Warsihy”). Anyway, Rogue One is great stuff.

But yeah, the TV seasons feels a bit rushed when they cut down to movies. It’s a great way to get Cassians story, but I really feel we loose a lot. However, this was the intention of the edits, so salute to the editor who did a great job to achieve his goal.

It would be great tough, if there was a fan edit of the TV shows that gives us much of the extra stuff and still fits well with this version of Rogue One. “Two short seasons and a movie”. Have you considered this, 21C?

Anyway - thank you very much for a fun night with Cassian!

All the members on this site should get a “OK, you were right”-free ticket to a pre-screening of this movie!

…and they should thank us personally when they see the box office and sale numbers afterwards.

Just saw this yesterday. And the King has done it again, folks.

I’ve always liked Rogue One, but watching this edit after Andor turns the whole thing up even a few more notches.

I’ll give this edit a 99.9 score.

0.1 points is deducted because of the missing “Jyn, I’ll be there for you… Cassian said I’d have to”.
So now I’m looking forward to the maximalist version where this is included 😉

Great work, Hal!

Thanks for all your replies, boys and girls! I’m even more excited now! 😃

We just have to get through some Marvel TV-shows and some anime before it’s my turn to decide what to watch 😄

Bored at 3AM said:

I watched the first two movies over the weekend and this is most certainly going to be my go-to versions from now on.

Out of curiosity: I guess you, as me, saw the original show. And hopefully I will be es excited as you when I finally sees this version.

But how you (and others in this thread, please share your thought also) think this edit will be for a first time viewer?

I’ve been planning to introduce my girlfriend to Star Wars in the (hopefully near) future. Will it be better to show her this then the TV show, or should we see the full show first and use these edits for rewatches?

oojason said:

I think it has been discussed somewhere on here mate - though the gist was it is likely a temporary crop for this aspect of the project - or possibly cropped to focus on / examine any potential image issues for the ALI team (or for those they are uploading the images for). It is also worth noting when using any IB Tech print footage it would likely be cropped more tightly before ‘final cut’.

Thanks!

As it is all a WIP (Work In Progress)… many of us simply trust ALI to get this right like they’ve done pretty much everything else so far. 👍

ALI akbar! 😄

oojason said:

NEW SCREENSHOT COMPARISON - AND A NEW VIDEO CLIP - FROM STAR WARS…

 

ALI…

Is ALI cropped differently? On the wall with lights, the lowest rows third light from left is almost completely gone here. UHD and 4K77 on the other hand shows more of this light, and the blu(e) ray even more.

Sorry if this is already discussed.

I can’t seem to seen any pixelation. I (re)downloaded the movies a couple of weeks ago and handbraked them to a smaller filesize.

Hal 9000 said:

Who knows? If rumors hold about the 50th anniversary OOT restoration, I’d be elated to start these three projects over from the beginning!

Clear your schedule for 2027! 😄

Onne said:

I would love to see “Definitive Editions” where all the problematic changes are reversed. Obviously, this brings a problem : what to keep and what to reverse?

To make every fan happy, Disney must release this on the streaming service with a questionnaire that the viewer have to fill out before watching the movie:

Do you prefer
a) Han shoots first
b) Greedo shoots first

Do you prefer
a) Yub Nub
b) Victory celebration

…and 50 questions later the streaming will adjust the movie according to your input! 😄

But to answer more seriously: If they ever was gonna make to a “Definitive Edition”, they should base it on Hals “Custom Special Edition”.

I’m sorry szpoman, but I really have to complain about this audiobook adaptation!

I was listning to the audiobook while driving to and from work this week. I was backing up my car into my garage and was fully focusing on that when I suddenly heard a big BOOM!

Seriously, I freaked out, because I thought a hit something with the car I bought a few weeks ago. I was about to go out and check … and then I heard a new BOOM!

It was then, that I realized that the BOOM was a sound effect from audiobook!

God damn, that gave me a real scare 😃

If my memory serves me right: it was those three, The Acolyte and The Rebel.

But if it’s troublesome to correct I suggest you leave it be. As I said, it was not really a issue understanding what movies that were the same.

A little nitpick:

I like to have my collections in order and I therefore gave each movie a number in front of the movie title. And then I noticed that some movies’ filename in the folder does not match what they are called in the Order.txt.

Really not a big issue. It was not hard to figure out what names belonged to what movie. But as it seems you still work on this project I thought I should mention it.

This is the way!

I guess Disney will also will be releasing this at streaming and physical media.

My respons: SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY!

JoyOfEditing said:

Cheers Y’all! “Director” is the right title for the job

Is your name Krennic? 😃

Oh, I’m sorry. I misunderstood and got it all wrong - I thought it was said that this new episode was supposed to be watched after s2e00(a), and was confused when I could not find an episode with that number.

I know understand that this episode was intented to be episode s2e00. Then everythings makes more sense 😃

My apologies, but English is not my native language.

EddieDean said:

• It’s placed early in season 2. I’d put it at s02e05b, and g00b recommends s02e00 (first episode of season 2).

Hmm, I can’t seem to find episode s2e00 in the spreadsheet? I do however see s2e00b and s2e00c.

Should there be a s2e00(a) or am I misunderstanding something here?

Have you seen this thread?

https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Joel-Schumachers-Batman-Forever-The-Assembly-Cut-/id/137240

I think this is the closest we are to get a Schumacher cut - as long as WB don’t seem to wanna release it.

This seems like a fun adventure! I’m holding of these until all of the movies is releases, and hopefully this can be something I can enjoy leading up to the Christmas holiday 😄

I do however have one question already: how long is these movies? I guess the movie-movies is about he same length as the ones they are based on, but what about the TV-to-movies?

Lokking forward to this edit!

g00b said:

Perhaps something like this:
[…]
Reeling from the death of their
close friend and rebel leader,
Jedi Knight KANAN JARRUS,
the Lothal Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their home planet which
is relentlessly being ravaged
by the Empire.

Much better! But it’s quite a long sentence and when reading it loud (which I like to do, to check how it sounds when reading) I do feel a need for pause.

The easiest fix for this is to just put a comma after “planet”. And then I would move “which” down a line.

Reeling from the death of their
close friend and rebel leader,
Jedi Knight KANAN JARRUS,
the Lothal Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their home planet,
which is relentlessly being
ravaged by the Empire.

Forgive me if this have been discussed before, but i just say everything that pops into my mind 😃

Would it be better to have the (Rebels) episode number in the title?
Something like:

"Rebels

Episode X.X
SECRET OF THE TEMPLE"

(I don’t know if it will fit here, bu I like episodes in Star Wars media!)

Should the Emperor, Pryce and Thrawn be capitalized like KANAN JARRUS?

The end of the second paragraph seem a bit clunky to me, but then again - I’m not a native English-user, so perhaps it is my language skills that is lacking. There will be better words to use than in the following example, but maybe something like this?

"the Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their beloved home world
Lothal, that is relentlessly
shattered by the Empire .

g00b said:
I’ve added this to the spreadsheet for those who like a chronological watch!

Absolutely glorious! Thank, g00b!

(And if anybody else is using a little laptop and wondering where this information is: scroll to the right, my friend 😄)