logo Sign In

Broom Kid

User Group
Members
Join date
3-Sep-2019
Last activity
8-Nov-2026
Posts
1,057
Web Site
https://linktr.ee/straightcutsnochaser

Post History

Post
#1694652
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time

losthead said:

Their functions are not the same, that’s the entire point. A human doing that job is a vital ingredient that cannot be replaced by a machine, no matter how advanced AI becomes. AI can mimic the look, feel, and sound of a movie, but the pacing, intention, message, and soul cannot be replicated without a human.

Further - the equivalence between “person feeding prompts into a busted algorithm” to “producer hiring writers” is false from jump. Feeding prompts into an LLM isn’t film production. It’s not the same skills, and even if you wanted to equate broken agents to human beings in terms of skill and ability, it’s not the same sort of labor, either.

The only thing that’s even remotely similar is the idea of there being a heirarchy, but even in that case, you have to fold yourself practically in half to pretend the hierarchy applies to the person prompting the algorithm to spit out a facsimile of creation that will mostly work only in the case of the viewer not really paying attention, and not knowing what to look for (or look at) even when they are.

Post
#1694651
Topic
Addressing prequel revisionism
Time

NFBisms said:

can’t wait for the sequel revisionism era that’ll be fun

I don’t think it’ll ever happen. Rise of Skywalker was basically pronounced irredeemable by the 2nd or 3rd week at the latest, and The Last Jedi is too tightly tied to the specific online moment it became almost a horcrux for. I’ve seen people try re-evaluating/re-assessing the film, as a film, but it inevitably becomes a layup line for people who have never stopped reciting the same rote arguments that got laser-etched into granite in 2018. The Last Jedi is an excuse to relive a unique period in time when Social Media was both its most influential and also it’s most toxic, simultaneously. The movie’s quality as a movie simply can’t be allowed to be the sole topic of a thing (as I just demonstrated) because it’s unavoidable, even now, 10 years later, to discuss it without a decade of accumulated “culture war” bullshit bubbling up and scalding everyone.

TFA might get a reclamation maybe (especially if Starfighter winds up going over well) but that was basically always generally liked as a delicious, frothy glass of pure sugar in the first place.

Post
#1694500
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time

Bingowings said:

Every fan editor is manipulating trademarked and copyright intellectual and artistic content.

This is true, definitely, but I think the difference comes in the intentionality and the decisionmaking behind the edits, the juxtaposition of shots, the way this affects and alters narrative. Editing is an art in and of itself. But you can’t edit artfully unless something has been created first, full stop. Novels, songs, movies… anything! That doesn’t make the act of editing uncreative in and of itself, though. The reliance on having something to work with doesn’t remove the art from editing - nor does the art inherent in editing innately make it good. Most of the art made by most of the people isn’t good art. A ton of it is awful. But it is still art because it’s people making deliberate artistic choices as a real human expression.

It’s the intentionality, and the creative decisionmaking, and the skill (or lack thereof) applied together to create something. In the case of fan-editing: yeah it’s illegal at its core, but there’s a reason all the best fanedits that everyone knows about are examples of an editor (or editors), taking material, and making something compelling out of it via their choices. They’re taking what they have to work with, and actively, thoughtfully, intentionally working it. The art is obvious and self-evident, whether it’s a “fix” or a full-blown transformation of style and tone.

Using algorithms to generate a facsimile of creativity, arrived at by averaging the scraped data of prior works and synthesizing an imitation of what it thinks a user wants, is not a creative act. the thing “creating” is incapable of thinking, much less feeling, much less being able to understand why the juxtaposition of images, the movement of shapes and bodies in the frame, are eliciting emotions or connecting dots. It can’t know, and won’t ever know, because it’s an algorithm, it’s not a person. And what it spits out when you prompt it isn’t a creative act.

algorithm-generated imagery is off, and is always off, no matter how detailed the imagery continues to become, because the algorithm doesn’t know why the camera moves the way it does, or why the shot is framed the way it is, why it’s lit the way it is. Same with vocal performances. It doesn’t understand why the inflections are placed where they are, why certain quavers and tremors communicate things in a line in a way that shouting or whispering won’t.

