logo Sign In

Shopping Maul

User Group
Members
Join date
12-Oct-2013
Last activity
9-Nov-2026
Posts
535

Post History

Post
#1694529
Topic
The <strong>random YouTube / Vimeo etc video finds</strong> thread for the Original Trilogy
Time

The blurb: ‘This episode of From the Star Wars Home Video Library focuses upon the 1982 advertising flyer for the initial VHS and Beta releases of ANH.’
 

I just love this flyer by the way - it really captures the essence of 1977 Star Wars before it truly became ‘episode 4’ of a convoluted saga. The idea of a band of misfits taking on the bad guys (not to mention the hint of romance between Luke and Leia) has been so muddied over the years. I really love the innocence of this. Thanks for the post…

Post
#1692878
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

The history of the Star Wars Universe was more interesting before Vader and Anakin Skywalker became the same person. It opened up the idea of a much earlier starting date for the Empire than we got. Maybe the Jedi had already been on the run for a generation before Vader tracked down Anakin in the Outer Rim and killed him?

I agree. As much as I love talking and debating about various aspects of the saga (and I heartily recommend Dagenspear’s TPM and Kenobi rewrites), I’ve pretty much landed on the original Star Wars '77 as my only true head canon. I prefer Darth Vader as just an awesome bad guy who killed lots of Jedi. And Obi Wan never lied.

Post
#1692200
Topic
How would you handle a hard reboot of all nine episodes of Star Wars?
Time

Such an interesting question! I think Star Wars '77 is basically sacred ground, and recreating the magic of that film would be impossible at so many levels (this of course extends to the rest of the saga to varying degrees).

I’d seek to do what Denis Villeneuve has done with Dune. I’m a huge Dune fan, and I really love how Denis has created an kind of ‘alternate Dune’ that deviates significantly from the books (which are sacred a la Star Wars '77) but still absolutely captures the themes and story in a way that honours the original (at least in my opinion).

For example the next Dune film will be an adaptation of the book ‘Dune Messiah’, but as fans we still have very little idea on how this film is going to go. We know the basics - we’ve read the book - but Denis has deviated so far from the text that it’s mostly speculation at this point.

So I think a Star Wars reboot should do the same - have the basic themes of adventure and heroism and family and The Force and the overall story in a broad sense, but create an unpredictable ‘alternate’ version rather than just have better effects and fan-service-driven repetition.

Bit of a nothing answer in terms of detail but you get my drift…

Post
#1691632
Topic
Obi-Wan Kenobi Series Fix
Time

This is great - really enjoyed reading it. While I appreciate what the Kenobi series attempted, I don’t think it really succeeded and I certainly wouldn’t consider it ‘canon’ in relation to the original 6-film saga. This version however does succeed (IMO) in bridging the two trilogies really well and enhancing them rather than merely providing fan service or over-explanations. Very cool!

Post
#1691631
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Obi-Wan-Kenobi-Series-Fix/id/137114

I’d be interested in reading your thoughts if you want to.

Well I finally read your alternate version of the Kenobi show. To be blunt - it was brilliant! Really enjoyed it. It kind of made the same points as the original but in an infinitely less clunky way, and it also tied up many aspects of the saga (the relationships between Obi and Owen, Anakin and Owen, Anakin’s ‘death’ at Vader’s hands, Leia’s ‘memories’ of her mother, Palpatine/Vader/Obi’s perception of Vader and Anakin separate entities etc etc). The Biggs stuff was a nice touch, as was the larger focus on Luke. Oh, and I loved Owen’s ‘navigator on a Spice Freighter’ routine and Luke’s feelings about his dad. Rather than coming across as fan-service or over-explanations, these details flowed very naturally in your version.

To be clear, I enjoyed the Kenobi show for what it was but would never consider it ‘canon’ (assuming my personal canon to be the PT and OT in this instance). I think your version would definitely make for good, valid canon within the 6-movie set. If anyone else in this thread has been following our conversation at all, I absolutely recommend taking the time to give this a read.

To return to the topic at hand, I think this outline provides something of an antidote to any misgivings about the prequels, and demonstrates how such a ‘bridging’ story could elevate the prequel experience and bring it more in line with the OT.

Post
#1691170
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

I think were arguing past each other at this point. To steelman your position (and by all means tell me if I’m misrepresenting you) you’re basically saying that the OT is what it is, love it or hate it, and it’s not the job of the PT to go the extra mile and repair whatever issues I (or others) may have with the OT. Essentially my issue is with the OT, not the PT which is honouring the OT as required.

If this is a fair representation, then you’re right.

That’s about my stance, you’re correct I think.

But I don’t think I’m alone in thinking that the PT could have told a story that makes the cringey elements in the OT resonate better in the context of the 6-episode saga. I think the ‘certain point of view’ still falls flat in the overall context because the PT failed to deliver a convincing character arc/analysis for Anakin/Vader. I think the ‘hidden from the Emperor’ thing still feels silly because the PT failed to make a reasonable case for why Luke was sent to Owen while Leia was sent to a high-profile colleague of the Emperor.

Maybe it could have for you, but I don’t think it’s a solid criticism of the PT that it didn’t do that.

As I said, I think the way the PT functions is at the most straightforward angle that I think makes sense. Leia went with a royal, because he was the only other person who knew who she was and what was going on. Luke went with his family because that was the only other people who were connected to him I think. The Jedi were being hunted.

The Kenobi series is an example of other creators trying to insert the dramatic points that the prequels lacked. I’m not saying that it succeeds, or that it’s even any good, but it illustrates the frustrations many fans have with the PT. That’s why the show seeks to create an actual relationship between Obi Wan and Owen Lars that kind of mirrors what I suggested earlier - that Owen is insistent on Luke being raised as a normal boy and not the Jedi hope of the galaxy. And it also tries to make the ‘Vader spiritually murdered his former self’ more overt in a way that makes Obi Wan’s lies in the OT seem less jarring. Again, I’m not saying it succeeds, but it’s illustrative of a common viewpoint regarding the PT.

I don’t know what you’re referring to in regards to the Kenobi series adding anything to the OT or PT. Obi and Owen are never developed to have much of a relationship in the OT. Moreso that Owen doesn’t want Obi involved in Luke’s life, I don’t think we need them to have a relationship for that overall really. But also I don’t think it’d add a lot to the overall story to have, as Owen dies fairly early and is never brought up again in the OT, so too much else about him I think would be a structural lacking to me. I said before I think Owen’s use in the PT leaves a bit to be desired, in some way, but moreso in his connection to Anakin. That and Obi-Wan’s lie I can see as a legit criticism, as I think there is simply no reason based in Obi’s character that I think he’d have to lie about that (though I think there’s a potential handwave for it, but that’s me doing the movies job for it, in the idea that Owen’s views are simply retroactive, as Kenobi plays it seemingly). I posted a TPM outline redo here that does some work at refining that aspect to me, in giving Obi’s words about Owen some actual basis, I’d like to read your thoughts on it:

https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/The-Phantom-Menace-Outline-REWRITE/id/142856

Well essentially you’re doing a similar thing in your rewrite to what I’m suggesting in this thread. Your rewrite of TPM (which was a fun read - thank you) strengthens the ties between Anakin and Owen, strengthens the relationship between Padme and Anakin (particularly by simply adjusting Anakin’s age which is a huge help), strengthens the narrative with Bail Organa etc etc. We’re basically coming from the same place as fans in terms of wanting more out of the PT than it’s delivering - we just diverge on the details. And the Kenobi show was trying to do the same - strengthen the relationships and attempt to make the retcons in the OT cohere more effectively.

I did get a little lost in the politics of your version - which echoes how folks tend to feel about TPM generally, but of course that would eventually come down to how that aspect is presented in an actual movie. Star Wars '77 was politics-heavy too - as a kid I had no idea about consular ships or regional governors with dwindling bureaucracies etc etc - but the ‘good guys/bad guys fun adventure’ side was so well placed in the fore that it never mattered. TPM suffered from a lack of that balance I think, so it would come down to how it’s all articulated in the final product. But that said I really enjoyed your take.

Like I said about trying to give him some form of outside justification, I think leans into, to me, dismissing responsibility away from the character of Obi and his lie, strips him of flaws as a human being, and agency in his perception as a character. I have no real issue with a story of Obi taking time to come to the perception, with more exploration, that Anakin killed that version of himself, but the Kenobi show, and some version where he makes a promise to Padme, I think more takes away from his character in what it does, tries to make him all pure and nice, instead of the complex human being who’d hide from one of his most painful moments fully of his volition, while for the Padme promise thing to me oddly throws onto him kinda unnatural flaws that the OT would never deal with I think (as I said before, him promising Padme he wouldn’t tell Luke about his dad, I think it kinda makes Obi like he’s mistreating the promise he made to her by using it to get Luke to kill Vader).

