Destinyg133

Yea i could wait for v2 of ROTS

For the OT i have both harmy’s trilogy and 4k projects

For the TPM, I only have adywans, which was okay, but rly want higher quality, and im actually excited for 4k scan from zigzag.
And BR for AOTC and ROTS, but will ask scorhman for his copy’s to fufill my collection. Too bad i have to bother him cause I dont have myspleen.

Also thanks for info, that will help others aswell

I wish MS actually open his application after 3 years, so i dont have to bother him

Anyways, thanks for info

ChainsawAsh said:

Destinyg133 said:

Before I made a post, I was looking trough forums for 5 straight hours, reading all of ya posts. 4k scan does indeed sound great.

Too bad I don’t own myspleen. Im very interested in Schorman’s HDTV preservation. Care to help if you have some free time? Couldn’t find it on my other private trackers

Send Schorman a private message.

If his preservation is finished, i will message him, thanks for informing me

Before I made a post, I was looking trough forums for 5 straight hours, reading all of ya posts. 4k scan does indeed sound great.

Too bad I don’t own myspleen. Im very interested in Schorman’s HDTV preservation. Care to help if you have some free time? Couldn’t find it on my other private trackers

Hello guys,
Wanted to ask a question what is best copy of preserved PT to be closest to theatrical cut in terms of quality

I do have adywans TPM, but was wondering if something new popped up.

Thank you in advance!

stretch009 said:

Destinyg133 said:

Well guys, just wanted to give ya info, version i got few days ago from usenet is not theatrical cut, its 3 mins longer, so i assume i got dvd version, now i feel very bad for not having access to myspleen, i probablly should not do this, but could anyone PM me theatrical cut, if they have free time ^^

Check your PMs it will tell you exactly where to find it on Usenet.

TY, got it 😄

Well guys, just wanted to give ya info, version i got few days ago from usenet is not theatrical cut, its 3 mins longer, so i assume i got dvd version, now i feel very bad for not having access to myspleen, i probablly should not do this, but could anyone PM me theatrical cut, if they have free time ^^

Puggo - Jar Jar’s Yoda said:

The only way I can bear to watch the prequels is with all the gaggy stuff still in. At least then there’s something to cringe at. Remove that and they’re just boring. And I couldn’t conceive of TPM without my favorite character in all of prequeldom, the legendary CPY.

For these reasons I prefer the original DVDs.

Thank you, i got adywans theatrical editition tho ^^

ChainsawAsh said:

Not popular enough for someone to upload it to a public tracker, and even if someone did I’d be shocked if it was still seeded.

Got my version, “TPM_AVCHD_ADYWAN” 7.85gb, converted it myself to MKV, hopefully that one is with fixed sound?, here is mediainfo from mkv https://hastebin.com/newutejuta.sql

schorman13 said:

I humbly suggest you download the 5.1 track from my LD audio archive as a replacement. It’s fully synchronized and it hasn’t been re-encoded, as adywan’s original was.

And where can i find this?

stretch009 said:

Destinyg133 said:

stretch009 said:

Destinyg133 said:

Does anyone still posses adywan’s realease with fixed audio, i would love to have this in my collection but cant find it anywhere

Usenet.
Myspleen.

Was thinking to get it without paying for usenet service and myspleen is just private tracker that i dont have access to 😕

There are free trials for Usenet providers.

Allright, ill try to find it there
Still confused, why is it posted there,and not elsewhere like harmy’s despecialized

stretch009 said:

Destinyg133 said:

Does anyone still posses adywan’s realease with fixed audio, i would love to have this in my collection but cant find it anywhere

Usenet.
Myspleen.

Was thinking to get it without paying for usenet service and myspleen is just private tracker that i dont have access to 😕

screams in the void said:

I enjoyed the fan edit of episode 3 called Dark Force Rising by Kerr . It made for a much tighter story and eliminated the most cringe worthy parts . But that’s just like , my opinion man .

I respect all opinions, altho i have decided to go for adywan’s theatrical editition for TPM, i just need to get my hands on it
And for ep II and III ill watch bluray ones probablly since there arent many difference, only major one being cgi yoda, i wont mind him, so watching II and III BR only for quality

Does anyone still posses adywan’s realease with fixed audio, i would love to have this in my collection but cant find it anywhere

ZigZig said:

Destinyg133 said:

Im asking cause someone mentioned minor oversight and i did not understood meaning of that)

This: http://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/635417

thank you, then for sure il get my hands on adywans reconsruction for TPM

Well then for TPM ill definitly go for theatrical cut, laserdisc one or adywans theatrical cut(this one is only better quality right?, Im asking cause someone mentioned minor oversight and i did not understood meaning of that)

So as far as PT goes, it kinda doesnt matter which version im going for? Only OT was altered to the point of serious changing?

ZigZig said:

I think that TPM desserves to be watched in its theatrical version: all that was boring in theaters is even more boring on Blu-ray (the podrace, which was already very long in theaters, is now endless; the added taxi scene just gives you more of Jar Jar; CGI-Yoda adds more videogame-like CGI air to the movie…).
But the only current way to see the theatrical version of TPM is a Laserdisc preservation or Adywan’s reconstruction (which is not in HD, and contains some minor oversights).

Tbh i was thinking about TPM in theatrical, and i saw on forums adywans version, but what do you mean by some minor oversights

I have no idea why prequels are so hated, but soon i find out right after choosing which one to see, i know bluray are called canon ones, and in OT theatrical were best ones and i agree for OT part
What do fanedits give that make TP more watchable
I want to have best experience watching but still see what was wrong with it

I just watched OT despecialized and i think Harmy did great job on bringing back OT in better quality, but im in dilema about PT, and what version should i watch, theatrical version, dvd version, bluray version or fanedit (and why)
Hopefully you guys can help me out with this one, just please dont go offtrack
ty in advance and may the force be with you all