I understand the increasing usage of AI as a substitute for creativity, because it’s easy, and it’s “close enough” for people who don’t want more than surface-level entertainment; especially if the person generating and then watching doesn’t have a good understanding of why the art they like actually works. Not everyone cares! They don’t HAVE to, to be entertained! And in fanediting especially, the appeal of having access to something that gives you the ability to say you made something - without knowing how, or even being able to actually make it, not in just having the means, but having the skill or the ability - is REALLY strong.

The devaluation of art into “content” for the past decade has normalized people accepting artless content as a primary media diet. And the ease of “content creation” has been increasingly welcomed in the niche fanedit community, where a TON of the output is clearly only made for the ability to say in a post or a tweet or a thread that you ‘fixed’ or ‘made’ something so you can put your name in the credits, and put your name on the poster - frequently, the AI-generated poster, that also has telltale signs that a human being never made any part of it. A machine that spits out superficial content is a godsend for people who see what they do, unironically, as “content creation” and who edit things for the sake of having something to share so they can see “engagement” go up.

A ton of pro-AI rhetoric tends to cop to this as the driving “creative” impulse more often than not - it gets framed as a sort of democratization of art, the free distribution of tools they’d otherwise be prevented, an opportunity to show the people behind the gate that they don’t NEED to be behind that gate, they can do it from here, with some judicious prompts and enough tokens and drops of water and all the prior created works an algorithm can scrape.

But it’s not the democratization of art, it’s the devaluation of it. It’s the ceding of thought, of creativity, to a faulty algorithm; and lowering the bar for what art could be, so that it sits an inch or two below the best result that algorithm can cough up. If you ask an algorithm to take over the creative impulse, you’ll only ever get disconnected facsimiles of what people have already done. And plugging those into human-created, collaborative, intentionally executed art is always going to be jarring, no matter how detailed those scenes might be, because the lack of humanity in the “creation” will always shine through. Especially if “creation” itself is devalued to the point that algorithmic regurgitations and amalgamations of real art by people who don’t understand what they’re doing and don’t want to - actually counts.

Breathing scrubbed oxygen will keep your lungs working. But it’ll never replace fresh air.

Post
#1692959
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Anakin doesn’t fall to the Dark Side because he has “mommy issues.” He falls because he’s consumed by his selfish desire to control what he can’t control so that he never has to experience the pain of losing what he cares about.

That is first (and consistently) exemplified by his attachment to his mother. The attachment to his mother as a kid is the entry point into this idea and the formative aspect of his character you’re describing. The way he chose to build in a “fatal flaw” that leads to his turning in Episode III was to decide that what would turn him into a control freak was losing his mother; which is why he got de-aged in Episode I, because he wanted to make sure that initial trauma was so strong. Again: He arrives at a bad idea, then comes up with worse ideas (why can’t she just come along? Because Jedi take kids, because they’re a weird cult now, oh, and she’s also a slave. Why can’t jedi free slaves? It’s not their job. etc. etc. etc) to justify the initial bad one instead of just CHANGING THE INITIAL BAD IDEA.

Of course, this gets confused by all the “prophecy” stuff anyway, but the character didn’t NEED to have a “fatal flaw” in the first place like that. He decided to root his control freak tendencies in losing his mom, which became losing his wife. But it never needed to be rooted in losing his mom at all - and if he wanted Anakin to be a control freak, there are other ways around it other than mommy issues that then get transferred onto his wife.

Lucas hemmed himself in and then kept sewing anyway.

Post
#1692908
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

The idea that what caused Anakin’s turn was mommy issues, was not an idea that needed to be implemented at all. A huge part of why the de-aging from 13 to 8 even happened was precisely because due to this: the only idea that seemed to occur to Lucas re: why Anakin might turn, was that he’s emotionally damaged from being separated from mom.

From this one idea that he just would not move off of, you wind up with Anakin becoming a little kid, Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon becoming two different people, Anakin’s mom being a slave, a weird/awkward relationship setup with Padme and the shoving of the relationship between Obi-Wan and Anakin to a completely different movie.

Had he not stuck so hard to the idea that Anakin even HAD to have some sort of fatal flaw ingrained in him via childhood to “explain” his turn (or his susceptibility to being turned) none of that likely would have happened, and there’d have been a much more understandable/relatable version of Anakin to begin with.

So much of the Prequels is written in this way, too: He arrives at an idea - it’s not good - and then starts coming up with other bad ideas as a way to paper over the initial bad one, and then you’re left with nothing super solid to build on.

