logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
26-Jun-2025
Posts
1,464

Post History

Post
#1649059
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

The Dark Side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural. They literally quoted Palpatine from Revenge of the Sith.

Rey was the daughter of his clone. His clone had no force powers and was a disappointment.

how he was able to transfer his soul into another dying clone, and maintain his midichlorians they never explain.

there is no way his body survived the death stars explosion or falling into a reactor. It’s absurd even for Star Wars.

Post
#1649013
Topic
'Rey Skywalker' (Upcoming live action motion picture) - general discussion thread
Time

Was there any news at celebration Japan because I did not hear of such.

Also not a peep about Kinberg’s trilogy either.

And Waititi and Mangold are still working on theirs independently.

Starfighter was greenlit; Rogue Squadron you would think never had existed. Is it memory holed like Rian Johnson’s trilogy, Benioff and Weiss Old Republic trilogy. Lando pretty much disappeared as well.

I swear it’s like half the projects either don’t get made or they take the idea and make it into something else.

Instead of a Boba Fett Bounty Hunter western film you get the Mandalorian. Instead of an Obi-Wan trilogy you get a season of a tv show. Instead of Old Republic you get the High Republic and the Acolyte.

Well to be clear I don’t want a Disney Revan trilogy.

Post
#1648949
Topic
Favorite official non-theatrical non-Special Edition release of each OT movie
Time

The 1990 Pan and Scan or it may have been a 1992 reissue. That is VHS.

If i was to pick a laserdisc its the Special Widescreen Edition for Empire Strikes Back.

And Definitive Collection for the whole trilogy.

For DVD its easily Return of the Jedi PAL Gout. The other two transfers look horrible. In Pal or NTSC. I prefer the PAL THX laserdiscs for those.

Post
#1648551
Topic
What Do YOU Think Star Wars Should Do Next?
Time

I’d like Ronin to become an actual full animated show. Not just two short films/animation.

I’d like a new trilogy of live action films but I don’t what about or who should Star in them.

I kind of don’t know if you can do anything further with the sequel trilogy without pissing large swathes of people off. Or at least online naval gazers.

Disney/Lucasfilm seems to not want to bring anyone back except Daisy as Rey. Probably to hand it off to whoever the next someone is like Luke was supposed to.

But they seem to genuinely not be fussed with getting a script together or timeline to shoot the movie, hell maybe it gets cancelled.

Post
#1648487
Topic
Star Wars Korean LaserDiscs Preservation - Released
Time

Welcome back. I’m looking forward to what you’ve discovered.

I’m also super excited for Indiana Jones if you ever get around to it.

I just pulled out my Hong Kong Return of the Jedi disc and Temple of Doom Korean. Indiana Jones would go into other preservations and fan projects. I’m just talking about foreign releases in general and their unknown qualities.

I’m having problems with my player at the moment though.

I think ROTJ should be uncut in the HK release. It has a nice pan and scan transfer, very good THX deluxe digital LPCM audio. I have to watch the entire film and take notes though.

And Re: the Technidiscs i don’t want to derail your thread. But would like to hear your opinion on them.

Post
#1648470
Topic
If you need to B*tch about something... this is the place
Time

What i can’t get over is the housing moving me into an apartment complex knowing this woman is nuts and makes false complaints and they’ve moved her around but won’t throw her out of the neighborhood. She made false noise complaints to them all last summer and the did not listen because she is a crank, so she calls cops on me when I’m asleep in bed.

And they had the audacity to move me here from my comfortable apartment down the way and lie and say my new neighbors were nice.

They put me in a situation where i can’t live or make any noise. They take my rent money more than i can afford every single month, they hardly seem to care.

Like they don’t care their own irresponsible movers stole important documents of mine, stole and committed theft of expensive items and destroyed valuables. As well as family heirlooms.

I’m ranting i know. But i condemn the entire lot of fools and condo board who bought this neighborhood. Ever since sketchy people work for them come at all hours and the things they allegedly fix they make worse, construction is always going on. The so-called landscaper’s landscape like criminals, i used to landscape i now how to do it properly. You don’t mow a lawn with a weedwhacker.

