logo Sign In

TWINIONENGINE

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
2-Feb-2018
Last activity
2-Feb-2018
Posts
4

Post History

Post
#1166709
Topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Time

Mrebo said:

yotsuya said:

NeverarGreat said:

joefavs said:

DominicCobb said:

On the one hand, maybe it drains remote suns just like how it destroys remote planets. But in that case, why does it drain its own sun? On the other hand, maybe it does move around to new suns, but in that case why doesn’t it completely drain the first sun it orbits like it does the second (Hux’s speech is in daylight)? To me it doesn’t matter much either way.

I honestly never thought it was two different stars. I just figured the star that they drained to destroy the Hosnian system was large enough that they were able to get two charges out of it.

But Finn claims that the weapon draws power from the sun until it disappears, implying that once the draining starts, it will not stop until the star is destroyed. Poe repeats this during their attack.

Stop and think for a moment. Using up two stars does not mean it had to move. It is possible that they found the ideal system with multiple stars to use with this weapons. They probably destroyed the smallest star first and from a larger one they might get several charges out of it. There is a big difference between Sol and Sirius. A star that might give one charge could be the companion of a star that can give sixty. And I never got the impression that the first star was destroyed as Starkiller base never went dark which it would if the sun was sucked dry. Sometimes science can be the friend of wild SF storytelling.

SW wiki says it moves by use of rocket ports. Even if in the same system that must take a long time. We might as well pretend it can move through hyperspace.

head canon

Post
#1166699
Topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Time

A sock puppet is when you’ve created a secondary avatar to interact with yourself secretly. That’s not what I’m doing…

I’ve needed to open a second account, because when the first one was banned I have no ability to message moderators or appeal anything. It forces you to create another account. I would not think to email someone based on a message board. I’d PM them, and will now.

I’m not sure what a “temp ban” is. My first account was “permanently banned” as far as I can tell (with no messages, no warnings, no temp bans). I would just use that one to make an appeal to a mod if I could log in…

Post
#1166688
Topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Time

Sorry, but being banned for the above is not fair.

I’m not trolling. I’m not trying to “wind people up”. I’m just posting about star wars.

The only thing I’ve done is posted my reactions after watching this movie. I was critical of the movie, yes. But my take is very in line with what many other people in this forum are posting.

Forum rules:

http://originaltrilogy.com/announcement/Updated-OTcom-Forum-Rules-and-Guidelines-Applies-to-all-forums-including-Off-Topic/id/52717

Breaking any of these rules will result in a warning, followed by any number of temporary bans at any arbitrary length as determined by the moderators. Excessive rule-breaking will eventually result in a permanent ban.

I received no warnings of any kind, either privately or via posts in this topic.

I also received no temporary ban. Just an unexpected ban after I posted a critical take of the movie.

I had no idea I was in danger of being banned.

Breaking the following rules may result in an immediate and permanent ban with no prior warning: [harassment, personal attacks, slurs, socks]

I did absolutely nothing to harass members, or personal attacks, or slurs.

I only opened a second account so I could post about a star wars movie. I would have used my main account, had it not been banned. If I had any way to contest the ban, or come back after a temporary ban, I would have just done that rather than create a new account. This is not “sock puppetry”.

Again, I’m not trolling. I’m just posting my thoughts after watching a movie.

I would like to keep doing that occasionally, without immediately being banned. My posts above are not deserving of a ban.

If there is some particular thing I have said that is worthy of a ban on these forums, please let me know via a warning or a temporary ban. I’ll adjust accordingly as I quite like this thread and reading the takes of other poster. I’d ask that my first avatar KILLOFFPOE please be unbanned.