Post
#1692768
Topic
Lucas once again tries to justify his Special Edition alterations: "Fans are doing it."
Time

What’s controversial (or new) about this? He’s given a version of this line in almost every interview in the last 40 years. “Movies are taken away - I wanted to finish it” usually there’s like a percentage or whatever.

Like, this isn’t justification so much as his saying “even the people who get mad at me about changing things now just change everybody’s movies, too”

Which is, ironically, mostly what a place called “originaltrilogy” is known for - fanedits. The place that was created to be AGAINST Special Editions became a factory for amateur creation of them, LOL. 😃

Post
#1692052
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

screams in the void said:

I think its awesome that the original film is getting an imax release but I really hope it will be released in regular theaters as well as there is no imax theater near me

It will, there’s only like 40 total IMAX 70mm/Dual Laser screens total. They’re not going to re-release the movie for only 40 screens. It’ll get a wide release

Post
#1692031
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

CHEWBAKAspelledwrong said:

Maybe I’m ignorant, but what’s the point of presenting a scope film on horizontal 70mm? Would it be any better than a conventional 70mm blowup?

It’ll likely be better in that the quality of the stock is higher, and the restoration will be of a higher quality than what was used in the 70s for the 70mm blowups back then.

Also, IMAX has presented scope films on their 70mm IMAX screens before, and it plays just fine, especially since the screens are so big and you’re seated so close to them that the only imagery you can really track is what’s smack in the center of the screen anyway. For most people, they’re not going to register the “black bars” top and bottom because the height of the scope composition will still be at the upper-and-lowermost ranges of their peripheral vision.

Post
#1688759
Topic
Do you think the special editions will get the same remastering as the 50th anniversary?
Time

It’s always wild how people presumably NEED to nurture a one-way parasocial relationship with a guy they don’t know, have never met, will never meet, and further, need that relationship to be an antagonistic one (even though the relationship itself is almost entirely imaginary in the first place)

Kathleen Kennedy okayed the restoration in the early 2020s specifically so it would be done in time for the 50th anniversary in 2027. George Lucas doesn’t care, and hasn’t cared for like 5-6 years now. He’s not upset and angry about it. Fantasizing about how Disney forced Kennedy to do a thing she didn’t want to and how George Lucas must be upset about it is WEIRD behavior.

Also weird behavior: a dude (not you) Spending over a year (at least) using multiple different screennames for the sole purpose of trolling a niche forum full of like 10-20 people that have made it clear the presence is unwanted.

Post
#1688107
Topic
Do you think the special editions will get the same remastering as the 50th anniversary?
Time

Verboten said:

I’m interested to know who’s in charge of all this. Doesn’t seem like something Kennedy would have done.

It was Kathleen Kennedy. The initiative to start doing this was likely 2020/2021, and work actually started in 2022.

reconforming the negative to the original version isn’t a “fuck you” to anyone, and I seriously doubt Lucas took it as such when he found out it was happening. It’s film preservation - AND his version is the one that is still the basis of the ongoing series at the studio (and his protege is now the creative head of the company).

Post
#1688077
Topic
Do you think the special editions will get the same remastering as the 50th anniversary?
Time

I don’t think the 97 SEs are ever getting this kind of restoration, because there’s nothing in it for them to do that. Lucas’ preferred version isn’t the 97 SEs, it’s the 2012/2019 SEs. And because of the way the Fandom has essentially turned “Special Edition” into a derogatory in general, the idea that anyone in the general audience would make a distinction between the 97 SE’s (the only ones actually titled Special Edition) the 04, the 10, and the 12 versions, much less enough of a distinction that they’d want a SPECIFIC version of the iterations above the others… it doesn’t make sense. It’s a niche of a niche of a niche.

COULD they restore the Special Edition back to all its 1997 glory? Sure. There’s basically no reason to do that though. They’re not the versions Lucas prefers, and they’re not the originals. They’re an early draft of the Special Editions that are basically devalued by its own name (Special Edition) and the fact they were iterated on 3 more times afterwards.

Post
#1686681
Topic
'The Mandalorian & Grogu' (Upcoming Movie) - General Discussion Thread
Time

For as much as this film has sparked off any number of conversations and “discourse” about how to “fix” the future of Star Wars before it happens, it feels like so much force-of-habit in the armchair CEO games folks like playing has led to people forgetting: This is effectively Filoni’s company now.

