With all the recent scenes from Revenge of the Sith remade shot by shot in animation...

… in TCW S7, Bad Batch and more, do you think we’ll ever get a RotS Animated remake?

I think the answer is no and I’d much rather see more fresh narratives rather than rehash of the very same story but still, it is an interesting concept that A LOT of people seem to really want.

Star Wars: The Bad Batch and Revenge of the Sith Scene Mashup/Comparison: https://youtu.be/hqynj7A8EPI

Palpatine’s Bad Batch Speech with Revenge of the Sith scenes: https://youtu.be/9monm0T8QNs

I think the answer is no, but I’d LOVE this. I think Revenge of the Sith is a phenomenal story with poor execution. We’ve seen how well the writers and directors of projects like The Clone Wars and Rebels can handle emotional scenes (just think of how great the final Clone Wars arc is!) and I’m convinced they could do a fantastic remake. One of my other problems with ROTS is a lot of the visuals, the excessive CGI not being to my taste, etc. An animated remake (ironically completely cgi) would most likely also fix this.

I love animation and an animated Revenge of the Sith remake would be a dream for me.

jedi_bendu said:

I think the answer is no, but I’d LOVE this. I think Revenge of the Sith is a phenomenal story with poor execution. We’ve seen how well the writers and directors of projects like The Clone Wars and Rebels can handle emotional scenes (just think of how great the final Clone Wars arc is!) and I’m convinced they could do a fantastic remake. One of my other problems with ROTS is a lot of the visuals, the excessive CGI not being to my taste, etc. An animated remake (ironically completely cgi) would most likely also fix this.

I love animation and an animated Revenge of the Sith remake would be a dream for me.

I’d much rather seem them pursue fresh narratives and pour resources into those rather than rehash same storylines.