Acbagel

Can I have a link? What’s the runtime on this?

Just found your channel and subscribed, will be following now! Thanks for taking this project on, it means a lot to us fans.

MMP said:

evilash1 said:

Hi,
After seeing this edit again, I think it is a nearly perfect version for my taste and a great improvement over the original.
If you ever use your magic in your own version of TRoS, I’ll be looking forward to seeing it!

Thanks for the kind words 😃
But I don’t think I will recut TRoS.
I think Hal9000 has done an incredible job with almost every SW-fan-edit he made.
I loved his versions of 1-7. But I didnt like TLJ. There was still too much Rian-Johnson-nonsense in it. Thats why I made my own version of TLJ.
When it comes to TRoS Ascendant, I think he did it right in almost every part. There is not much I would change. First I was concerned if there would be problems or plot holes between my version of TLJ and TRoS Ascendant, but it works almost flawless. So for me, there is no need to change anything.
I found my favorite versions of Star Wars 1-9, Rogue one and Solo (both from Digmodification) and I don’t think I will edit any SW-Content soon.
I will continue recutting movies I don’t liked in cinema.
Atm I’m working on a recut of The Lone Ranger. But I’m not sure if I will upload it, cause I don’t think there is much audience who want to see it 😉

What’s your favorite cuts of 1-9?

Watching your TPM edit tonight with my wife. Your ideas seem great so I’m excited to see it in action!

FreezingTNT2 said:

Acbagel said:

FreezingTNT2 said:

Acbagel said:

Hal 9000 said:

Well, that certainly means a lot coming from you.

While the changes to V6 of the prequels have not been unanimously well received, I think it was worthwhile to give them another go. I’m really happy with the end result. Was it worth all that it ended up figuratively costing me? Probably not, but at least I accomplished a goal. I’m hoping that I’ll be able to halfway enjoy sitting down and watching 1 through 9 of the complete Hal9000 presentation of the saga when it’s finished. Anyone can join me. I’ll bring chee-toes.

Thanks for all your hard work. I watched V5 of 1 & 2 and they were incredible. My wife has never seen Star Wars before and when we watch the saga together I will be showing her these versions of the prequels.

Can you show her Adywan’s ANH:R, ESB:R, and RotJ:R (once the latter comes out)?

That’s the plan! Looking at the Coaxium Heist for Solo, undecided on R1, and then leaning towards Hal’s VII. It sounds impossible, but she doesn’t even know that Anakin is Vader, and even more clueless about the Emperor’s identity. Going to do an experiment with her, we are going to watch everything in chronological order including The Clone Wars, so I am wondering when she will pick up on these huge plot points during the show.

Which edit are you going to be using for The Last Jedi?

Leaning towards using The Last Jedi: Rekindled as a base and then adding some of HAL’s changes and maybe some from other edits. Will end up taking what I like most from a few different edits and making my own cut. Will probably do the same thing with mixing V6 of LoE and Revenge of the Sith: Rebalanced. Appreciate the great work from HAL and the other editors. I don’t think there’s any competition to HAL’s 1 & 2 in terms of better “theatrical” versions. To me, a SW movie needs to be at least near 2 hours long so I really appreciate the V6 of the PT HAL has made.

FreezingTNT2 said:

Acbagel said:

Hal 9000 said:

Well, that certainly means a lot coming from you.

While the changes to V6 of the prequels have not been unanimously well received, I think it was worthwhile to give them another go. I’m really happy with the end result. Was it worth all that it ended up figuratively costing me? Probably not, but at least I accomplished a goal. I’m hoping that I’ll be able to halfway enjoy sitting down and watching 1 through 9 of the complete Hal9000 presentation of the saga when it’s finished. Anyone can join me. I’ll bring chee-toes.

Thanks for all your hard work. I watched V5 of 1 & 2 and they were incredible. My wife has never seen Star Wars before and when we watch the saga together I will be showing her these versions of the prequels.

Can you show her Adywan’s ANH:R, ESB:R, and RotJ:R (once the latter comes out)?

That’s the plan! Looking at the Coaxium Heist for Solo, undecided on R1, and then leaning towards Hal’s VII. It sounds impossible, but she doesn’t even know that Anakin is Vader, and even more clueless about the Emperor’s identity. Going to do an experiment with her, we are going to watch everything in chronological order including The Clone Wars, so I am wondering when she will pick up on these huge plot points during the show.

Hal 9000 said:

Well, that certainly means a lot coming from you.

While the changes to V6 of the prequels have not been unanimously well received, I think it was worthwhile to give them another go. I’m really happy with the end result. Was it worth all that it ended up figuratively costing me? Probably not, but at least I accomplished a goal. I’m hoping that I’ll be able to halfway enjoy sitting down and watching 1 through 9 of the complete Hal9000 presentation of the saga when it’s finished. Anyone can join me. I’ll bring chee-toes.

Thanks for all your hard work. I watched V5 of 1 & 2 and they were incredible. My wife has never seen Star Wars before and when we watch the saga together I will be showing her these versions of the prequels.

Very cool! That is definitely the best version so far.

If you want to turn Rey’s dream into a nightmare then just add the TLJ scene where Luke throws the lightsaber. 😉

Is this still in progress?

He is going to somehow link to it in the comments from an anonymous account or something like that.

The Edit is being released this Thursday on his YouTube channel. I have been following Ivan for a long time and have seen clips of his edit, many of his new scenes are quite good.

That lighting looks incredible

Your creativity is awesome with that thought. I do video editing for work, and there is ALWAYS something else I could improve. It will never be perfect, so work until you are satisfied. I think it is a cool idea, but we could also come up with cool ideas for every scene in the movie lol. I trust you if you think it is worth the time!

I really like this scene. Good work on that! Much more emotional without the extra nonsense, very smooth editing too, I didn’t even notice anything was cut.

This is looking like it might be the best TFA edit out there. Can’t wait for the full product, thanks for taking the time to do this!

Looking forward to it. Thanks for taking the time to make it the best product possible!

This is an amazing idea. A Clone Wars fan edit is much needed and I love your direction.

These changes look amazing, I’ve been searching for a RotS cut that I truly love. Can’t wait to watch yours soon! I am waiting for 1.3, let us know when it is ready!