Mr. Manehead

Interested to check this out!

There are some shots in the 4K remastered blu-ray where the DNR resulted in strange effects, e.g. the smearing of detail on some characters faces resulting in them having a plastic appearance in certain frames. There is also a shot from Return of the King of Gandalf and Pippin walking in the Courtyard of the White Tree outside Denethor’s hall, and you can visibly see that the DNR causes the top of Gandalf’s staff to disappear from the image entirely.

These videos on YouTube do a good job of analyzing the DNR problems with the 4K remasters:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ba1F0hyMvr4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I3Z58uiwcME

It’s cool to hear that your 4K HDR remasters are mixing the grain structure of the 2011 bluray to the 4k HDR disc. I’m interested to see if this will alleviate some of the smearing of faces mentioned, or if it would be better to replace those shots with alternate sources. The same goes for shots like the one where the detail of Gandalf’s staff is erased by the DNR.

Thanks for your work on this!

Hello everyone, this project looks awesome! I understand that there were some frame rate stutter issues with the initial exports of the first two films in the trilogy - was this fixed in a subsequent version after all? Hoping to view these projects for myself! Considering the strange tint of the 2011 bluray release and the DNR problems on the 2020 4K release, I’m interested to see how these films look in their original theatrical format.