Watching these two videos and made me realised that the current versions of Star Wars, had always been 2K, in my opinion.
https://youtu.be/I7Iuia5560Y
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4XEomJZV6I
When the first versions of the SE, and Phantom Menance came out, it was still film reels, but because of the effects and other digital movie editing at the time that made things easier, all the film recordings were definitley gonna be downsampled to 2K, and at least be put on a 2K master. (if not get put to film again for distribution convience.)
By the time Attack of the Clones came out, I feel like the workflow affected the look a bit, when it was one of the biggest films to use digial cameras. (technaclly the first film to use the digital 1080p24 mode was Kamen Rider Agito’s summer movie from what I gathered.) Looking at even the compositing here, let’s just say Phantom Menance and at least the early SE 1997 (aside from Jabba) blended better than AOTC, which for recording on film and then transfered it, can help at least mask it, and color corrected. Not saying AOTC had bad VFX, but you can see in the first video how rough it was for a all digital workflow at the time.
This may also be why the 2004 SE looked so unatural since they may have just transfered the 1997 SE, and not even bother to fix some of the color errors (proabably due to cheaper film, like how Sailor Moon was tinted pink when it got a HD remaster.) like Luke’s Lightsaber during the training, and other weird digital alterations. I don’t even know if they DNR’ed the transfered film while doing the SE. (if at least done less since it was a DVD release and it was still 480/576)
Both may or may not have been mastered in 2K or just regular 1080p.
ROTS is a little better since the CGI and VFX stuff had matured a bit for the past 3-4 years with AO, and other stuff, even upgraded the camera for a better 1080p. Heck even when I watched it last year in the cinema, it didn’t bother me as much as I thought.
Then we get the 2011, which used the same master as the 2004 DVD which was 1080p at best, (2K is a weird term for me, it’s either 2048x1080p max or 2560x1440p) and all they did was add the DNR, which depending on if they had use DNR in the 2004 version, it looked worst.) Even Phantom Menance was hurt from bad color palette, my best bet was when they transfered the 1997 version for the 2004 DVD, the film degraded as mentioned earlier because it was using cheaper film, and then did the same with Phantom Menance, and only now just transfered it to HD in 2011. Leaving the color palette intact.
Idk if Phantom Menance had a all digital master like Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith, let me know.
I can’t go any futher with the 4K Versions, but I have heard some changes were made for a 3D release including more SE level changes like Maclunkey, and did fix the color problems, and redid some minor changes meant for the 3D version.
I just want to get something out to talk about, since the Prequels were an interesting piece of Behind the Scenes history with George pushing an all digital editing workflow, and then try to inovate with digital cameras being used on a hollywood level.