Tree Dude

BmB said:

And no, I didn't consider that I might be wrong. Because I can't be. There's nothing up to interpretation in the scene, it's fairly clear cut and fits well within the extremely loosely defined space physics of Star Wars. You just keep telling me I'm wrong even when I told you how I think I'm not and you are, instead of defending your position with counter examples. I'm looking for one of two outcomes here; either you come to see the error of your ways, or you show me how your version makes sense and adds to the movie. Neither is happening right now because you are being extremely defensive.

Ady clearly stated his reasoning and most everyone agrees with it but you. You are very stubborn and the fact that you are continuing this debate when everyone else has asked for you to stop only shows how wrong you are.

Maybe it is time for a moderator to step in and end this.

I didn't think one x-wing was a big deal. It actually always bothered me that no one gets shot down in that scene.  To each their own though.

I didn't care for the lightsabery needle in ANH, but no big deal considering how awesome everything else was.

Just watched this over the weekend with my wife. We were both very impressed. It is going on my DVD shelf and the 2004 DVDs are getting packed away. I can't even imagine watching them again.

We are eagerly awaiting your ESB release. Keep up the wonderful work and may the force be with you!