The people who paint don’t know how to paint looks like someone did it with a blindfold on. They come to fix your doors and windows give you no new screens, and make sure your door closes worse than did before you complained. And not only is your shower impossible to turn on its impossible to turn off, and leaks water into the hallway if you don’t put beach towels or spa size towels in front of it.

The last year has been a nightmare.

I’m determined to somehow hack out an existence even in the mist of high inflation and tariffs. And nothing in the world being constant anymore or making a lick of sense.

Post
#1648293
Topic
An exact quote from Lucas on Greedo shooting first.
Time

I did watch a 1997 press conference for the Special Edition and I thought it was wild, he seems to be saying he always intended for Greedo to shoot first.
Not in those words but if you parse his intent, He says he doesn’t like the idea of Han killing in cold blood because it was not intended.

And this does not reflect how the shoot went down and what Gary Kurtz has said.

If he admitted he didn’t like the message it was sending kids, and that was why he wanted the change I wouldn’t like it, but would understand his motives. The whole Han can’t be a hero or marry Leia if he is killer is laughable and pandering.

Luke nuked an entire space station full of people, those weren’t robots George. I guess 99% were imperial nazis but they had to have some slaves who died on that thing. Or conscripted forces and labor.

Post
#1647564
Topic
Original Trilogy: Korean LaserDisc Release
Time

Hello Enater. Did you find anymore differences. I watched Some of my Hong Kong of Return of the Jedi and so far its not censored or cut. But i will have to watch the rest to confirm. The quality was superior to the Pan and Scan Faces VHS as well with its own varied issues. What surprised me was the quality of the print they telecine or interpositive source. It tells me that Return of the Jedi likely did not need a restoration but Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back did in the 1990s.

That and the proof of LPP quality prints, show prints. Only the 70mm seems to have faded.

Did receive error pressings for the Technidisc labels on wrong side, dead sides etc. It not a test release it is junk basically but watchable.

I do wonder the different releases you can PM me the details or talk about them here. I’m more aware of the Mitsubishi and Pioneer USA, and Pioneer Japan pressings.

Post
#1647314
Topic
ILM - Disney+ 6 part documentary series
Time

I never knew or had forgotten the Throne Room was a Harrison Ellenshaw matte. For years this has been called a cardboard cutout.

Matte painting before digital is kind of a lost art, the best kinds were ones people thought were a normal part of the image and blend in, don’t draw attention to themselves.

Like warehouse in Raiders at area 51.

Ben Kenobi suspended on a platform hundreds of feet above the bottomless depths of the death star.

The Genesis Cave matte painting in Star Trek II.

Post
#1646730
Topic
Info: Mono soundtracks that were butchered with 5.1 remixes in later releases
Time

The Decimator said:

The Mobile Suit Gundam Trilogy of films from the early 80s were “remastered” in 2000 or so. This involved having most of the original actors come in and redub their lines, and adding new, out of place sounds that belong in a PS2 game. Sadly all of the BD releases of these films only include the redubs. The only way Americans are able to experience the original sound design is if you have copies of the VHS with the infamously bad dub.

Another Gundam project with butchered audio is the OVA series Stardust Memory. In 2006, it, like the Trilogy before it, was remastered to 5.1 audio by redubbing all of the dialogue and sound effects. American releases only include the 5.1 mix, while the dub has sound effect alterations of its own, so that should be avoided as well.

I thought they released the original mixes in Japan is that not the case. US is barely a footnote and afterthought for the Japanese industry. Extra money at best but not even a consideration. How many decades have Gundam fans and Macross fans been screwed here. Not to mention to Space Battleship Yamato fans.

Post
#1646729
Topic
<em><strong>ANDOR</strong></em> - Disney+ Series - A General Discussion Thread
Time

Thanks for recommending the series Jason and sticking with it.

I haven’t liked anything else they’ve done recently. Except for Ronin from Visions.

I even think light and magic while initially awesome petered off.

There isn’t much on the Disney service worthy of one’s time and effort to fully digest it.

Andor is well written and has good sets and production values, it does not look completely faked in the volume and cgi. Nor is it insultingly cartoonish.

Post
#1646582
Topic
What's yall's opinion of Brian Daley's Audio Dramas?
Time

As in National Public Radio, John Madden directed Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back. As well as Highbridge audio production of Return of the Jedi.

I have them all on CD in two sets.

