logo Sign In

Goji

User Group
Members
Join date
25-Apr-2010
Last activity
12-Dec-2012
Posts
5

Post History

Post
#571302
Topic
Cropping the Original Trilogy : 35mm vs dvd (gout)
Time

I apologize for having such a "newbie" question, but are the GOUT releases cropped because that's how the letterbox '93 transfers always looked on home video, or because they were always non-anamorphic to begin with? What would have happened had Lucasfilm made GOUT versions anamorphic on the 2006 DVD's? Because from the looks of it, it doesn't seem like we would have gotten more (horizontal) picture anyway if the '93 transfer was already cropped to begin with.

From reading this topic, it seems all home video releases of GOUT are cropped in one way or another =/

Anyways, I apologize if there is something I'm not understanding here. I still have a lot to learn about the various aspect ratios, and how classic films are adapted for home video (and how they were prior to more modern formats like DVD/BD).

 

Post
#419761
Topic
"Alert my Star Destroyer to prepare for my arrival." What was the point?
Time

It would be interesting if this line is re-inserted into the Blue Ray version of the SE of EMPIRE, but I sincerely doubt it. If anything, I'm pretty sure we're in store for more negative changes.

Honestly, the only added scene to the SE that I truly love is the Wampa sequence in EMPIRE. Being a big fan of suitmation, I was absolutely floored by the Wampa costume when I first saw it. The shot of him sitting up with the blood dripping down from his mouth, and then shuffling over to Luke looks absolutely fantastic.

While it kind of demystified the Wampa a little bit (you get very quick shots of it in the original trilogy, and is always seemed like an "elusive" creature, what being able to blend in with his environment and creeping on unsuspecting victims!), I felt it was a fine addition to the SE version of EMPIRE, and I still stand by that. The other changes, I could DEFINITELY live without.

The changing of Boba Fett's voice and the sequence with the Emperor (in the 2004 version) are the two things that down right piss me off, and make the SE of EMPIRE almost completely unwatchable for me.