I get what you’re saying (I think) but I guess I’ll just never be convinced by the lie and its resolution in RoTJ. If the OT had been written with Luke’s parentage intact from the get-go, there’s no way Obi Wan would have done the ‘betrayed and murdered’ thing (nor would Leia be making out with Luke!). Like I said earlier, it’s actually crueler (towards Luke) than the truth (“your father joined the Empire”). My ‘vow to Padme’ thing doesn’t negate Obi’s ‘point of view’. I’m just suggesting that he share this notion with Luke’s mother and that a combination of their shared belief and Padme’s determination that Luke and Leia never hear the truth be the motivator for the overtness of Kenobi’s lie. Yes, it’s making Obi Wan appear more noble, but why not? He still takes responsibility in RoTJ (just as he takes responsibility for training Anakin despite the Qui Gon connection) but the whole thing becomes deeper and more complex (IMO).

In fact, as I write this reply, it occurs to me that maybe the ‘certain point of view’ would be even better as Padme’s expressed viewpoint alone. Having a dramatic death scene where she makes Obi Wan swear to the ‘Vader killed Anakin’ narrative for the sake of the children (without him necessarily agreeing with her perspective overtly in that moment) could be really cool. That way he’s merely honouring her wishes and any agreement he has with her perspective is implied in RoTJ without him throwing Padme under the bus.

For a variation of this, I posted a Kenobi series outline redo here as well, I’d also like to read your thoughts on, but it’s more of a read, so I’d understand if you wouldn’t wanna go through it:

https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Obi-Wan-Kenobi-Series-Fix/id/137114

Thanks, I’ll free up some time!

Post
#1691051
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

Because, to my mind, the PT was (or should have been) an opportunity to make the clunky story decisions in the OT actually have dramatic weight and an added sense of logic. When Obi Wan says “what I told you was true, from a certain point of view”, it still feels as ridiculous as it did in 1983.

But why should it be those movies job to do this? Instead of what you want it to do?

At the end of the day, the way the twins were supposedly ‘hidden’ does not make a lick of sense. You don’t hide the future ‘only hope for the galaxy’ at his uncle’s house (30 ft away from Grandma’s grave no less)! You don’t hide the other ‘only hope for the galaxy’ in the office next-door to The Emperor! It’s absurd. I can’t help with the Leia nonsense, but at least with Luke we have the potential for a complex emotional situation regarding Owen that could logically justify this less than ideal hiding place.

That was the OT as well that made that choice (without the grandma thing though).

How does it make sense for the character of Owen, what you said before? And how does your pitch explain why the Jedi would leave Luke with Owen? Or Obi telling Luke that Vader killed his dad?

But also… I don’t get this. The PT the most straightforward reasoning I think they could given the situation:

The Jedi are being hunted, and so keeping the kids with them wouldn’t assist them.

And keeping them apart I think ensures that even if one is found the other could be out there.

And I think putting them with people they think they can trust to look after the kid makes sense, so one goes to his family, the other to the only other trustworthy, to them, person they know who knows about who the kids are, and he chooses the girl because he’d wanted to adopt a girl.

And Obi left Anakin for dead, so the only person who would go there for any reason Obi I think has reason to think is dead by that point.

You’re right, it doesn’t work. I’d forgotten that Obi Wan said both twins would automatically be a threat to the Emperor.

Again, I believe the PT could (and should) have cleaned up the mess made by the OT and created a better, logical, dramatic story.

Why is this the PT’s job to fix the mess of the OT movies? Why criticize the PT movies for doing that? Especially considering people I think have also ragged on the PT for diverting too far from the OT? Do you criticize the OT movies for these things to this point?

I think were arguing past each other at this point. To steelman your position (and by all means tell me if I’m misrepresenting you) you’re basically saying that the OT is what it is, love it or hate it, and it’s not the job of the PT to go the extra mile and repair whatever issues I (or others) may have with the OT. Essentially my issue is with the OT, not the PT which is honouring the OT as required.

If this is a fair representation, then you’re right. But I don’t think I’m alone in thinking that the PT could have told a story that makes the cringey elements in the OT resonate better in the context of the 6-episode saga. I think the ‘certain point of view’ still falls flat in the overall context because the PT failed to deliver a convincing character arc/analysis for Anakin/Vader. I think the ‘hidden from the Emperor’ thing still feels silly because the PT failed to make a reasonable case for why Luke was sent to Owen while Leia was sent to a high-profile colleague of the Emperor.

The Kenobi series is an example of other creators trying to insert the dramatic points that the prequels lacked. I’m not saying that it succeeds, or that it’s even any good, but it illustrates the frustrations many fans have with the PT. That’s why the show seeks to create an actual relationship between Obi Wan and Owen Lars that kind of mirrors what I suggested earlier - that Owen is insistent on Luke being raised as a normal boy and not the Jedi hope of the galaxy. And it also tries to make the ‘Vader spiritually murdered his former self’ more overt in a way that makes Obi Wan’s lies in the OT seem less jarring. Again, I’m not saying it succeeds, but it’s illustrative of a common viewpoint regarding the PT.

That said, all of your points have given me something to think about and I appreciate the back and forth.

Post
#1691020
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

You’re right in the sense that I think the prequels should have ‘fixed’ the flaws in RoTJ. For those who feel that RoTJ is great, then I guess the prequels are fine just reiterating the points made by RoTJ in more detail.

For me RoTJ makes some pretty outrageous claims and, even worse, betrays the obvious fact that Lucas was making this thing up on the fly. Granted, this is because George thought it would be epic to have Vader claim to be Luke’s father, as well as float the notion that Luke had a rival in the hero-stakes. All well and good but he had absolutely no follow-up in mind when he dropped these bombs. So what we got was “uh, well, from a certain point of view” and “surprise! Leia’s your sister” - both claims being entirely incongruent with the previous films and even blatantly contradicting them (not to mention the claim that the twins were ‘hidden’ in the most ridiculous way).

So yes, to return to crux of the thread, I did want the prequels to explain why Obi Wan felt compelled to lie so blatantly to Luke. The actual truth would have been less traumatic - “your Uncle, to his credit, did not want you to know this but your father became an Imperial agent. I’m sorry Luke”. Done! Luke says “no, I can’t believe that!” and Obi says “come with me to Alderaan, the royal family will explain it all to you”. How is “he was betrayed and murdered” - a blatant lie - more helpful than what I just outlined? Of course this is all because Vader was just a bad dude who killed the Jedi and was never Luke’s dad in the first place.

But why is this the fault of the PT that I think it kept in alignment with what the OT had said on these things?

Because, to my mind, the PT was (or should have been) an opportunity to make the clunky story decisions in the OT actually have dramatic weight and an added sense of logic. When Obi Wan says “what I told you was true, from a certain point of view”, it still feels as ridiculous as it did in 1983.

I wanted the prequels to explain why Luke still had his father’s surname while he was ‘hidden’ on the family farm. Or why Yoda thought Leia was next in line for the hero-job when he’d just whined about Luke being too old for training. All of this could have been resolved easily. Owen Lars could have been stubborn in his refusal to hide from Vader and insisted on Luke keeping the family name out of reverence for his former brother (hence a vigilant Obi Wan residing nearby). The Jedi could have been depicted as a boys’ club that refused to train women, with Yoda being the lone progressive voice of dissent - hence Leia coming up as a late option in TESB. And yes, Obi Wan could have been bound by a shared vow with Luke’s mother to push the ‘murdered by Vader’ narrative for the benefit of the kids.

Luke never uses the name Skywalker on tatooine in A New Hope as far as I think we see, that I remember, only ever referring to himself as Luke Skywalker when he’s on the death star rescuing Leia, after he’s met and connected with Obi, whose told him things about his dad.

In regards to things the PT actually explains: First of all, the idea that Owen would be too stubborn to hide from Vader I think runs entirely counter to his main character trait in the ANH, which is not wanting Luke involved in Obi-Wan’s situation. But also, Owen’s moisture farm is developed in the PT as having very nearly no connection to Anakin at all, so it’s no family farm of his.

At the end of the day, the way the twins were supposedly ‘hidden’ does not make a lick of sense. You don’t hide the future ‘only hope for the galaxy’ at his uncle’s house (30 ft away from Grandma’s grave no less)! You don’t hide the other ‘only hope for the galaxy’ in the office next-door to The Emperor! It’s absurd. I can’t help with the Leia nonsense, but at least with Luke we have the potential for a complex emotional situation regarding Owen that could logically justify this less than ideal hiding place.

