TheDimitrios

I honestly love that idea.

Having Krennic recruiting Galen as a cold opening of the first Andor episode, with an “X years later” before jumping to Andor could work very well. Jynn would kinda work as a bookend then. Not in a way that a normal TV show would do it, but for a fan edit I can see it working fine.

Having Saw capture Bodhi in the last Andor episode could improve the pacing of Rogue One actually. It makes sense to have in the last Andor episode, because it puts into place all the dominos for Rogue One and Rogue one itself can get going a bit faster.

Having Bix at the end of R1 could work very well, if a bit on the nose. Going from Leias “Hope” to Bix does have some potential.

I think crossing over the Tivik stuff into R1 is probably a bit too far. I don’t see it working out pacing wise.

These plans sound legit great!

They hinted at big plans for Ventress. That can either be an adaptation of Dark Disciple down the line, or maybe something in the Maul series, or Ahsoka, or something completely different. But it does not end with the Tales show, I am pretty sure.

Personally, I think it would be odd to create the new Quinlan model for just one scene and I am skeptical that they would create that whole sequence on Dathomir just to keep continuity with a book, when they are happy to retcon printed media in other cases.

So my money is on an Adaptation of Dark Disciple in some form. That’s why I would wait just a little bit with a project like this.

I honestly think some minimal crossover hereight just work.

The Ronin Black and White version is quite nice. The lack of color and top layer grain hides a lot of little imperfections in the sets and effects that pulled me out of the show originally. Pacing is quite fast and very cool solution for the lightsaber color change scene.

Watching Book 5 and it flows pretty well so far. Small nitpick: At 52:30 it cuts from the head of the droid to Mando’s head, with both being in exactly the same place. That transition is a bit rocky.

Personally, I thought the design was close enough. The Inquisitors in Kenobi were in desperate need of fixing, some people did not even recognize the Grand Inquisitor, so that was work well spent for Trials of the Master. Investing big amounts of time to make Bane look 10% better is not worth it imo.

One thing just came to me: Will the scene of Grogu seeing the space whales be in there? It is just so damn beautiful. ❤️

With the Maul show and Ventress’ Tales story taking place in the same timeframe, it seems like they are not quite done with this part of the timeline. Fingers crossed.

Sadly it will not be the canned Clone Wars Arc.

It is a super fun watch. Can recommend.

This does look indeed amazing!

Thanks for all your hard work!

This does look amazing

I have just stumbled over this guy, some stuff might be worthy of inclusion in some fan edits
https://youtu.be/s8MD6shUMtA?si=evG3WSPIrF57rPQU

Just jumping in to say that your work is highly appreciated.

The gif has Obi Wan and the whole landscape outside shifting, while the inside of the cave stays static.
I assume there is just a png of the inside with a transparent cutout on the top layer.

I also pitched in. All the best wishes.

Flows pretty well, considering the original footage. Maybe someone has an idea to get rid of the planet core mentioning? Making it just a secret passage into the city?

DZ-330 said:

Hoping the new versions of Episode I will also remove the force run scene …

I second this

So elegant. I love it.

Rebels 1 Feedback:
It works better than I thought as a single movie. A few little things caught my attention:

An Audio transition when Ezra is on roof right in the beginning is a bit rough

Ezras first Hyperspace jump could get a second or two more to breath.

When Ezra meets his contact with the Empire, his fake name is a strong hint that material was cut. Getting rid of that would make it feel more smooth.

When Kanan decides to actually train Ezra you could go directly into the jedi temple journey. The lightsaber practice feels distinctly end of episode like.

When the crew escapes into the sewers they are suddenly split up without explanation. That feels weird.

Beil Organa mentioning a previous meeting with Kanan makes the missing content more obvious. Maybe it is possible to cut around that?

Really really good job though. Condensing this whole season into a movie is impressive.

Rebels 1 Feedback:
It works better than I thought as a single movie. A few little things caught my attention:

An Audio transition when Ezra is on roof right in the beginning is a bit rough

Ezras first Hyperspace jump could get a second or two more to breath.

When Ezra meets his contact with the Empire, his fake name is a strong hint that material was cut. Getting rid of that would make it feel more smooth.

When Kanan decides to actually train Ezra you could go directly into the jedi temple journey. The lightsaber practice feels distinctly end of episode like.

When the crew escapes into the sewers they are suddenly split up without explanation. That feels weird.

Beil Organa mentioning a previous meeting with Kanan makes the missing content more obvious. Maybe it is possible to cut around that?

Really really good job though. Condensing this whole season into a movie is impressive.

NM

It would be great to have the Padme Funeral scene from Totj in the last episode!

Big fan of a lot of your stuff. Personally, I am not a big fan of just adding scenes so characters have screen time. It was my biggest problem with BB2 that those Phee and Batch scenes in the first half felt so disjointed/disconnected.