So all the talk about bringing in new creatives, taking new creative approaches, trying to branch out (but still remaining true to the spirit of Star Wars, which is a pretty malleable thing to define in the first place) seems to be rooted in there being a faceless, manipulable bland “other” in the captain’s chair at the company.

But it’s not a “them” in charge. It’s Filoni. And we’ve got about 20 years of evidence as to his approach, and his execution. The Starfighter movie is effectively a tonal reset, and then the next thing after that is going to be a Filoni/Kinberg trilogy, with Kinberg driving that particular tractor trailer to the finish line.

Star Wars is going to be very on rails for the foreseeable future. Dave Filoni as a creative only knows how to patch holes in bad narratives, do bondo work on bad creative decisions, and repurpose other people’s old movies into Star Wars stories you’re already semi-familiar with. The key to his success is a lowered bar and lessened expectations, and a steady, consistent level of “quality” in the hopes most people will just give in and acclimate to it.

What’s most likely going to happen is people will do just that, and in about 10 years people will look back on “The Early Disney Days” and wish for the sort of wild chances and experiments that resulted in unique filmmaking vs the staid, pat, standard and safe Lucas-karaoke they’ve been getting via Filoni’s stewardship, regardless how successful it ends up ultimately being (and it will likely end up being successful despite it’s mediocre quality)

Post
#1686514
Topic
Do you think the special editions will get the same remastering as the 50th anniversary?
Time

Also, the person who is in creative control of Lucasfilm now was ALSO hired by George Lucas and is even more hardline about pursuing his desires and vision. Kennedy was in charge when the decision to restore/remaster the original versions for a 50th anniversary celebration. Filoni isn’t going to be doing anything to the 2012 versions of the film (Lucas’ final take) at all. And I doubt he’s going to be ordering up a restoration of the 1997 Special Editions, either, since those aren’t the “Final” versions of Lucas’ intended Star Wars Trilogy (he revised them three times after that).

There’s no real reason, I don’t think, for a Filoni-led Lucasfilm to spend time and money on restoring ONE of the iterative versions between the original and the final.

Post
#1685655
Topic
The Mandalorian And Grogu - Edit ideas (contains spoilers)
Time

The bullet dodging at point blank range from 3 AT-AT Walkers, it stretched credibility beyond breaking point. This could do with toning down.

I haven’t seen the film yet, but just this clip (when it was released a couple weeks ago) could have been cut in half, I found. There’s some real strange holds on shots that aren’t even that good looking. It draws out the sequence unnecessarily and lessens the punch of it. I’m hearing that a LOT of the action ends up feeling samey and monotonous, and I’m getting the sense it’s this lack of tempo in the edit that’s doing it. I would bet that large chunks of action setpieces (if not whole sequences) could come out of the movie and improve its pace/punch.

I’ve also heard that Jeremy Allen White just… sounds like Jeremy Allen White. Which, I get! that’s probably WHY you get Jeremy Allen White, you want the way he delivers dialog. Since Huttese is a recognizable/established Star Wars language, I don’t know how you get around this unless you know someone who can do a good Jeremy Allen White impersonation AND someone who knows how to translate to Huttese, LOL. I’ve heard a lot of his dialog is repetitive (he complains about how tough it is to be Jabba’s kid quite a bit I guess) so it might just be that carving around all his exposition to key in on the lines that deliver the best combo of emotion and plot-info, vs trying to completely re-record (or worse, AI-generate) all his dialogue AND get it to match the lip-flap

I’ve heard there are opening credits (not just a big title card drop after the first 5-10 minutes like all the other anthology movies) and I’m really curious as to how it plays. People seem to be aghast at it but I’m just imagining like… a scene going and credit tags showing up onscreen as it plays? Which is pretty normal so far as cinematic convention goes. I guess I’ll see what it is when I see it, but short of completely generating a whole new title sequence out of whole cloth, (does it end up playing like the Superman main titles? Do we creatively zoom and crop to get rid of titles and then backload them to the end credits?) I’m really curious how you’d get around it.

Post
#1685397
Topic
'The Mandalorian & Grogu' (Upcoming Movie) - General Discussion Thread
Time

Acbagel said:

We live in different times now, and Hollywood has no faith in that kind of story sadly.