As for Leia, I think the movie already has Yoda as willing to train Luke, so if he’s willing to for him, why not Leia? Leia isn’t a first option, I think by the mechanics of the story. Obi died before getting to her, he never had a chance to train her in any way. Where is the real contradiction in Yoda’s suggestion if they think Luke may be on the path of destruction? Why does making them a boys club make them better written here?

You’re right, it doesn’t work. I’d forgotten that Obi Wan said both twins would automatically be a threat to the Emperor.

I’m not saying these are the greatest ideas on earth by any stretch. I just personally wish the writing had striven for consistency rather than floating all these vague notions that we, as the audience, have to then twist and turn in our minds to make them cohere.

Why is this a criticism of the PT?

Again, I believe the PT could (and should) have cleaned up the mess made by the OT and created a better, logical, dramatic story.

Post
#1690713
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

You’re absolutely right - after making my point about prequel Anakin being ‘Conan’, I was referencing the ‘certain point of view’ in RoTJ. So yeah, I am technically off-topic in that regard.

That said, I still think the ‘promise to Padme’ thing would be an improvement with RoTJ as is.

In RoTJ Obi Wan says “I took it upon myself to train him as a Jedi”. We now know that Qui Gon made him promise to do so, but Obi Wan keeps that detail to himself and doesn’t whine about this additional fact - taking the responsibility himself. Which is noble. Similarly, had he vowed to Padme that he would not tell the truth to the kids, his vague explanation in RoTJ would come across the same way. He’d be taking all the responsibility in the context of that conversation, but we would all know that it was much more complicated. There would be a dramatic scene in RoTS where Padme expresses that Anakin is dead, Vader is a separate entity as far as she’s concerned, and that she wants Obi Wan to never tell her kids the awful truth. Obi Wan would express that he agrees with her perspective, Anakin is indeed ‘dead’, and vows to honour her wishes regarding the children.

Again, this makes his lie in '77 much more plausible. He’s expressing his ‘certain point of view’ but with the added weight of his vow to Padme. And again, this also justifies his being tight-lipped about the truth when Luke jets off for Bespin. By that stage he would arguably be inclined to spill the beans right? But his vow remains.

I just think this would make all the ‘point of view’ stuff - which very few folks find convincing - much more plausible and indeed rather poignant.

But again, I think that’s closer to expecting ROTS to fix what the OT established.

Again, I don’t see too much of a difference here. Not only do I think that doesn’t connect to Luke, as Padme’s pursuit of the idea that Anakin is still capable of changing back I think is reflected in Luke more personally (Padme and Luke to me have an engaging, yet tragic, comparison in ways), to me, in ROTJ, but also I’m not sure I buy that someone like her may view it in those terms of someone being dead because they turned evil, and I don’t think it makes it more honoring of her or sensible that Obi chooses instead to tell Luke that Vader killed his dad. If anything, I think that kinda makes it look, to me, like he’s kinda twisting Padme’s dying wish to get what he wants. I don’t think that makes him look better and kinda leaves his twisting of Padme’s wish just untouched.

You’re right in the sense that I think the prequels should have ‘fixed’ the flaws in RoTJ. For those who feel that RoTJ is great, then I guess the prequels are fine just reiterating the points made by RoTJ in more detail.

For me RoTJ makes some pretty outrageous claims and, even worse, betrays the obvious fact that Lucas was making this thing up on the fly. Granted, this is because George thought it would be epic to have Vader claim to be Luke’s father, as well as float the notion that Luke had a rival in the hero-stakes. All well and good but he had absolutely no follow-up in mind when he dropped these bombs. So what we got was “uh, well, from a certain point of view” and “surprise! Leia’s your sister” - both claims being entirely incongruent with the previous films and even blatantly contradicting them (not to mention the claim that the twins were ‘hidden’ in the most ridiculous way).

So yes, to return to crux of the thread, I did want the prequels to explain why Obi Wan felt compelled to lie so blatantly to Luke. The actual truth would have been less traumatic - “your Uncle, to his credit, did not want you to know this but your father became an Imperial agent. I’m sorry Luke”. Done! Luke says “no, I can’t believe that!” and Obi says “come with me to Alderaan, the royal family will explain it all to you”. How is “he was betrayed and murdered” - a blatant lie - more helpful than what I just outlined? Of course this is all because Vader was just a bad dude who killed the Jedi and was never Luke’s dad in the first place.

I wanted the prequels to explain why Luke still had his father’s surname while he was ‘hidden’ on the family farm. Or why Yoda thought Leia was next in line for the hero-job when he’d just whined about Luke being too old for training. All of this could have been resolved easily. Owen Lars could have been stubborn in his refusal to hide from Vader and insisted on Luke keeping the family name out of reverence for his former brother (hence a vigilant Obi Wan residing nearby). The Jedi could have been depicted as a boys’ club that refused to train women, with Yoda being the lone progressive voice of dissent - hence Leia coming up as a late option in TESB. And yes, Obi Wan could have been bound by a shared vow with Luke’s mother to push the ‘murdered by Vader’ narrative for the benefit of the kids.

I’m not saying these are the greatest ideas on earth by any stretch. I just personally wish the writing had striven for consistency rather than floating all these vague notions that we, as the audience, have to then twist and turn in our minds to make them cohere.

Post
#1690671
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

Yes, but Yoda’s “consumed by Vader” line is just an attempt to square the round hole established by the OT. It still doesn’t justify “he betrayed and murdered your father”. Obi Wan simply wouldn’t say that. He would say something like “the Jedi were all destroyed by the Empire - your father along with them” or something similar, leaving room for the full truth somewhere down the line. And it still doesn’t account for Obi Wan and Yoda allowing Luke to fly off to Bespin where, obviously, Vader is going to reveal the truth.

As opposed to “he promised Padme”?

Your issue here may be with ROTJ I think, the movie that threw around the perceived handwavey line. ROTS is more taking what was given in that movie I think and just laying out the view of it. I think you seem, to me, maybe, to want ROTS to fix ROTJ’s handwave. How does your pitch fix that idea of how Obi would never say that Vader killed Anakin? How does him promising Padme fix that?

With the ‘promise to Padme’ scenario, you could still have the ‘certain point of view’ intact, but it would also account for the extent of Obi Wan’s lie in 1977, as well as accounting for the Bespin situation.

How does it do that? “Oh I know I told you that Vader killed your dad, but I promised your mom that I wouldn’t tell you your dad is evil so I told you instead that Vader killed your dad”. Where does that thought process come from? Why would he do that? Again, I think your complaint may more be with another movie that, to me, you seem to want the PT to fix, TESB where Obi and Yoda would naturally know who Vader is I think yet they both never tell Luke, even as he’s going off to face him, and when confronted with this in ROTJ, Yoda says it was unexpected, if I remember correctly, that Vader told him. ROTS is going with what the OT said in this case I think. Obi never mentions Luke’s mom or that he made a promise. He goes entirely with the certain point of view thing. ROTS goes with that I think.

You’re absolutely right - after making my point about prequel Anakin being ‘Conan’, I was referencing the ‘certain point of view’ in RoTJ. So yeah, I am technically off-topic in that regard.

That said, I still think the ‘promise to Padme’ thing would be an improvement with RoTJ as is.

In RoTJ Obi Wan says “I took it upon myself to train him as a Jedi”. We now know that Qui Gon made him promise to do so, but Obi Wan keeps that detail to himself and doesn’t whine about this additional fact - taking the responsibility himself. Which is noble. Similarly, had he vowed to Padme that he would not tell the truth to the kids, his vague explanation in RoTJ would come across the same way. He’d be taking all the responsibility in the context of that conversation, but we would all know that it was much more complicated. There would be a dramatic scene in RoTS where Padme expresses that Anakin is dead, Vader is a separate entity as far as she’s concerned, and that she wants Obi Wan to never tell her kids the awful truth. Obi Wan would express that he agrees with her perspective, Anakin is indeed ‘dead’, and vows to honour her wishes regarding the children.

Again, this makes his lie in '77 much more plausible. He’s expressing his ‘certain point of view’ but with the added weight of his vow to Padme. And again, this also justifies his being tight-lipped about the truth when Luke jets off for Bespin. By that stage he would arguably be inclined to spill the beans right? But his vow remains.

I just think this would make all the ‘point of view’ stuff - which very few folks find convincing - much more plausible and indeed rather poignant.

