Ice

adywan said:

The Stardestroyer chase was flat. compare this sequence to those in the OT, especially ESB with the stardestroyer chasing the falcon, and you will see what i mean. The stardestoyer itself looked more 90’s CG than the quality we have come to expect from ILM today.

I thought the star destroyer looked great. It was CGI, but like Rogue One, it was CGI meant to look like a model, not a space ship

Release order > Chronological order

There’s another twist ruined by watching them in chrono order - the identity of Yoda

Master Lawdog said:

Darth Porg fixed Anakin’s appearance and made the shots available to download in 4K. Link is in the description.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhPmdlUuwOI

Now we just have to add traffic in the sky

That would ruin the twist in TESB entirely.

Oh, I agree!
I don’t want this in any edit; I just think it would be a fun thing to do

Although I don’t think it’s necessary, seeing Guiness’ “Anakin” from ROTJ dubbed in place over the “Darth” would be an interesting excercise for sure. The mouth would have to be animated a little extra

fmalover said:

OK. After five episodes what’s the general consensus among you guys? Is this series worth watching?

I feel no real desire to watch it.

I like it. It isn’t perfect, but it’s entertaining, and I only want to be entertained, not analyze everything to pieces

Was there de-aging done in the flashbacks? I couldn’t tell if it was used conservatively or not at all, but either way both actor’s looked great!

Anchorhead said:

Tiny nit-pick; The tracking device has been done. Come up with another way.

I think this is their way to tie into the OT a little; maybe that’s why Leia is so certain that “they let us go” in ANH; she’s seen it happen before.

How many people can fit in a T-47 now?

A child in the backseater’s lap maybe… but an additional adult?

I’m interested 😃

RogueLeader said:

I’m curious, do you really think that character is dead? I thought it was surprising but I have no doubt they’re gonna get put in a bacta tank and healed up.

Are we even sure it’s the same character? “Grand Inquisitor” is just a title after all

May I have a link please?

SparkySywer said:

All three of them have higher highs and way more interesting stuff than TCW

I disagree. Seasons 6-7 of the clone wars had incredible highs and depth not found in the films

Basically it boils down to this:

The prequels are a fantastic story with subpar execution.
The sequels are fantastic execution of a subpar story.

I’m thinking that the entire epilogue with Din meeting Luke and Ahsoka might be better saved for a fanedit of Mando season 3; it’s completely separate from the main plot of the whole film. Just my opinion of course.

Don’t forget to listen to “Rebel mission to Ord Mandell” before ESB. Only 30min.
Unfortunately the main voice cast are all different.

In the final space battle, I’d like to see an interdictor star destroyer, it makes sense for the Empire to try to prevent the rebels from escaping. This can then be one of the star destroyers later seen being destroyed during the battle

It would make it weird because the Ewoks seem unknown to everyone, hardly the case if they were on a moon of the capital

NabooDuck said:

If the movie starts with Luke constructing his lightsaber, it would be better if he doesn’t ignite the blade? For a surprise and impact reason in the sail barge action scene

Agreed

I just listened to the radio drama.

The opening sequence is:

Luke in Ben’s hut contructing lightsaber helped by R2
Droids go to Jabba’s palace -> Sarlaac battle
Vader arrives on DSII

I feel that any prequel is always intended to be watched in release order; ie the very fact that it is a prequel means that it should be watched with the knowledge of the film that comes after it.

Chronological order ruins the viewing experience, at least for a first-time viewer (people who have seen all films can choose any order).

Someone here made clever edits of the ewok battle combined with footage from one of the ewok movies:

https://streamable.com/hz7s3

https://streamable.com/buy7x

Currently working on something else, so can’t spend to much time on audio, but here’s a gif of the idea.

As Han and Leia stand up, we hear the sound of SPURS. They stop, Leia looks up, and she sees Boba Fett aiming his gun at them. Leia is frozen in shock. HARD CUT to Han being thrown into a cell. He reunites with Chewie. Afterward, we cut back to Leia. The whole palace is now awake, and she is brought before Jabba.

THAT is a kickass idea that I can totally see working!

Haarspalter said:

I think a lot of goodwill towards ROTS comes from the fans which grew up with the Clone Wars animated series.

I’m a fan of the clone wars series, and yes, it gives necessary context to the PT as a whole and the characters. As much as I like the series though, it wouldn’t be needed if the PT was written better

IMO

The prequels are a fantastic story with sub-par execution.

The sequels are a fantastic execution of a sub-par story.