I quite liked your original idea. While ROTS didn't give us much character development, the whole prequel trilogy didn't give us much either. I would use as little of the other prequels as possible, if I were you.
darklordoftech said:
DominicCobb said:
At the same time, I do feel as if Filoni doesn't really give a s**t if he messes with continuity or not. I'm mostly referring to The Clone Wars. The fact that that is now the canon version of that time period is kind of dumb. The incompatible Clone Wars events from the comics, books, and micro-series were much more believable and just better thought out, for the most part.
Actually, Filoni did whatever he could to stick to continuity. Things like returning Maul were things that Lucas insisted on. It's Lucas who doesn't really give a s**t about continuity.
I hated that Dooku fought Anakin in TCW. ROTS clearly implied that this was their first duel since AOTC. I also hate how Obi-Wan was always fighting Grievous. He obviously seemed surprised that Grievous had four arms and could use lightsaber in ROTS, but in TCW Obi-Wan saw that all the time.
Is that what you're calling your Episode I Smithers?
Thanks Frink
So did you end up uploading it? HAL9000 requested it and you said you'd see about it.
Does anyone know where to download AEMovieGuy’s cut of Revenge of the Sith? The links on fanedit.info are dead.
Tobar said:
Honorable mention goes to:
While they look sleek at first glance, an iota of scrutiny reveals a failure to stick to any real theme. Yoda for AOTC just makes no sense when the rest are villains.
Generic Stormtrooper instead of Boba Fett? Heck, if they wanted to stick to big bads they could have used Tarkin for SW and then Vader for ESB.
Ultimately, lazy floating head designs are always a fail.
Bonus points for dropping the episode numbers. But points docked for just slapping STAR WARS on each with the film's title underneath. Each cover should have had the film's title as a logo:
I don't mind those, though I wish the character choices were a bit better. I would have gone:
Episode I: Darth Maul
Episode II: Jango Fett
Episode III: Either Darth Vader or Palpatine
Episode IV: Either Darth Vader, Tarkin, or Trooper
Episode V: Boba Fett
Episode VI: Either Darth Vader or The Emperor
Heh heh
Don't post here.
TV's Frink said:
LuckyGungan2001 said:
Heh heh! Gringo!
Why.
I don't know. Something just gets to me when you see threads from years ago resurrected and in the 1st page. Sue me.
I just want the cover so that I can pretend to have the complete set. So yes, a completionist thing.
Heh heh! Gringo!
Since I had no luck locating an Australian VHS of ROTS, I decided to just see if I can find some people with the UK version, which seems to be far more common. If anyone has one, could they please make some high definition cover scans for me please. The scans on SWONVideo.com are very small and low-res.
Actually you've given me a good idea. I'll change tactics.
Downloading the torrent now.
I tried a while ago, but I gave up as it was too hard, and I didn't know the specifications of the cover.
Asteroid-Man said:
Good call Frink! Seems to be working now. Looks like it'll be about 40 parts. Uploading parts 1-20 now.
Great! I can't wait!
Edit: Yay! New page!
Oh my goodness...
Dude, that's horrible!
Is it up yet?
I'm starting to think that too...
:(
Just downloaded and watched some of this, and it was really good. My favourite part was that the Air Taxi Scene was taken out, as it should be. The CGI in that scene was just not good enough quality compared to the rest of the film.
No, I've been largely successful with finding cover scans of every ROTS VHS except Australia's. I have heard that there are copies that exist, but the internet has no pictures of any kind.
Yet no Aussie ROTS VHS's.
I read that they released an Aussie VHS of ROTS, so I was wondering, if anybody has one, could they perhaps do some cover scans and send them to me?