Post
#1690453
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

I also think giving Obi’s reason to never reveal it as a promise is trying too hard to shade away the ambiguity of his choice. “No, look, he had to lie, he made a promise, he’s still a completely great guy with no specific flaws!” Stuff like this is one of the reasons I’m not into what they did in the Kenobi show with that where Anakin just goes, “You didn’t kill Anakin, I did,” and Obi just kinda shrugs and goes along with it with a “whatever you say”. I seems to me to make it look like somehow Yoda’s line in ROTS, “The boy you trained gone he is, consumed by Darth Vader,” wasn’t overt enough in seeding an idea for Obi’s view on Anakin.

Yes, but Yoda’s “consumed by Vader” line is just an attempt to square the round hole established by the OT. It still doesn’t justify “he betrayed and murdered your father”. Obi Wan simply wouldn’t say that. He would say something like “the Jedi were all destroyed by the Empire - your father along with them” or something similar, leaving room for the full truth somewhere down the line. And it still doesn’t account for Obi Wan and Yoda allowing Luke to fly off to Bespin where, obviously, Vader is going to reveal the truth.

With the ‘promise to Padme’ scenario, you could still have the ‘certain point of view’ intact, but it would also account for the extent of Obi Wan’s lie in 1977, as well as accounting for the Bespin situation.

Post
#1690394
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

I said this a while back but I think the saga simply does not deliver when it comes addressing the disparity between the noble father/friend described in Star Wars '77 and Vader’s claim/revelation in Empire. The ‘certain point of view’ is lame, and the prequels fail to build a narrative that makes genuine sense of it all.

I maintain that Anakin should have been a true slave (not a suburban ‘yippee, hanging out and racing go-carts’ ordinary kid) with an underlying desire for some kind of revenge for his plight. This would account for him being a great guy and a ‘good friend’ etc but he would still have had a chip on his shoulder that would logically manifest as something the Jedi could never condone. I also think the Jedi (and by extension Obi Wan) should have cheated him of his vengeance in some way, which would account for his resenting the Jedi and making an ideological shift, especially with the presence of Palpatine urging him on.

I also think Obi Wan’s ‘certain point of view’ in RoTJ should have instead been “I made a promise to your mother that I would never reveal the truth”. This would be fleshed out in the prequels as something of a sacred vow, which would make Obi Wan less of a liar and also account for why Obi Wan and Yoda didn’t tell Luke the truth before he left for Bespin.

Post
#1689512
Topic
What would a remake of the OT look like if it was made by someone who had only ever seen the PT and ST?
Time

I imagine it would be much the same but with the twists and contradictions taken out. Luke would be Luke Lars (because he’s in hiding) until finally taking the Skywalker name at some dramatic point, and Obi Wan wouldn’t blatantly lie about Anakin (although he may be cagey with the full truth). Luke wouldn’t be attracted to Leia, just drawn to her in a more protective sense. Obi Wan would recognise the droids immediately in an emotional scene. Yoda would actually be keen to train Luke (because that was the plan, right?). There would only be one Death Star, to be destroyed in ep 6, and huge chunks of it would be seen hurtling through space. Palpatine’s demise would be ambiguous, and there would be some subtle references to eternal life (a la Anakin’s quest to save Padme and the whole Plagueis thing) and some nods to cloning as well. Ewan McGregor, Joel Edgerton, Bonnie Piesse, and of course Ian McDiarmid would reprise their roles. No one on the Death Star would have sideburns…

Post
#1685667
Topic
<strong>The Battle Of Hoth</strong>...
Time

JackNapier said:

Shopping Maul said:

I love the way Luke is depicted during the Hoth battle. You get a real sense of how much he has grown as a rebel and a leader since the previous film. That’s why I find Yoda’s claim that “all his life has he looked away…” to be somewhat disingenuous given Luke’s obvious adherence to the task at hand post-ep 4.

Wasn’t Yoda talking about Anakin or am I remembering that wrong?

No, he was referring to Luke when Luke arrived on Dagobah. I only noticed this recently - Yoda’s castigating Luke for ‘always looking to the future, to the horizon, never his mind on what he was doing’ etc etc when the truth was that Luke had clearly been perfectly ‘present’ and responsible during the three years following ep 4. They’d established a new base, Luke was doing security patrols, he was a Commander etc etc. It was only at Obi Wan’s urging that he suddenly ditched the Rebellion and went off to be a space Samurai…

Sorry, I really don’t want to derail this thread!

On another note I really love how the Hoth battle looks on 4K80. Obviously the matte lines and transparent cockpits are very much apparent, but that just goes to the ingenuity of what was being attempted back then. I also love how General Veers’ Walker takes the time to shoot that one dude before taking out the Power Generator!

Post
#1680731
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

I do think Anakin in the TPM is a bit overly cutesy, but I only see that as a minor thing in that movie. For most of his scenes I think he’s generally more serious, sad or excited, rather than overly cutesy to me.

It’s not just Anakin who is cutesy, it’s his whole world that’s cutesy. For me it’s difficult to see his slavery as a serious consideration when it basically mirrors suburban living. He lives with his Mom, she entertains guests, he gets to work in a fix-it shop and race go-carts…it just doesn’t feel fully realised. The ‘baby Conan’ scenario at leasts gives a full-blown reason for a good, decent guy to have a very reasonable chip on his shoulder.

I also prefer, personally, Owen being Anakin’s step brother, rather than brother, as I feel that a character driven so much by his personal connections, I feel it doesn’t really connect much for Vader to have had a brother that he was raised with, and then that brother dies and it never comes up in the OT. I already feel like it’s an issue in the OT that they’re never mentioned again after they die.

I agree in a sense - I mean I wish Owen had come up in RoTJ (imagine if Luke, having beaten Vader to a standstill, rubbed the death of Owen and Beru in Vader’s face)!
The Owen connection I posited would work (IMO) because it would illustrate a definite (and poignant) crossroads between Anakin and Owen. Anakin would meet Obi Wan and be filled with zeal at the idea of tracking down evildoers and (eventually) getting his revenge. Owen would be like “it’s not worth it, let’s be farmers and leave all that behind us”. This to me is much more emotionally potent than the movies as they stand, especially given that there’s no real ‘idealistic crusade’ issue expressed or even demonstrated in the movies.

In terms of a Luke/Anakin parallel let me just say this - Conan '82 and Star Wars share many commonalities, something that admittedly only really occurred to me over time. Lucas and Milius were essentially going for similar things - the sense of myth, the Kurosawa inspiration, the aged mentor, the ‘used universe’, the ‘father’ tropes including the handing down of the sword/sabre and the villain becoming the dark mirror image of the noble father etc etc (even the poster art is the same BTW!). Both Luke and Conan end up in much the same place…basically standing over a defeated James Earl Jones with a sword and wondering where to go from there.

Luke chooses mercy and redeems his ‘dark father’. Conan does the opposite and kills his ‘dark father’ (of course Vader was actually Luke’s father while Conan’s villain was claiming ‘fatherhood’ in a spiritual sense, but anyhow…). This to me is an example of what Anakin could be - less a Luke figure and more a Conan figure.

Now Conan gets to just wander off and keep doing Conan things, but had he been bound by something like an allegiance to a Jedi Order (with his best friends and wife bound by the ethical constraints of that order as well) then you have an interesting state of affairs and a great springboard for the kind of character who could embody all the noble traits of ‘a good friend’ and ‘a cunning warrior’ but also be driven to rage by orthodoxy in a way that wouldn’t allow him to ‘let go of his hate’. This way we, the audience, could empathise with him whilst also seeing how such a great dude could become a bad guy. As it is now we kind of have to flex our credulity somewhat to go from ‘whiny teenager Anakin’ to ‘killing younglings and joining the bad guys’ Anakin. I just think the ‘baby Conan’ idea gives a more straightforward, and believable, path from child-slave to Dark Lord that easily smooths out the discrepancies between Obi Wan’s fond recollections on Tatooine and the homicidal psychopath that Vader actually was. But his central struggle wouldn’t be the ‘saving Padme’ stuff or anything to do with being a Chosen One. It would be about his slavery and his obsession with personal autonomy growing through adversity into an obsession with personal power - which would lead to his descent into darkness when that obsession is challenged by those he loves.

Post
#1680589
Topic
⭐ Star Wars' <strong>50th anniversary</strong> in 2027 ⭐ | Your hopes and expectations <em>(if any)</em>...
Time

Thanks to CaptainSolo’s channel (mentioned earlier in this thread) I obtained the relatively recent Arrow release of Conan the Barbarian '82 (my other favourite movie). I write this here to a) thank the good Captain if he happens to be lurking here and b) to illustrate just what a good Star Wars 4K/BluRay would look like. Conan has suffered the same indignities as Star Wars, albeit in a less extreme way, in terms of alterations and availability. This release has all three versions intact - a theatrical cut, a director’s cut, and an extended (Special Edition if you will) cut - plus a ton of extras which include past documentaries from previous releases. Oh, and the original theatrical poster art on the case!

