- Time
- Post link
The OT appealed to anyone cause the characters were normal, and they upbeat and fun movies. I am not a sci-fi fan, but the OT are my favorite set of movies, so it was able to get fans like me to love it. You could identify with Luke, Leia, and Han, and that was the appeal, and of course they are great movies to begin with.
I read what the appeals to the PT fans: Many say, they identify with Padme/Anakin because they have had relationships like that. I think, who the hell has forbidden love affairs on this planet cause of those circumstances? They can identify with Anakin because of his attachment issues as a kid, and the things he goes through and the choices he makes to go to the darkside. I say to myself, "who thinks of killing a bunch of kids to save your wife?" In short, they are really identify with Anakin & Padme, the same way we identify with Han, Luke, and Leia, and I say they have some major issues.
I am not saying that these fans aren't genuine in their love for the PT, but it is getting creepy, and I am really starting to believe that the PT diehards are a niche audience that won't stand the test of time. These people will outgrow these movies in 10 years when they get over their forbidden love affairs issues and their demons in them as teenagers than Anakin faces.
I believe there is a good amount of fans that like the PT, and cause of their love of the OT, they give it a pass because it is more SW. Then there are niche fans like us who have major issues, and there are niche fans like them who love it to death.
The reason the OT is still great today, is the movies still resonate because anyone can relate to the little guy beating the big guy, and the underdog story SW is really about. Most of these PT fans are big fans of ROTJ, and the last half hour of ESB, where Vader is prominent. In essence, they dont' like SW '77 cause it doesn't deal with Vader, and it is his story that interests them the most. I want to see 20 years from now when they are in their 30's and 40's if they still give two shits about Darth Vaders story played out in movies that aren't that great. I know I don't watch any movies from 20 years ago, that I don't deam a classic, I heavily doubt they will either.