logo Sign In

TheFourthHorseman

User Group
Members
Join date
22-Sep-2015
Last activity
21-Oct-2015
Posts
28

Post History

Post
#792140
Topic
What can Disney do to improve the nuEU?
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

Fire whoever's been giving the shitty new comics and novels the stamp of approval and replace them with someone who'll actually say a great big "NO!" to schlock stories.

Abandon the stupid concept of "canon" once and for all and let the writers write whatever stories they may in whatever continuity they wish (be it a previously established continuity or their own personal continuity).

Cancel all the ongoing Star Wars comic series and replace them with a single SW series -- an anthology series containing multiple stories per issue focused on a wide variety of characters from various timeframes. 

Publish fewer novels.

That's it -- that's all it would take to improve the nuEU for me.

 I'd have to agree with you there. Forcing every story to fit into a single continuity was a large part of what made things so hard for me to follow. Give fans a choice of whatever writer's continuity they like more. Star Wars is big enough for this to work.

Also I'd like to see less retcons. Hundreds of those spilling into each other didn't help with my confusion.

Post
#791781
Topic
When did you realize the Prequels sucked?
Time

Longer than most. I'm 31 years old today so you can do the math. I was fairly young when episode I was released. I remember liking the lightsaber fight while the plot went mostly over my head. Same with Episode II.

My thought process was changing by the time ROTS launched. But largely I realized the prequels sucked in hindsight.

Post
#791420
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

It's worse. Atris fell to the dark side at some point without admitting it to herself. So the Jedi are more or less following the code of a traitor.

And none of the exile's students thought that might be worth considering while they were busy rebuilding the order. No future Jedi did either apparently.

I guess it's good to have someone to blame for the PT Jedi.

It's also stupid because of how utterly contrived it is.

Post
#791372
Topic
The Marvel Cinematic Universe
Time

FanFiltration said:

I thought I was going to tire of all the over saturation as well, but yet I find myself excited that Agents of SHIELD is returning for series three tonight.

 I'm glad you're still enjoying things.

I'm currently waiting to see what kind of debacle the Batman/Superman movie turns into as DC stumbles towards a fast tracked Justice League movie.

Post
#790938
Topic
Knights of the Old Republic 1 vs 2. Which do you like more?
Time

The problem is clarity. It's implied that her plan might have worked if she killed herself at Malachor V. Why she doesn't is anyone's guess. The force bond isn't lethal. She died and Meetra was fine. Why was unclear.

She also knew Mira would be there when the time came and had the evil wookie bounty hunter waiting to hold her back from catching up with Meetra. Problem is that the Exile doesn't seem to know Mira is even there. The two never meet up. It's unclear how Mira even gets off Malachor since the Ebon Hawke is taken by the Exile.

Did she return to the ship? Did Meetra track her down before leaving? Hell in one cutscene we see the ship falling into the planet's core. How did we get it back? How many other party members are here?

Nothing is clear. Everything is hazy and open to interpretation. That isn't a strength in this case.