This is all we need for Star Wars. Hopefully that’s where we’re headed…

Post
#1680206
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

“Look how invested we all got in TLJ when Holdo seemed to be a baddie, only to turn around and be secretly leading the rebels to Crait. You could create a similar tension in the sequels where Holdo comes off as a likely identity for the evil hologram lady, only to be revealed as a good guy”

“Heck, I don’t even like RoTJ!”

It’s all making more sense now

Not sure if you’re taking a shot at me here but let me clarify…

I said the RoTJ thing in fun, only because it’s ironic I’m defending the story integrity of a movie I don’t really like. But the fact remains that RoTJ is a definitive ending to the saga and is thus easily undermined by potential sequels - which is why I’m so hung up on the sequels presenting a story thread that can preserve RoTJ’s conclusions (which included the prequels’ ‘balance’ theme) whilst allowing for a continuation.

I also don’t like TLJ - but I did at least like the idea (if not necessarily the execution) of Holdo’s duality, and I thought a similar notion could work (as it did for many in TLJ) in a sequel trilogy.

Post
#1680005
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Yes, Mon Mothma is a very minor character. Especially before the Andor show, which arguably gives her too much screentime anyway. General audiences wouldn’t freak out, they would say “who is she supposed to be?” You would have to develop her for a little while before you make it a big twist.

I’m not too familiar with the Yuuzhan Vong but I think that’s the kind of direction you have to go if you don’t want to repeat the Sith and the Empire again. Lucas’s idea of underworld criminal elements filling in the power vacuum left by the Empire is also good (though I’m iffy on it having Darth Maul.)

Being that this is Star Wars, I don’t believe there are ‘minor’ characters anymore. That’s why every scene in the Mandalorian has some kind of callback be it an alien, a piece of hardware etc. We even had the cantina guys repeat their '77 dialogue in Rogue One!

It would be so easy to generate a nostalgic connection to Mothma in ep 7. One early appearance in an RoTJ-esque outfit, with Leia saying “it’s so good to see you my friend - we’ve missed you terribly” would bring a rousing cheer and establish a ‘between films’ connection that would fuel the Ben Solo thread. Maybe he attended university in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas?

The criminal underworld thing is plausible of course, but as much as we hate to admit it we do want the Sith and Empire again! Of course we do. Casual audiences definitely do. Again, the Mothma idea at least gives credence to the notion of a reconstituted status quo rather than the obvious ‘uh, the Empire grew back’ thing of Zhan’s novels, the Dark Horse comics, and the sequels. Again, it leaves the OT victory entirely intact whilst presenting the sinister idea that one of the lovely characters in the Rebel briefing room was actually a baddy with a future axe to grind…

Yes that kind of thing sucks, it’s something people both fans and outsiders complain about all the time. Seemingly every single character in the Mos Eisley cantina was given their own fleshed out backstory and adventures. Sometimes minor characters are just minor characters. The fondness some people have for minor characters out of universe does not mean they suddenly had more screentime retroactively added to the movies. Easter eggs are not the same thing as main characters.

“Uh, the Empire grew back” is not at all what happened in the Zahn books or the comics. The Empire is described as being on the back foot, fracturing into groups of warlords, not what it once was but not completely destroyed either. It makes perfect sense. The Empire starts winning in the Thrawn books because of Thrawn. He’s a singular, once in a generation military genius who lets them consistently win battles for the first time in a while, and he makes good use of technology like cloning, and various aliens. They also have help from a powerful dark jedi.

That makes so much more sense than Mon Mothma being a secret bad guy and rebuilding the Empire in secret, unless you basically made her into a Thrawn figure. That’s much more “Uh, the Empire grew back.”

I don’t disagree - indeed the fan service thing is annoying to me too (I never want to hear another Gonk Droid in my life!) but at the ‘nicer’ end of that scale is the fact that minor characters can and have been much loved (like Boba Fett as I mentioned in another reply and the ongoing disappointment regarding his demise, or a character like Wedge who is highly regarded). I think Mothma falls into that latter category - certainly enough for Lucas to include her in ROTS (edited out in the end but still…) and for writers to include her in Rogue One/Andor.

I’m not at all claiming that Zhan’s books or the comics are bad. I’m just saying that all they can really do is create a ‘new’ bad guy and/or a ‘new’ Empire. So really it’s just more Star Wars for the sake of more Star Wars, which is fine I guess. In a sense you’re right - I am positing Mothma as a ‘Thrawn figure’, but at least one where we go “damn, she was there all along!” rather than “well, there was another bad guy who we never heard of that has now emerged etc etc”. That’s just more appealing to me, but to each their own.

The specific individual we hadn’t heard of, just like we hadn’t heard of 99% of the imperial leadership, but the star destroyers and infrastructure were out in the open. The Mothma thing where it’s reversed and the Empire rebuilds without anyone noticing makes less sense.

Especially because there are plenty of ways you could sabotage the rebellion long before the second Death Star, if you were its main leader. Forgive the hacky comparison but if you were FDR or Winston Churchill and working for Hitler, there would be some serious differences in how the war played out before 1945. You could just give the Empire the location of Yavin or Hoth, for example.

I didn’t mean ‘she was there all along’ to mean she was a spy or a baddie all along. I meant it in the sense that we’d seen her in RoTJ. Her actual conversion to the Empire/Palpatine could’ve been recent by RoTJ’s standards. None of us had seen or heard of Mothma prior to RoTJ - and there was no Rogue One or Andor. She was a blank slate at that point - basically just a nice rebel lady who was delivering some DS plans. As far as I can tell she wasn’t at the Endor celebration either, even though the space lobsters were! I just think it would be cool to have a connecting thread to the OT - which would make it feel a little more like a genuine Episode 7 rather than just more Star Wars.

For example when we watch Obi Wan talking about Luke’s father in ep 4, we now see all these huge implications in Obi Wan’s discomfort. Of course none of those implications existed at the time, but now the saga is richer for it. It’s a similar thing when Yoda says “there is another” or when Leia and Luke Force-connect at the end of Empire. These moments now have weight that binds the episodes, even though the intention at the time of writing was otherwise. In this instance the RoTJ briefing scene, when viewed through the lens of the 9-film saga, would now carry this kind of pre-emptive foreboding that would give the ‘new’ trilogy a sense of continuity to its predecessors.

So she wasn’t in the alliance at all until shortly before ROTJ, but became the leader of the whole thing immediately? I wasn’t even referring to Andor or anything like that, I’m saying that just within the context of ROTJ by itself, she’s clearly the leader in some capacity. On the other hand, if you think that she could plausibly be just some common woman they appointed to deliver the briefing, there wouldn’t be any interest or shock value in her being a traitor.

So why can’t a leader become corrupt? Didn’t Dooku start out as a good guy? The interesting thing is that we never saw Mothma in the previous episodes at all - she wasn’t on Yavin, she wasn’t on Hoth. RoTJ showed the Rebels basically coming together, presumably from far and wide given all the new faces, for one last battle - so we have no idea where she operated from or in what capacity. She was a blank slate, irrespective of her rank (not that any rank was actually alluded to in the film beyond ‘here’s an important rebel lady’). All we know is that this important rebel lady delivered the false information - as intended by Palpatine - that lead the rebels into a trap. I’m merely suggesting that she was in on it, rather than just being a dupe along with everyone else, and that, like Dooku, or Grievous, or Darth Maul, or Anakin Skywalker, she had been offered power in exchange for aligning herself with Palpatine’s evil designs.

The information wasn’t false though, it was completely true. It could be used as a trap because it was a tempting target. Palpatine takes credit for it himself. No one in particular had to deliver the information within the Alliance, other than the Bothans that found it out in the first place. She’s just giving the briefing, so she’s not introducing any deception right that moment.

I mean ‘false’ in the sense that what the rebels thought was a great piece of covert discovery was actually Palpatine letting them know purposefully. He was deliberately letting them know about the shield on Endor, he knew about the “rebel fleet massing near Sullust”, he knew that a stolen shuttle had landed on Endor etc etc. All I’m adding here is that she knew what he was up to and was facilitating his wishes rather than being, like I said, another dupe.

