Is it possible to change around the voices Rey hears? It’s frustrating that she hears voices of Jedi who couldn’t preserve themselves past physical death. Keep the voices of Qui-Gon, Kenobi, Yoda, Anakin, and Luke- cut the rest? The gaps might be awkward so other lines from those characters could fill in.
I can’t remember what the original scene was like Cinefy, but the music seems fitting. Just a bit too loud over the dialogue
^ I would appreciate the Solo-less audio as well since I’ll be putting in Battle of the Heroes on my own
New coloring for the film definitely looks better, I just think some scenes have heavy orange skin tones like Ajan Kloss, Kylo’s Quarters, Reylo kiss, Tatooine
Is Rey Nobody going to be a separate edit? I don’t see it in the main post and honestly I prefer Palpatine -> Skywalker over Nobody
Edited my comment to clarify, sorry about that
EDIT: The excessive red is far more present in the google drive preview- viewing the fully downloaded video looks much better. The only issue really is that most white characters end up looking orange on Ajan Kloss, Reylo kiss, and Tatooine.
https://theposterdb.com/set/16498 (Star Wars: The Complete Collection - by RedHeadJedi)
I really like these and wanted to print them out for Blu-Ray cases, but I’m not sure if there’s a fitting size.
I think it’s possible for sure, I personally just like the symbolism and meaning of Ben finally wielding his grandfather’s lightsaber he’s always wanted but with the crackle to show he can’t ignore his sins of the past.
Has anyone considered editing the voices Rey hears to only be the Force spirits of Qui-Gon, Kenobi, Yoda, Anakin, and Luke? It’s bothered me since the movie came out that she hears voices of Jedi who weren’t able to preserve themselves after death. Some of the lines play off of each other so there would have to be some workarounds, plus the empty spaces may need to be filled in with other lines from the Force spirit characters. Just a thought, I think it would be worth looking into.
Looking great, kewlfish! Especially the shot at 1:09
It’s definitely the second option, kewlfish. Kylo’s crystal is cracked because he didn’t properly bleed it. This crystal is cracked because Rey and Kylo broke it in half and Rey messily mended the saber and crystal back together, so it should crackle the entire time.
^ Exactly, I would say to have it crackle the entire time and if people want to have it revert for Ben, they can slice the original footage in.
Just wanted to chime in and say that I’d definitely want to crackle the entire time. It’s much more symbolically meaningful for Ben to wield the saber he’s always desired but crackling (to represent how he can now honor his bloodline but not ignore his sinful past). Plus it doesn’t make much sense for it to change and would confuse many…
And kewlfish, it’s looking great! Like dgraham414 said, the saber looks too thick on the log scene but the rest is great. You nailed the training remote part! Looking forward to seeing more.
Kewlfish that is amazing! Especially for only being a rough early draft.
^ Is there a reason he can’t?
Yeah, it’s definitely a lot of effort for something that doesn’t seem to be highly requested. I’d try to do it myself but know very little about editing.
Hello! Has it been considered to edit Rey’s saber for the entire movie to crackle like Kylo’s? Personally I was/am extremely frustrated that they could have either gone with a double-bladed repair or the yellow saber for the entire movie, and instead just banded the saber back. However, I just read this idea recently and think it would fix my problem completely while not breaking canon. Is this do-able? Has anyone worked on something like it yet?
Hello, I just received the PM link and it says the file is in the owner’s trash.
Just joined! Hello everyone