Hollywood has plenty of faith in stuff like that (they spend billions of dollars trying to replicate it all the time).

The problem here isn’t “Hollywood” it’s Dave Filoni/Jon Favreau. That’s it. Hollywood isn’t keeping Lucasfilm down. Lucasfilm is doing that to itself, because it is beyond terrified of its own Fandom, and they have good reason to be (It’s mostly terrible most of the time). It’s just that instead of finding better solutions (like not paying any real attention to it, hello Tony Gilroy) they keep doubling down on the worst decisions. Which they’re going to keep doing because they put one of the blandest, safest, least interesting creatives that’s ever come through there in charge of the entire studio’s creative output.

I want THAT kind of Star Wars to return to theaters, the kind that forever changes a generation, not the kind that gives you a few smiles for an evening.

No film series can live up to that level of expectation as a baseline standard. Star Wars arguably failed at it six years after it came out (it’s worth remembering the very first thing Star Wars did after breaking all box-office records was The Star Wars Holiday Special, too). A huge part of why Lucasfilm is so scared and reactive and frankly, DUMB so much of the time, is because of sentiments like “every movie has to be a generation changing event” - which they can’t do. Nobody can do that even semi-reliably. That bar is set way too high, and holding the series to that standard despite the fact it’s never gotten close to that beyond 1977 is basically inviting incessant disappointment most of the time.

There’s gotta be a way to accept that this thing can’t hit all home runs all the time, while still being frustrated that they’re TRYING to do that anyway, and trying it with some of the most boring, simple, not-even-great-on-average designated hitters in the business. Well, I know there’s a way, because I’m already there, LOL.

Post
#1684201
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

Sir, Maam, or they/them, this is a Wendy’s.

That’s not even how that meme works, though. “this is a wendy’s” is a gag at the expense of someone who is making a ridiculous ask and/or ranting at length about something barely, tangentially, related to anything on the subject. But this is a forum specifically about the sort of stuff being asked about, and there are literally FAQ’s everywhere, LOL. The reasoning for yanking the thread that was just given is the first time anyone’s given any sort of reason for anything up to this point, so as it turns out - asking is good 😃

Post
#1684104
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

There isn’t a thread about those anymore, however you can still see the compilations of all the leaked clips on YouTube pretty easily. Last time I checked, simply searching “Star Wars Restoration Leak” will not only autofill that phrase, but return 3 different channels at minimum, on top of other channels/videos simply talking about the restoration, but prominently using clips in their video.

Up until now most questions/answers regarding that one thread being deleted and/or hidden away for whatever reason have been, themselves, deleted, but I think it makes more sense to simply have a post that can be referenced stating straight out that the thread is gone (apparently due to “legal requests from the rights holders” I guess), but if you want to look at that stuff still, before the official release in about 9 months or so, it’s available on YouTube (and Reddit, I’d imagine)

Post
#1683674
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

That guy with no name said:

Also, if they haven’t told the public about whether they’re gonna release ESB or Jedi, why the hell would they tell the LSO out of all people and allow them to post about it publicly???

The LSO/Royal Albert Hall isn’t the public, they’re a business partner. It’s the same general idea every licensor has with any licensee - they know what’s going to happen before we do, because they HAVE to know in order for the deal to actually WORK. IMAX 100% knew about their Star Wars screenings AND the change in release date long before we did, for example. And they definitely knew it was the original version before they made the deal. They would need the leeway and the time! And using your example, Royal Albert/LSO would need the time to get new sheets made for the orchestras to use.

And the tickets going on sale don’t say anything about the version they’ll be screening over that weekend. And by the time that weekend rolls around, mass-produced DCPs of the restoration WILL exist. Hence my calling it a hint at our upcoming future, since it seems very likely those other two restorations are getting screened for the 50th. Remember, Lucasfilm itself announced a 50th anniversary screening before OFFICIALLY clarifying it was the original version from 77. There’s tons of examples of people knowing about a thing that’s coming before it gets announced to the public, that’s just how business is done.

I just think it’s a cool thing to keep an eye on. The LSO doing a live score at Royal Albert Hall on the 50th Anniversary of Star Wars - it’d add an extra element of “hell yeah” to the proceedings if they were doing the original score along with seeing the original version. Something to maybe look forward to, you know?