Again if she’s a total blank slate and we assume that she’s not the main leader and she’s just some woman delivering the briefing, then the twist wouldn’t have any meaning or impact. At most it’s just “Oh, it’s her. Weird.” You’re relying on the context of her being some variety of fan favorite character, but those don’t exist in a vacuum. In the EU, Disney canon, and the ROTS deleted scenes, she’s high leadership from the start. That’s why people would care. You can have her as a blank slate or you can have her as a popular character turning heel, but you can’t do both.

That’s not what I mean by ‘blank slate’. Of course she’s a main leader, but that’s all she is (in RoTJ). We don’t get a backstory, and we don’t have a prior connection to her. She is a fan favourite of sorts, but only by virtue of showing up in a very popular movie and sporting a very recognisable look and being a lovely, regal figure who shows up to brief the rebels. I’m merely positing that the nice, regal figure who led the rebel meeting was actually in cahoots with the bad guy. From which naturally follows that she wasn’t thrilled when the rebels won and was politically in a position to plan some kind of retaliation, and was personally in a position to take her revenge on the Skywalkers by messing with their son.

I get what you’re saying about ‘fan favourites’, but I think she’d be fan favourite enough just by virtue of the above. For casual viewers who wouldn’t necessarily recall (or care about) the nice regal lady on the squid ship in RoTJ, it would still be something of a sinister revelation - especially if she’s given screen time in the sequels as her nice, nostalgia-baiting self (sharing pleasantries with Luke and Leia for instance). It’d be like “oh, so it’s that lady? Jeez, okay, that’s dark” (all the more so when viewed in a marathon with the OT). To me that’s so much more satisfying than Snoke being a random nobody or Palpatine just…returning.

I think I said this earlier but you could also have a red herring, like Holdo for instance, to generate tension. Look how invested we all got in TLJ when Holdo seemed to be a baddie, only to turn around and be secretly leading the rebels to Crait. You could create a similar tension in the sequels where Holdo comes off as a likely identity for the evil hologram lady, only to be revealed as a good guy while Mothma, having appeared as lovely fan service for Luke and Leia throughout the new trilogy, is actually the villain - an effect that is automatically heightened by her role in RoTJ.

Let’s say there’s a big showdown in episode 9, and Leia has figured out who the new bad guy/lady is (there could be a side-note for instance where Lando or a new character discovers journals that reveal the Bothan spies had been aware of the DS trap and were intending to reveal it before they were killed). Sparks are flying and stuff is going down, and Leia says something like “it was you! You killed the Bothan spies! You delivered us in to the trap on Endor! You were in league with the Emperor! And now this! Why Mon, why!”.

And the audience is like “yeah why? You were so nice in RoTJ. And we just saw you in the Hosnian system being so lovely and we cheered 'cos we recognised the white outfit and wow, you’re messing with our nostalgia!”

And Mothma’s howling like a madwoman (as sparks are flying and Tie fighters are blowing sh*t up) “he offered me power, power beyond my wildest dreams! And you took it away from me!”

That’s all you’d need. And of course, down the line, authors like Timothy Zhan and Matthew Stover would write EU about the fall of Mothma, and how she went from ex-Senator and beloved Rebel leader to Palpatine’s lackey.

I’m not saying all this because it’s the greatest piece of storytelling in the world. Heck, I don’t even like RoTJ! I just think it’s a potentially cool sneaky way to introduce/create a little sinister thread that can justify a continuation of the story beyond the usual ‘from beyond the Outer Rim came a new baddie’. We can still have new villains, new bounty hunters and Knights Of Ren and whatever the heck we want, but I just think it adds connective tissue to the saga to have the prime motivator of the new bad stuff be someone we encountered in the OT and, better yet, never suspected.

Post
#1679948
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Yes, Mon Mothma is a very minor character. Especially before the Andor show, which arguably gives her too much screentime anyway. General audiences wouldn’t freak out, they would say “who is she supposed to be?” You would have to develop her for a little while before you make it a big twist.

I’m not too familiar with the Yuuzhan Vong but I think that’s the kind of direction you have to go if you don’t want to repeat the Sith and the Empire again. Lucas’s idea of underworld criminal elements filling in the power vacuum left by the Empire is also good (though I’m iffy on it having Darth Maul.)

Being that this is Star Wars, I don’t believe there are ‘minor’ characters anymore. That’s why every scene in the Mandalorian has some kind of callback be it an alien, a piece of hardware etc. We even had the cantina guys repeat their '77 dialogue in Rogue One!

It would be so easy to generate a nostalgic connection to Mothma in ep 7. One early appearance in an RoTJ-esque outfit, with Leia saying “it’s so good to see you my friend - we’ve missed you terribly” would bring a rousing cheer and establish a ‘between films’ connection that would fuel the Ben Solo thread. Maybe he attended university in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas?

The criminal underworld thing is plausible of course, but as much as we hate to admit it we do want the Sith and Empire again! Of course we do. Casual audiences definitely do. Again, the Mothma idea at least gives credence to the notion of a reconstituted status quo rather than the obvious ‘uh, the Empire grew back’ thing of Zhan’s novels, the Dark Horse comics, and the sequels. Again, it leaves the OT victory entirely intact whilst presenting the sinister idea that one of the lovely characters in the Rebel briefing room was actually a baddy with a future axe to grind…

Yes that kind of thing sucks, it’s something people both fans and outsiders complain about all the time. Seemingly every single character in the Mos Eisley cantina was given their own fleshed out backstory and adventures. Sometimes minor characters are just minor characters. The fondness some people have for minor characters out of universe does not mean they suddenly had more screentime retroactively added to the movies. Easter eggs are not the same thing as main characters.

“Uh, the Empire grew back” is not at all what happened in the Zahn books or the comics. The Empire is described as being on the back foot, fracturing into groups of warlords, not what it once was but not completely destroyed either. It makes perfect sense. The Empire starts winning in the Thrawn books because of Thrawn. He’s a singular, once in a generation military genius who lets them consistently win battles for the first time in a while, and he makes good use of technology like cloning, and various aliens. They also have help from a powerful dark jedi.

That makes so much more sense than Mon Mothma being a secret bad guy and rebuilding the Empire in secret, unless you basically made her into a Thrawn figure. That’s much more “Uh, the Empire grew back.”

I don’t disagree - indeed the fan service thing is annoying to me too (I never want to hear another Gonk Droid in my life!) but at the ‘nicer’ end of that scale is the fact that minor characters can and have been much loved (like Boba Fett as I mentioned in another reply and the ongoing disappointment regarding his demise, or a character like Wedge who is highly regarded). I think Mothma falls into that latter category - certainly enough for Lucas to include her in ROTS (edited out in the end but still…) and for writers to include her in Rogue One/Andor.

I’m not at all claiming that Zhan’s books or the comics are bad. I’m just saying that all they can really do is create a ‘new’ bad guy and/or a ‘new’ Empire. So really it’s just more Star Wars for the sake of more Star Wars, which is fine I guess. In a sense you’re right - I am positing Mothma as a ‘Thrawn figure’, but at least one where we go “damn, she was there all along!” rather than “well, there was another bad guy who we never heard of that has now emerged etc etc”. That’s just more appealing to me, but to each their own.

The specific individual we hadn’t heard of, just like we hadn’t heard of 99% of the imperial leadership, but the star destroyers and infrastructure were out in the open. The Mothma thing where it’s reversed and the Empire rebuilds without anyone noticing makes less sense.

Especially because there are plenty of ways you could sabotage the rebellion long before the second Death Star, if you were its main leader. Forgive the hacky comparison but if you were FDR or Winston Churchill and working for Hitler, there would be some serious differences in how the war played out before 1945. You could just give the Empire the location of Yavin or Hoth, for example.

I didn’t mean ‘she was there all along’ to mean she was a spy or a baddie all along. I meant it in the sense that we’d seen her in RoTJ. Her actual conversion to the Empire/Palpatine could’ve been recent by RoTJ’s standards. None of us had seen or heard of Mothma prior to RoTJ - and there was no Rogue One or Andor. She was a blank slate at that point - basically just a nice rebel lady who was delivering some DS plans. As far as I can tell she wasn’t at the Endor celebration either, even though the space lobsters were! I just think it would be cool to have a connecting thread to the OT - which would make it feel a little more like a genuine Episode 7 rather than just more Star Wars.

For example when we watch Obi Wan talking about Luke’s father in ep 4, we now see all these huge implications in Obi Wan’s discomfort. Of course none of those implications existed at the time, but now the saga is richer for it. It’s a similar thing when Yoda says “there is another” or when Leia and Luke Force-connect at the end of Empire. These moments now have weight that binds the episodes, even though the intention at the time of writing was otherwise. In this instance the RoTJ briefing scene, when viewed through the lens of the 9-film saga, would now carry this kind of pre-emptive foreboding that would give the ‘new’ trilogy a sense of continuity to its predecessors.

