FVDnz

Just watched the first of the 3 episodes and I have to say, fantastic work!

Just a minor criticism though, which is mainly the Closing Credits. I don’t recall Bail Organa and Darth Vader featuring in the episode where they had credits and Genevieve O’Reilly didn’t actually have a credit either. Just thought I give that a mention, otherwise brilliant job!

And perhaps while it’s still called Andor, shouldn’t Diego Luna still have top billing?

Thanks for the links, mate. While I haven’t begun to watch your edits yet (3 more episodes to finish Season 2 to go), it will be a shame that Jimmy Smits was unavailable to reprise Bail Organa. And Genevieve O’Reilly has been brilliant as Mon Mothma as well.

doubleofive said:

asterisk8 said:

ThiscouldbeR2D2 said:

That guy with no name said:

ThiscouldbeR2D2 said:

Honestly, I’m starting to get very fearful right now.

What are you talking about? Are you ok?

Sorry, I just feel extremely worried about all these things that kept getting in the way of the Revisited edits being finished.

Pretty selfish viewpoint, no? Not “I’m worried about adywan” but “I’m worried I won’t get to see Revisited.”

To be fair, it’s entirely possible that Adywan has been working on Revisited for this user’s entire life. 😉

Revisited will be finished before George R.R. Martin releases The Winds of Winter… 😄

I kinda like the idea of the deleted scene of Luke’s lightsaber reveal actually taking place on Dagobah after his conversation with Yoda. I don’t know if we should have the conversation with Obi-Wan including the revelation of Leia at the beginning though. Maybe it can still be added later?

Clearly, I overlooked that detail. All good…

May I request a link too, please?

After picking up the Arrow Bruce Lee films in London recently, my greatest wish is to have Arrow work on the James Bond films.

timdiggerm said:

Funnily enough, the recent comics have added all kinds of hijinks to Fett’s life between obtaining Solo and delivering him to Jabba.
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Boba_Fett#Hunt_for_Nakano_Lash and everything after that

From what I understand, it is indeed stupid

Guess it is fair enough not to show Boba delivering Han after all. You’re right about the taking 1 year to get to Jabba bit. It actually reminds me of reading Shadows of the Empire many years ago with what Boba already went through, evading other Bounty Hunters to get to Jabba in the first place.

nightstalkerpoet said:

Considering 3P0 mentions Chewie not coming back as they’re on the way to the palace, would it be feasible to cut the scene of Leia arriving in disguise and handing over Chewie? Just cut straight to her sneaking in to free Han, getting captured, and we first see Chewie as Han arrives in the cell. Makes the plan less convoluted.

I’ve been liking this idea since reading Mac’s big list of ideas actually. Somebody on Facebook came up with a suggestion to begin the film with Slave One arriving on Tattooine delivering Han to Jabba, but I guess we got a decent reveal of Han in Carbonite when the Droids delivered Luke’s message (can it be improved upon? :p)…

adywan said:

Quick update:

https://www.facebook.com/swrevisited/posts/pfbid02MGc6EQrpgkXhMQcLDZXnxg4YV9GRqY9furbPAxU9tVd4QKbQ8dxGt7eJk8LCnGirl

Annual pay-rise and bonus coming up next month. I’ll be sure to contribute once again. 😃

It would also be awesome to see the DSII in full circumference during the space battle too, over seeing the same position throughout the film. Plenty of opportunities there, not to mention the Executor’s destruction.

I love the idea of two SD’s escorting the Executor coming into view at the beginning of the film. If something like this can be done, that would be amazing! Just doesn’t make sense using a normal SD really. Would look cool seeing them come out of lightspeed and Endor Prime actually appearing in view.

And it would be cool to see how expansive Home One could be too…

May I also have a link, pretty please… 😃

I basically sacrificed most of my bedtime where I funnily enough, accidentally stumbled upon this thread where I must have clicked it while falling asleep during Ady’s ANH:R HD thread - and then I saw this upon waking. So I kept reading and decided to continue after I woke up later.

.Mac. - I loved how you structured the story and it would be amazing if Ady even adopted some of your ideas into ROTJ:R. With the way technology is scarily progressing lately especially in the advent of AI, maybe some of your ideas can be achieved?! And as for Crix Madine - not a bad idea to recast I suppose. Upon reading, I was automatically kinda wondering what if YouTuber Dave Cullen could be considered or interested in such an endeavour? I know he’s a Lore nerd and everything, but I’m sure we can find other actors out there. 😃

Once again, nice work!

I believe Revolver from the recent boxset with the new stereo remix, has an unaltered Mono Mix on one of the CD’s. The singles Paperback Writer and Rain are also featured in Mono.

Still wish there was a Bluray included with Hi-Res mixes though (though there are Hi-Res files digitally available including the Mono mix). I enjoyed the new stereo mix so having a lossless Atmos mix too would have been amazing!

Class316 said:

For those interested it seems someone restored the Kostal version and uploaded it to archive.org. Just google “fantasia Kostal” and it will be in the top results.

Man, if the multitracks for this soundtrack are still available, this could use a good 5.1/Dolby Atmos mix to compliment the visual quality more. Thanks for sharing…

grayz2001 said:

Disney+ and Peter Jackson answered yalls prayers lmao

Very true, however, I’m hoping that one day, Get Back will get the same film quality treatment “descrubbing” the image quality and going the Let It Be route by showing the series in the 4:3 aspect ratio. Some continuity would be wonderful…

Fantastic! May I have a link to your labours, please (or do I need to PM?)…

I’ve never actually watched the films but I’ll definitely watch a fan edit if it’s going to remove much of the fluff. Count me in too please. 😃

Humby said:

Rebel Scummm said:

Hello. Any news on this wonderful project?

Every time I see this thread get upped a small part of me gets super excited as though “IT’s FINALLY OUT!!!”

But nope, no updates on any of his socials in a while I believe. A comment (maybe on reddit?) that he’s still working on it from a few months ago.

He seems like a good-faith fan editor, and he’s been pretty honest about his progress & delays. I’d bet, at this point, that he’s just planning on waiting a few months for holiday season. Until another update, I’m crossing my fingers for sometime in December.

It’ll be out before The Winds of Winter, that much I will guarantee… 😏

Only found out yesterday that the edit was released when KP himself released a video on YouTube detailing the process. Will watch this evening. 😃

TDS91939 said:

Yes!! And Justice for Jason… Wait that sounds familiar

I see what you did there (justice for St Anger too)… 😄

And I can confirm that the mp4 files work with the USB connected to my TV. Methinks, I’ll look at converting your mkv files to mp4 format, as that usually tends to be a solution. Greatly appreciating the work thus far! 😃

Yup. After watching Nerdrotic’s review of Episode 6 of The Acolyte, that audio assisted description of the scene of the “Sith” bathing scene definitely sounded like something out of a romance novel. This is Star Wars?!

Hey, cheers for the headsup! I’ll see what happens with my PS5 (can try the Bluray player too). 😃

And it’s all good about the file sizes. Might look into those Plex servers you speak of, however, I may even try mp4 instead of mkv and see if that may even work. At this stage, my current HD doesn’t seem to be supported on either PS5 or my Panasonic Bluray player - and it’s not necessarily that old either. Could try an SSD perhaps…