logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
7-Jul-2025
Posts
1,476

Post History

Post
#1544378
Topic
Original Trilogy Edits - some changes are justified
Time

I know Lucasfilm usually does their own in house stuff, but they should have the people who restored Cinderella restore the OT theatrical cuts. Hand it off to Disney. For the first time that movie looks like film again in 4K. They should do that as little DNR as possible, and include the original audio. Just remove the garbage mattes but no other fixes.

Post
#1544369
Topic
The Clone Wars messes up continuity or how Lucas is still destroying star wars.
Time

Basically i’ve given up on the very idea of canon being anything other than a guideline. Since the people making these television and film franchises are just making it up as they go. Whether it is Star Wars, Indiana Jones or Star Trek. Its malleable and not set in stone. That doesn’t mean that a secondary universe should violate its own rules, or lore.

Its all fake isn’t a good excuse for telling a bad story, or making a bad movie. Anymore than saying its a kids movie, or i based it on 1930’s matinee serials so the quality doesn’t matter.

Post
#1544085
Topic
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic - General Discussion thread (KotOR, KotOR II)
Time

I still wonder what happened to Revan. In the unmade Kotor 3. I don’t accept the story they gave us in the book and in the old republic. It doesn’t fit with the story of Kotor 2 the Sith Lords.

Kotor I was very familiar to the original film Star Wars, it wasn’t as original as II.The Revan twist was the only really novel thing about it.

Post
#1544081
Topic
'Rey Skywalker' (Upcoming live action motion picture) - general discussion thread
Time

Sounds like someone just took the news from celebration, that Kathy Kennedy interview and the previous Lindelof story and ran with it. Only changing the timeline from 100 years after TROS to 15 years. It is far too early for any story synopsis. The only trade i trust is Variety. Most of their scoops were based on fact or from info directly from the people at Lucasfilm. the only other i’ve found reliable is Vanity Fair.

Edit: I also hope they can get Oscar Isaac and John Boyega back but this doesn’t look like its going to be episode 10. The only connection to that trilogy is Daisy/Rey. I also think Mark Hamill despite some fans concerns is absolutely not needed in this movie the torch was passed. We need new worlds and new characters and to expand outward not shrinking the galaxy. I also hope the Empire is barely touched on, though wouldn’t mind a little bit of world building about the state of the galaxy and New Republic. And no new Sith,a new challenge/foe would be preferable.

Post
#1543794
Topic
'Rey Skywalker' (Upcoming live action motion picture) - general discussion thread
Time

Well i don’t know i’d be interested if they can make a Star Wars film that would get me back again and engaged. as is all the plus shows far too many, and all the Disney EU to much to follow. I’m not looking for a homework assignment like with the Disney MCU to follow continuity.

At least the sequel trilogy you could come in and watch them and you didn’t need supplementary material to watch them.

But clearly that Star Wars era i love and hold dear is done and over. With Mark Hamill announcing retiring the role of Luke Skywalker. I already walked away from this franchise with episode 9. I wanted to watch the Obi Wan thing but i never finished it. That was the only thing sort of tangentially connected to Lucas Star Wars with the prequel actors.

Its just a bunch of fanfiction now really. There are a lot of things to enjoy if you care to dip your toe in. I’m far too old to begin my fandom again. Throwing away years of EU i understand why they did it but that was where my fandom was along with the original trilogy and prequel films. Disney SW feels like a reset.

Post
#1543607
Topic
Why are people like this?
Time

You can support the artist and still say its a BS position to not release the original cuts of his movies. I include American Graffiti and THX 1138 in this not just the Star Wars trilogy. Lucas is really his own worst enemy. Why not just release the movies the same way they looked and their original audio as catalog titles for Lucasfilm, Or at least allow Disney to do so. George might not like how grainy they look in a new 4K scan, but i would be phenomenally grateful to own the original Techniscope photography of THX and Graffiti. the DNR versions are trash. The cgi is garbage.

Post
#1541050
Topic
What changes would you make to the Sequels?
Time

The thing is Force Awakens and Last Jedi are far from perfect but the third film should have been where they should have stuck the landing. Instead they made a film worse than Return of the Jedi. I like Rey more as the adopted niece and a nobody than a Palpatine. Finn isn’t the only character they failed they also just about erased Rose. I mean i get it its Rey’s story and Finn and Rose are supporting roles, but they got even worse than Han and Leia did in ROTJ.

The third one introduced new characters i very much liked like Zorri Bliss, and Jannah. But in adding more characters it was overstuffed no room for Rose Tico?

Post
#1541049
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

I really enjoyed Dungeons and Dragons with Chris Pine. A fun movie and doesn’t try to be anything more than it is.