So she wasn’t in the alliance at all until shortly before ROTJ, but became the leader of the whole thing immediately? I wasn’t even referring to Andor or anything like that, I’m saying that just within the context of ROTJ by itself, she’s clearly the leader in some capacity. On the other hand, if you think that she could plausibly be just some common woman they appointed to deliver the briefing, there wouldn’t be any interest or shock value in her being a traitor.

So why can’t a leader become corrupt? Didn’t Dooku start out as a good guy? The interesting thing is that we never saw Mothma in the previous episodes at all - she wasn’t on Yavin, she wasn’t on Hoth. RoTJ showed the Rebels basically coming together, presumably from far and wide given all the new faces, for one last battle - so we have no idea where she operated from or in what capacity. She was a blank slate, irrespective of her rank (not that any rank was actually alluded to in the film beyond ‘here’s an important rebel lady’). All we know is that this important rebel lady delivered the false information - as intended by Palpatine - that lead the rebels into a trap. I’m merely suggesting that she was in on it, rather than just being a dupe along with everyone else, and that, like Dooku, or Grievous, or Darth Maul, or Anakin Skywalker, she had been offered power in exchange for aligning herself with Palpatine’s evil designs.

Post
#1679781
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Yes, Mon Mothma is a very minor character. Especially before the Andor show, which arguably gives her too much screentime anyway. General audiences wouldn’t freak out, they would say “who is she supposed to be?” You would have to develop her for a little while before you make it a big twist.

I’m not too familiar with the Yuuzhan Vong but I think that’s the kind of direction you have to go if you don’t want to repeat the Sith and the Empire again. Lucas’s idea of underworld criminal elements filling in the power vacuum left by the Empire is also good (though I’m iffy on it having Darth Maul.)

Being that this is Star Wars, I don’t believe there are ‘minor’ characters anymore. That’s why every scene in the Mandalorian has some kind of callback be it an alien, a piece of hardware etc. We even had the cantina guys repeat their '77 dialogue in Rogue One!

It would be so easy to generate a nostalgic connection to Mothma in ep 7. One early appearance in an RoTJ-esque outfit, with Leia saying “it’s so good to see you my friend - we’ve missed you terribly” would bring a rousing cheer and establish a ‘between films’ connection that would fuel the Ben Solo thread. Maybe he attended university in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas?

The criminal underworld thing is plausible of course, but as much as we hate to admit it we do want the Sith and Empire again! Of course we do. Casual audiences definitely do. Again, the Mothma idea at least gives credence to the notion of a reconstituted status quo rather than the obvious ‘uh, the Empire grew back’ thing of Zhan’s novels, the Dark Horse comics, and the sequels. Again, it leaves the OT victory entirely intact whilst presenting the sinister idea that one of the lovely characters in the Rebel briefing room was actually a baddy with a future axe to grind…

Yes that kind of thing sucks, it’s something people both fans and outsiders complain about all the time. Seemingly every single character in the Mos Eisley cantina was given their own fleshed out backstory and adventures. Sometimes minor characters are just minor characters. The fondness some people have for minor characters out of universe does not mean they suddenly had more screentime retroactively added to the movies. Easter eggs are not the same thing as main characters.

“Uh, the Empire grew back” is not at all what happened in the Zahn books or the comics. The Empire is described as being on the back foot, fracturing into groups of warlords, not what it once was but not completely destroyed either. It makes perfect sense. The Empire starts winning in the Thrawn books because of Thrawn. He’s a singular, once in a generation military genius who lets them consistently win battles for the first time in a while, and he makes good use of technology like cloning, and various aliens. They also have help from a powerful dark jedi.

That makes so much more sense than Mon Mothma being a secret bad guy and rebuilding the Empire in secret, unless you basically made her into a Thrawn figure. That’s much more “Uh, the Empire grew back.”

I don’t disagree - indeed the fan service thing is annoying to me too (I never want to hear another Gonk Droid in my life!) but at the ‘nicer’ end of that scale is the fact that minor characters can and have been much loved (like Boba Fett as I mentioned in another reply and the ongoing disappointment regarding his demise, or a character like Wedge who is highly regarded). I think Mothma falls into that latter category - certainly enough for Lucas to include her in ROTS (edited out in the end but still…) and for writers to include her in Rogue One/Andor.

I’m not at all claiming that Zhan’s books or the comics are bad. I’m just saying that all they can really do is create a ‘new’ bad guy and/or a ‘new’ Empire. So really it’s just more Star Wars for the sake of more Star Wars, which is fine I guess. In a sense you’re right - I am positing Mothma as a ‘Thrawn figure’, but at least one where we go “damn, she was there all along!” rather than “well, there was another bad guy who we never heard of that has now emerged etc etc”. That’s just more appealing to me, but to each their own.

The specific individual we hadn’t heard of, just like we hadn’t heard of 99% of the imperial leadership, but the star destroyers and infrastructure were out in the open. The Mothma thing where it’s reversed and the Empire rebuilds without anyone noticing makes less sense.

Especially because there are plenty of ways you could sabotage the rebellion long before the second Death Star, if you were its main leader. Forgive the hacky comparison but if you were FDR or Winston Churchill and working for Hitler, there would be some serious differences in how the war played out before 1945. You could just give the Empire the location of Yavin or Hoth, for example.

I didn’t mean ‘she was there all along’ to mean she was a spy or a baddie all along. I meant it in the sense that we’d seen her in RoTJ. Her actual conversion to the Empire/Palpatine could’ve been recent by RoTJ’s standards. None of us had seen or heard of Mothma prior to RoTJ - and there was no Rogue One or Andor. She was a blank slate at that point - basically just a nice rebel lady who was delivering some DS plans. As far as I can tell she wasn’t at the Endor celebration either, even though the space lobsters were! I just think it would be cool to have a connecting thread to the OT - which would make it feel a little more like a genuine Episode 7 rather than just more Star Wars.

For example when we watch Obi Wan talking about Luke’s father in ep 4, we now see all these huge implications in Obi Wan’s discomfort. Of course none of those implications existed at the time, but now the saga is richer for it. It’s a similar thing when Yoda says “there is another” or when Leia and Luke Force-connect at the end of Empire. These moments now have weight that binds the episodes, even though the intention at the time of writing was otherwise. In this instance the RoTJ briefing scene, when viewed through the lens of the 9-film saga, would now carry this kind of pre-emptive foreboding that would give the ‘new’ trilogy a sense of continuity to its predecessors.

Post
#1679557
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

I feel I’ve derailed this thread somewhat so, to bring it back to the main point, ‘somehow Palpatine returned’ is bad because it’s such a clumsy non-explanation for something we all know to be utterly ridiculous. It doesn’t even really feel like something Poe should be saying.

I guess, if Palpatine really needed to be resurrected, I’d prefer Poe say something like “the intel has revealed a huge planet-destroying fleet amassing in the Exegol system and preparing for war. It claims to be under the command of…Emperor Palpatine”.

Then everyone gasps and looks concerned. That’s all you need. Elsewhere in the movie you’d (theoretically) get some kind of explanation.

Post
#1679555
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

Shopping Maul said:

Vladius said:

Yes, Mon Mothma is a very minor character. Especially before the Andor show, which arguably gives her too much screentime anyway. General audiences wouldn’t freak out, they would say “who is she supposed to be?” You would have to develop her for a little while before you make it a big twist.

I’m not too familiar with the Yuuzhan Vong but I think that’s the kind of direction you have to go if you don’t want to repeat the Sith and the Empire again. Lucas’s idea of underworld criminal elements filling in the power vacuum left by the Empire is also good (though I’m iffy on it having Darth Maul.)

Being that this is Star Wars, I don’t believe there are ‘minor’ characters anymore. That’s why every scene in the Mandalorian has some kind of callback be it an alien, a piece of hardware etc. We even had the cantina guys repeat their '77 dialogue in Rogue One!

It would be so easy to generate a nostalgic connection to Mothma in ep 7. One early appearance in an RoTJ-esque outfit, with Leia saying “it’s so good to see you my friend - we’ve missed you terribly” would bring a rousing cheer and establish a ‘between films’ connection that would fuel the Ben Solo thread. Maybe he attended university in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas?

