Sign In

REVENGE OF THE EDIT: A Fan Edit of 'Revenge of the Sith' (Released)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

TL;DR:

Cut about 30 minutes out but also inserted most of Siege of Mandalore arc, giving it a runtime just under 3 hours.

OP:

Today, I would like to present a fan edit that I’ve been tweaking and re-editing again and again and again until I finally am 100 percent satisfied with it.

Basically, I started with the New Canon Cut of ‘Revenge of the Sith’ by NFBisms as a solid foundation.

Then, I cut most of the Battle of Coruscant so it seems like Anakin and Obi-Wan head straight to General Grievous’ battle cruiser.

Also cut a couple of quick shots of Grievous so that the audience ends up seeing him at about the same time that Ani and Obi do.

Also cut about 30 minutes of scenes after Anakin’s secret reunion with Padme at the end of Palpatine’s rescue, leading up to Anakin’s talk with Palpatine at the Galaxies Opera House.

I cut all of that footage because I’d always felt that those scenes were way too dialog-heavy without actually moving the plot forward; in this way, I feel the pacing is much better.

1251isthetimethati, a Reddit user, has a video that helped me download all of the scenes from the Siege of Mandalore arc from ‘The Clone Wars.’

Unfortunately, because I really wanted the intro titles to be seamless and everything, I didn’t include the intro to the Mandalore arc.

However, I did include it as a post-credit scene of another fan edit I did, Episode 2: Labyrinth of Evil.

In this edit, I did my best to integrate the Mandalore scenes with the original ROTS scenes while also keeping up the pacing, which means I kind of had to snip off some footage toward the end of a sequence, etc, but I also used wipe transitions where I felt they would work well.

You may also notice that Anakin’s assignment to spy on Palpatine is basically given off-screen, again, for pacing reasons.

There was a point where I was looking for the end of Obi-Wan’s fight with Grievous, and I realized it occurs after the scene where Palpatine reveals himself as a Sith to Anakin.

To me, such timing feels out of place, so I moved the end of that fight to an earlier point where we see Grievous escaping on his motor bike.

I mean, sure, Obi defeats Grievous before Anakin informs Palpatine that Obi has engaged Grievous, but a fight can escalate more quickly than Ani can receive a play-by-play of it.

Toward the end of the credits, I inserted Obi-Wan’s message from Rebels.

At the end of the credits, we can also see the final transformation of Darth Vader.

Another note: It must seem insane, how many times I’ve edited this film, but I feel that I’m finally 100 percent satisfied with it.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

UPDATE:

Someone has let me know that the quality is kind of low.

All I did was compress the video using HandBrake and uploaded that compressed video to Google Drive.

Would anyone have any suggestions to improve the quality?

Maybe I should try uploading the original video to MEGA?

EDIT:

Specifically, SandMTV said,

SandMTV said:

It is in 360p. And if I go anywhere when the film stars plays, it loads for a long time. When I restart the film it goes to the beginning.

Author
Time

There is a contunuity error when Ahsoka and Rex are looking at the door is sparking Rex is sitting at the table and Ahsoka is nest to Rex and two shots later, Rex stood up and grabbed his helmet and Ahsoka approaches the door.

Author
Time

SandMTV said:

There is a contunuity error when Ahsoka and Rex are looking at the door is sparking Rex is sitting at the table and Ahsoka is nest to Rex and two shots later, Rex stood up and grabbed his helmet and Ahsoka approaches the door.

Thank you for bringing this to my attention.

What’s the time for that?

Author
Time

At the end of S7E11 and the start of S7E12!

Author
Time

Thanks.

I was just hoping for a time that I can use to refer to in the video, as in 0:00:00.

Author
Time

Sounds fascinating

I’m just a simple man trying to make my way in the universe.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

JackNapier said:

Sounds fascinating

Thanks! Would you like a link to watch my fan edit?

Also, regarding the continuity error, when I see it myself using a time stamp, I may or may not care too much.

I could leave it in as a kind of Easter egg.

Right now, I’m mostly concerned with getting the quality back up.

Instead of linking to a compressed video, maybe I should try uploading the original video?

Author
Time

I would love to

I’m just a simple man trying to make my way in the universe.

Author
Time

Thanks for your interest.

First, I need to get the quality improved.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Good news, everyone.

Currently watching my own fan edit on my phone from a link I shared with a friend while making dinner in my apartment, and…

I see absolutely nothing wrong.

Have a great day.

Author
Time

If you’re working off of New Canon Cut, you absolutely have quality problems. xP

Author
Time

NFBisms said:

If you’re working off of New Canon Cut, you absolutely have quality problems. xP

Only in the sense that I felt a need to cut the 30 minutes between Padme’s “I’m preggers” reveal and the opera house scene.

Author
Time

I never released in NCC in anything higher than 720p, and being re-edited onto another project from there had to compress it further. xP