Elyk

I just finished watching this edit and as I have come to expect from Smudger’s work, am very impressed. I don’t really have anything to add that hasn’t already been mentioned in the thread. I very much enjoy the flow of the narrative, and am very thankful for how much time, effort and creativity you put into your work. I am looking forward to seeing how all of the edits evolve as more content is added. On a slightly different topic, I know in the past you have said you don’t want to revisit your Clone Wars edits, and I am sure you are tired of the question. However, with you dipping your metaphorical toe back into animated editing with the Bad Batch, has your position softened on this? I know I and many others would love to see your completed vision for that series. I do understand that BB is a much less onerous lift than CW but I can’t help but hold out hope! Regardless, thank you for this edit and for your willingness to share. Looking forward to Episode IV!

Watched the edit recently. I think that Smudger has done an excellent job. It was a lot of fun to see the creative choices you made to make the story work and stay within your time limit constraints. I think all of my minor critiques have already been mentioned, so I won’t rehash anything. Just wanted to offer my sincere thanks for the time and effort you put into this edit. It’s a great gift for fans that are looking for an alternate, but still quite satisfying way to watch this story. I am eagerly waiting for episode 2.