I also watched Shazam Fury of the Gods, loved the first one. This was terrible. Bad cgi, lackluster villains. Poor performances. Even the Wonder Woman scene which was fun didn’t save it. It reminded me of those Percy Jackson movies and Jessica Alba Fantastic 4 movies except worse. The best i thing i can say is it wasn’t offensive at all and is a decent family movie, but it is also one of the worst DC Superhero movies ever made.

Post
#1540463
Topic
Are you glad Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney or do you wish he hadn’t?
Time

I’m glad he sold in a way and also upset they won’t continue Legends as a separate timeline.

I’m not going to pretend i wouldn’t have watched Lucas sequels had they been made. I’m also not going to pretend the idea of Darth Maul as the big bad wasn’t a stupid idea, and bringing in Darth Taalon from the EU. Lazy and hamfisted.

Leia leading the New Republic sounds awesome. Han being a leader in the rebellion sounds great, Luke training new Jedi cool. Just not the training younglings thing. And the worst aspect Whills and Midichlorians, why?

Post
#1540459
Topic
What do you think of the <strong>Sequel Trilogy</strong>? - a general discussion thread
Time

Luke has a story in between 6 and 7. Lucasfilm for some reason just hasn’t told it beyond a couple cameos, a comic book and a novel. The sequel trilogy isn’t at fault for that though nor is Rian Johnson. The sequel trilogy is Rey’s trilogy not about Luke. Its not about Anakin either. It really didn’t even need to have the OT actors at all and could even have been set in the far future. Because they do very little at all they were window dressing. They are touchstones of memory. Remember Luke, Remember Han, Remember Leia. Fan service for Gen X fans. Even down to largely following the same style and story beats of the originals. Rebels Vs Empire. Jedi Vs Sith.

The actual world building is shallow and poor. Bordering on imitation. We know nothing about the state of the New Republic, or how the resistance became to be. We no nothing of the origins of the first order or the state of the Empire. And we never see the Return of the Jedi. I hate to say it but the prequel did a better job at world building than actual flavor of the story or likeable characters which the sequel did better. And the OT did better than both. But it was a smaller story and more contained.

I will say going back to the adventure style of the OT was enjoyable actually and i initially really enjoyed Force Awakens because it brought that style of good Star Wars back. It only took me awhile to realize well of course i liked it i love the 1977 film. I understand what George Lucas meant when he said Disney made a fan movie, that did nothing new.

I will always like Rey, Poe, Finn and Rose and i wish the movies were better.

Post
#1538244
Topic
JURASSIC PARK 35mm 4K scan + 35mm 4k scans of many trailers Mega Project including the rare Spiderman Twin Towers Teaser, Blade Runner, Pretty In Pink and numerous, some rare, others, see post (WIP - 6.5K scans of JP and trailers complete. Scan data now in hand! Funding of the project is a little past half-way now. Contributor only project for feature. I can't publicly distribute it. Small preservation project.)
Time

The amazing thing is i bet your Bring it On trailer is better than the actual film on blu-ray which is quite lackluster.

Post
#1538228
Topic
What's the most heated Star Wars argument you've gotten into?
Time

Over the Last Jedi. I defended it as a good movie. Not sure i was right. I desperately wanted it to be. It still has elements of a good movie in it even with all its mixed parts good and bad.

I’m not going to take back what i said about Mark Hamill’s performance i think it was great and i still do.

The Abrams movies i really have to be in a sort of mood to watch, they are bad fanfiction. But can be fun if you turn your mind off.

My brother and i never really don’t like the same things in regards to SW. He hated the EU wouldn’t even give Heir to the Empire 5 minutes of his time because it wasn’t real Star Wars. He likes the Disney TV stuff, beyond the animated stuff i don’t. I like the SW comics he won’t bother with them or the novels or games because they aren’t real SW.

He likes the prequels i despise them, except for a soft spot for Phantom Menace. He says Episode III is the best one. He doesn’t mind Han shooting second or Hayden in ROTJ i do.

My brother in law also loves Disney SW and hated the prequel, and he liked the Last Jedi and honestly thought people were crazy over hating that movie. His own son hated it so much.

Post
#1538224
Topic
It seems like nobody involved in the making of the Original Trilogy has spoken up about George Lucas’ oppression of the unaltered theatrical version of the OT.
Time

The strangest thing is George Lucas promised Kershner final cut on Empire. The Special Edition is going back on his word and changing a film he didn’t direct. Worse on Return of the Jedi Richard Marquand was dead and couldn’t be consulted or asked. Only on the first film did he have a right as the director to change the movie. Still should have preserved the original for posterity.

Post
#1538220
Topic
The Weeb topic
Time

Don’t consider myself a Weeb. But i like Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex season 1 and 2, and Cowboy Bebop and Outlaw Star. I liked Soul Eater quite a bit, and Samurai Champloo but the ending was kind of meh.

I really liked the first season of Fireforce and the second season less so. But its not Soul Eater good. And the amount of fan service can distract from the overall story.

Liked the First season of Demon Slayer as well.

One Punch man was good for a few laughs.