Sign In

Max Rebo

User Group
Members
Join date
24-Jun-2019
Last activity
15-Sep-2019
Posts
16

Post History

Post
#1293354
Topic
What Are The Best Sequel Trilogy Edits???
Time

ChainsawAsh said:

Restructured for TFA, with Nev’s Starlight Project probably supplanting it for me when finished.

Rekindled for TLJ.

I will actually be doing a review of what are considered the “best” fan edits, and Rekindled is one of them. Starting with the best of TLJ, I wanna compare so I can see which is better whilst adding my opinion on them alongside in what regard each edit succeeds or fails at. After that I plan on doing the same thing for the best edits of TFA.

Post
#1293352
Topic
What Are The Best Sequel Trilogy Edits???
Time

JSteven said:

My personal favs are DigMod’s Heir to the Force and ForceGhostRecon’s Last of the Jedi. Definitely check them out if you can! The Fallen Knight was a really good edit as well.

I have FGR’s edit is the whole reason why I’m on OT.com and I really love Heir to the Force but I think a couple more scenes would have went a long way. I’m thinking about using that as a base to add said scenes.

Post
#1293028
Topic
What Are The Best Sequel Trilogy Edits???
Time

rocknroll41 said:

The ones you mentioned are good, but they also break away from the overall saga continuity a little bit, so they’re not really my favorites.

I’d say my favorite version of TFA is Hal9000’s The Force Awakens Restructured, and my favorite version of TLJ is ClarkZuckerberg’s The Fallen Knight, with ForceGhostRecon’s Last of the Jedi (Color Regrade Version) as a close second.

Thanks, I will be sure and check those out.

Post
#1292982
Topic
What Are The Best Sequel Trilogy Edits???
Time

What would you guys say are the best edits of the ST bar none? Mine are Digi Mod’s Heir to the Force edit and FGR’s TLJ Clean Cut also. Digi’s Rogue One and Solo edits are good (Rise of the Rebellion and The Coaxium Heist). Ivan’s TLJ was meh with only few edits in there are good , and I have yet to watch the TLJ Rekindled by PapaSketti. In conclusion, what would you guys say are the best ST/Spinoff edits?

Post
#1287283
Topic
Star Wars: Heir to the Force (TFA edit) <em>Released</em>
Time

DigMod said:

Yes. The entire scene was removed as to introduce Cassian when Jynn meets him for the first time. Too much planet hopping and ultimately it wasn’t needed. I also wanted Cassian to be more of a hero in the edit.

That is fine man, I will say I am enjoying what I’m seeing so far. I will give this a full watch. I love the changes that I’ve seen such as less glossy and more natural Grand Moff Tarkin. Also, Vaters eyes aren’t to read. I do realize that his eyes were red in certain lighting in the original trilogy, but in rogue one they overdid it. You made it look a bit more natural and amazing as a post to a very detailed cosplayer’s Halloween costume. PS, I also love the or heck of planet names when people go there and I love how Jyn is dreaming about her past.