The criminal underworld thing is plausible of course, but as much as we hate to admit it we do want the Sith and Empire again! Of course we do. Casual audiences definitely do. Again, the Mothma idea at least gives credence to the notion of a reconstituted status quo rather than the obvious ‘uh, the Empire grew back’ thing of Zhan’s novels, the Dark Horse comics, and the sequels. Again, it leaves the OT victory entirely intact whilst presenting the sinister idea that one of the lovely characters in the Rebel briefing room was actually a baddy with a future axe to grind…

Yes that kind of thing sucks, it’s something people both fans and outsiders complain about all the time. Seemingly every single character in the Mos Eisley cantina was given their own fleshed out backstory and adventures. Sometimes minor characters are just minor characters. The fondness some people have for minor characters out of universe does not mean they suddenly had more screentime retroactively added to the movies. Easter eggs are not the same thing as main characters.

“Uh, the Empire grew back” is not at all what happened in the Zahn books or the comics. The Empire is described as being on the back foot, fracturing into groups of warlords, not what it once was but not completely destroyed either. It makes perfect sense. The Empire starts winning in the Thrawn books because of Thrawn. He’s a singular, once in a generation military genius who lets them consistently win battles for the first time in a while, and he makes good use of technology like cloning, and various aliens. They also have help from a powerful dark jedi.

That makes so much more sense than Mon Mothma being a secret bad guy and rebuilding the Empire in secret, unless you basically made her into a Thrawn figure. That’s much more “Uh, the Empire grew back.”

I don’t disagree - indeed the fan service thing is annoying to me too (I never want to hear another Gonk Droid in my life!) but at the ‘nicer’ end of that scale is the fact that minor characters can and have been much loved (like Boba Fett as I mentioned in another reply and the ongoing disappointment regarding his demise, or a character like Wedge who is highly regarded). I think Mothma falls into that latter category - certainly enough for Lucas to include her in ROTS (edited out in the end but still…) and for writers to include her in Rogue One/Andor.

I’m not at all claiming that Zhan’s books or the comics are bad. I’m just saying that all they can really do is create a ‘new’ bad guy and/or a ‘new’ Empire. So really it’s just more Star Wars for the sake of more Star Wars, which is fine I guess. In a sense you’re right - I am positing Mothma as a ‘Thrawn figure’, but at least one where we go “damn, she was there all along!” rather than “well, there was another bad guy who we never heard of that has now emerged etc etc”. That’s just more appealing to me, but to each their own.

Post
#1679542
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Dagenspear said:

Shopping Maul said:

Well the problem is that there is no story after RoTJ. RoTJ was the ending - definitively. So all you can do is what has already been done ad nauseam - just posit a ‘new threat’ and dust off some TIE fighters. Snoke was useless because, in the end, no one cared. He had no connection to anything. Palpatine’s ‘return’ was silly, unexplained, illogical, and ruined the ending of a 6 film saga.
At least with Mothma you get someone with emotional weight - a beloved (despite her screen time) character whose betrayal of Han and Leia would actually mean something. And the idea that she was in the Rebel briefing room basically laying a trap on behalf of her boss because he’d promised her power (or to spare her world or whatever) is infinitely more satisfying than ‘a new threat has emerged from beyond the outer rim…’

Beloved to only really more heavily invested fans, from one scene in one movie basically I think.

I think you’re underestimating the nostalgic potential of minor characters. People are still whining about Boba Fett’s ignoble demise in RoTJ despite his minor status in TESB. There was major speculation about him in the early 80s - one magazine (Starlog?) did a massive article explaining how he was actually Luke’s father and had previously owned the Millennium Falcon!

Lucas included Mothma in ROTS. Okay, so she didn’t make the edit, but he thought she was worthy connective tissue to the OT. Rogue One agreed and placed her on Yavin in her traditional outfit. I think it would be so easy to exploit the feel-good factor of her presence (like I suggested in another reply - have her appear early in ep 7 in RoTJ-esque garb with Leia gushingly saying “Mon, so delightful to see you, we’ve missed you so much”)…

I think it’d kinda come out of nowhere really within the mainline movies, for me. And as for Han and Leia, they’re older characters. What does this mean for the newer characters? Beyond Kylo.

The fact that it would impact the older characters is the whole point. That’s what would tug at the heart-strings. All the newer characters need is a new villain, a new threat, and a reason to fight. And like I said, having Mothma be the family friend who corrupts Ben Solo is much more emotionally charged than “some new evil guy corrupted Ben Solo”. I mentioned in another reply that perhaps Ben could have been educated in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas.

To return to the OP’s point, the whole “somehow Palpatine returned” is ridiculous at so many levels. Palpatine’s death was crucial to the saga, so it undermines the PT and OT. Secondly, it strikes me as an odd thing for Poe and Rey and co. to be reacting emotionally to. Palpatine would just be a kind of evil legend to them - bad for sure but not necessarily carrying an immediate, visceral emotional weight. So that whole quote was playing for Leia, Chewie and us (fans) anyway. So swap “somehow Palpatine returned” for Leia saying to all assembled…

…“it was her. It was Mothma all along. She was in league with Palpatine. She killed the Bothan spies and led us into the trap on Endor. This is her revenge. That is where the First Order is striking from…the Bothan System!” (or something)…

If it was to spare her world, then I don’t see what she’d care about after Palpatine dies and empire falls. I maintain my stance, why would Palpatine offer anyone this, and why would he not use Mothma lead the empire to the rebels instead, and why would anyone buy what he says if he offers them a seat at his side?

Star Wars thrives on vague motivations, so we wouldn’t need some elaborate backstory (Matthew Stover would write one later anyway!). All we’d really need is the revelation that Mothma was working with Palpatine in secret, that he had promised her power of some kind, that she had killed the Bothan spies herself and delivered the false Death Star message on Palpatine’s behalf etc etc. When the rebels defeated the Empire, she was denied her ambitions.

Kylo had no backstory really, until Rian destroyed Luke Skywalker in order to give him one. In the Mothma version Kylo is betrayed by an adored friend, someone masquerading as an ally whilst filling his eager mind with distortions regarding his ‘true’ grandfather and using him for his power. Again, seeing Mothma as the nice robed lady on the Mon Calamari ship and realising she would later turn Leia’s son against her is way more interesting to me than ‘random Palpatine wannabe appeared out of nowhere for no reason and turned Kylo bad’.

A friend that has about as much weight as, as far as the movies gave, “a voice in his head” basically. Why would he trust her over his family? Why does she matter this much to Kylo? Why would his granddad Vader matter to him this way? These are more my questions.

Fair enough, but I would add - what exactly did Snoke add to the saga? What did resurrected Palpatine add to the saga? More pointedly, what did they take from the saga? The Mothma idea, to me, is a way to continue the story with all the good elements of the sequels intact without undermining the 6 films in any way. And it even adds a nice little twist to RoTJ.

I’m not defending Snoke or Palpatine (in this avenue, as in a post TLJ story I think he works more than Kylo to me) as a villain. I’m just not for this.

All fair enough - I’m not arguing with you per se…I just love nerding out over Star Wars!

Post
#1679533
Topic
ROS is bad, yes, we know. But why is this one line the thing that people always point to?
Time

Vladius said:

Yes, Mon Mothma is a very minor character. Especially before the Andor show, which arguably gives her too much screentime anyway. General audiences wouldn’t freak out, they would say “who is she supposed to be?” You would have to develop her for a little while before you make it a big twist.

I’m not too familiar with the Yuuzhan Vong but I think that’s the kind of direction you have to go if you don’t want to repeat the Sith and the Empire again. Lucas’s idea of underworld criminal elements filling in the power vacuum left by the Empire is also good (though I’m iffy on it having Darth Maul.)

Being that this is Star Wars, I don’t believe there are ‘minor’ characters anymore. That’s why every scene in the Mandalorian has some kind of callback be it an alien, a piece of hardware etc. We even had the cantina guys repeat their '77 dialogue in Rogue One!

It would be so easy to generate a nostalgic connection to Mothma in ep 7. One early appearance in an RoTJ-esque outfit, with Leia saying “it’s so good to see you my friend - we’ve missed you terribly” would bring a rousing cheer and establish a ‘between films’ connection that would fuel the Ben Solo thread. Maybe he attended university in the Bothan system and stayed with the Mothmas?

The criminal underworld thing is plausible of course, but as much as we hate to admit it we do want the Sith and Empire again! Of course we do. Casual audiences definitely do. Again, the Mothma idea at least gives credence to the notion of a reconstituted status quo rather than the obvious ‘uh, the Empire grew back’ thing of Zhan’s novels, the Dark Horse comics, and the sequels. Again, it leaves the OT victory entirely intact whilst presenting the sinister idea that one of the lovely characters in the Rebel briefing room was actually a baddy with a future axe to grind…