Post
#1683668
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

That guy with no name said:
Not really… the LSO and many other orchestras have been doing these LTP’s for years now…

Yes I know but I’m talking about the fact the dates on this one are Apr 29-May 2, 2027.

The context matters, LOL. The previous live-scores they’ve done (and everyone’s done) didn’t occur during a time period where newly restored/remastered DCPs of the original versions existed simultaneously. I’m suggesting this might be an unofficial hint they’re going to make the Empire/Jedi releases known soon. (-ish).

Post
#1683655
Topic
Star Wars (1977 Original Version) Theatrical Rerelease Discussion
Time

It’s very likely just going to be a standard trailer with the standard formula that basically everything is cut to. The level to which trailers have become almost a thoroughly researched science at eliciting emotional response is hard to ignore, and marketing teams have gotten EXCEEDINGLY good at making 2min commercials into tiny little short films.

they’ll push the hell out of it - the 50th Anniversary is clearly going to be part of the big set up for Starfighter, which the studio seems to believe is the REAL new kickoff of their theatrical endeavors. As has been said before - the re-release strategy at Disney is to use the classic film both as floor-raiser AND seat-holder. If a re-release makes serious bank, all the better, but usually they’re simply re-relasing something as a way to hold onto seats and screens they wouldn’t have exclusivity over otherwise, and raising the profile of the new release that will be following after it.

Star Wars 50th will be a big deal for them, because it’s the cleanest way to an audience palate cleanser, and they want a massive audience for Ryan Gosling’s follow up to Project Hail Mary, which just so happens to be a Star Wars movie by the Wolverine & Deadpool guy. They’re 100% aiming for the widest general audience appeal they can get. Starting the year with big splashy re-releases of THE STAR WARS TRILOGY is how they focus attention.

Post
#1683137
Topic
⭐ Star Wars' <strong>50th anniversary</strong> in 2027 ⭐ | Your hopes and expectations <em>(if any)</em>...
Time

Update, the ALI channel is responding to our comments on the video, with some pretty hilarious responses. They’ve never responded to our comments before this.

I mean, my first inclination is that a fan has control of the channel now and is goofing around, but that would call into question just a metric ton of things I dont’ think anyone wants to call into question, LOL.

Along those same lines, direct evidence that whoever is behind the channel knows to come in here and check this thread especially is… saying something. They (so far as I know, I only just found out about the predilection for shitposts a couple hours ago, LOL) have never even responded to direct comments on their channel, right? But now they’re posting comments in their own comments section, to baffled posts on a completely separate messageboard that (IIRC) you have to have an account to even look at now?

So someone at the channel has an account here and instead of just posting here, is leaving responses to a thread people can’t see under an iMovie-lookin promo video starring Kevin Spacey.

All of this is stuff I kinda wish wasn’t made known to anyone, LOL, because the implication now is that at some point this stopped being a valid leak and just became weirdos online behaving weirdly for the attention of a handful of folks on this forum.

Post
#1683129
Topic
⭐ Star Wars' <strong>50th anniversary</strong> in 2027 ⭐ | Your hopes and expectations <em>(if any)</em>...
Time

Why are you so obsessed with Kevin Spacey all of a sudden?

I dont’ get this response, really, I’m sorry! I’m not obsessed with Kevin Spacey - but basically the only thing you can make out in the video is him shouting “I WILL NOT YIELD” (which is also… a bizarre hook to hang this promo on).

I’m making myself pretty clear here, I think? At least I’m trying to! I don’t know what about my posts is causing so much confusion & consternation. As a promo, it’s not very good. As a shitpost (which I wasn’t aware was even an option before) it’s still… not great? It doesn’t make any sense and is centered around vocal clips from a non Star Wars tv show, from years past its last gasp of relevance culturally, being shouted by a guy who is primarily known for being a serial sex pest/abuser/accused rapist.

I’m not saying people have to share the same opinions as I do, I’m not even saying anything about anyone who says they like it (has anyone even said that yet?), or trying to be rude and/or dismissive based on that difference of opinion. I’m sharing my thoughts on this leaked promo video that maybe all of 50 people have seen so far, that I think missed the boat in a real weird way, and then responding to the folks responding to me 😃

(edited for clarity!)