I quite enjoy Perry King as Han Solo and Brock Peters as Darth Vader. Mark Hamill is very good in the first two. Tony Daniels is excellent. They even got Billy Dee for Empire. And John Lithgow played Yoda.

Billy Dee nor Mark reprised for JEDI.

But Billy Dee came back for Dark Empire for Time Warner audiobooks, but Mark did not. John Cygan played Luke Skywalker in that.

There are also further radio plays in The Dark Forces trilogy, Crimson Empire, and audiobooks of Dark Empire II and Empire’s End and Tales of the Jedi, and Dark Lords of the Sith.

Brian Daley only did the Star Wars trilogy before he passed away.

Tom Voegli did the NPR trilogy plus Crimson Empire and The Kyle Katarn ones.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but i do not believe there is radio adaptations by fans or books on tape for the Han Solo trilogy by Daley. Only abridged books on tape for the Ann C Crispin books.

Post
#1646144
Topic
Star Wars novels and comics review thread
Time

I think the quality of printing varies some of the Marvel Epic collection appear to be identical in quality to the Dark Horse Omnibus volumes. In other cases, the Dark Horse printings are superior.
I swear in some instances Disney Marvel just dumps the digital file and prints it. I thought Legacy looked bad.

Maybe I got a bad printing, I have no idea.

my opinion and my experience is marvel epic collection print quality is wildly inconsistent vs dark horse Star Wars, your mileage may vary, and there are more than one printing for some of the books. Some have better paper stock than others.

Post
#1646105
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

The different variants for the comics do we really need 3 different versions of Empire Strikes Back. the Dark horse colors in the Omnibus six volume, the original colors in facsimile in original Marvel years. Plus the all new stand alone remastered version. Plus there are 3 different versions of Jedi and 2 of the Roy Thomas comic.

Because the omnibus is the 1997 special edition comic and they didn’t even include the original comic.

Wait I mean 4 versions because you also have the black and white edition scanned from the original art which is very much out of print for the Roy Thomas Star Wars comic, and the Al Williamson The Empire Strikes Back.

And not even getting into variant covers for the hardbacks and the fact they have like 5 different covers per issue of some of their comics.

Post
#1645973
Topic
Your DVD Collection
Time

My Star Trek II and III gold-colored Japanese rental discs come today, and damn aren’t they beautiful even without an OBI.

I haven’t had the time to watch them yet but they are pristine.

Now i just have to wait for Willow Rental with OBI, and Star Wars Technidisc trilogy, and my James Bond 20 film special edition DVD boxed set from UK in PAL to arrive.

Edit:

my technidisc trilogy arrived in better than described condition, i’m pleased as punch. i only wanted star wars so getting empire and jedi is a bonus in my opinion.

I helped them get rid of something from an attic cleanout, i got my films, they got paid a non-criminal fair price, we both win.

Edit: Bond set lost in the mail. Now I have to see if Willow actually arrives. It’s like no package from UK can reach the US for some reason and not get lost.

Willow arrived. with two sealed bonus laserdisc i’ve never heard of some French film and a Bergman film. It’s a wonder it arrived at all considering the seller did not pack it in bubble wrap and uses a standard box meant for shipping oversize magazines or documents. and no bubble wrap or craft paper or cardboard.
It’s slightly suspicious that seller is allegedly in Uk and item was shipped from France using a Swiss delivery company. and it took weeks to get here for an expedited item. But it did arrive.

The James Bond DVD set though is since i was giving a non-tracking tracking number i’m forced to believe the seller never had it in stock or did not want to deal with the tariff situation for a such a large box set.

Post
#1645667
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

As much as George spurred on the digital revolution with ILM and Pixar and the Lucasfilm computer graphics group, i don’t think they are nearly as groundbreaking as the originals. They are more contemporary to the films that were coming out in the age of cgi movies. Where films like the Matrix, and Lord of the Rings, and the Spider-Man movies and Superman Returns existed.

And the MCU is, and Disney Star Wars is like their successor.

They didn’t change the face of cinema. Have they inspired an entire generations imagination. Will they be remembered in 50 years as significant. I can’t answer that because i’m too old for the films to have been made for me. The OT was made for me. By the time prequel fans hit 50 i’ll be long gone or old and gray.