Sith for now. After I get it on DVD in November.I will have a complete sagathon,and then re-watch Sith & Jedi and then I will decide for sure........
"When Theres No More Room In Hell,The Dead Will Walk The Earth"
SUPERBOWL LII CHAMPS!!!
Made for IE Forum's Episode III theme month - May 2005.
I can't remember where I heard it, but Ben Burtt said that most people were not impressed and disappointed with Empire. Over the years, though, most people fell in love with it and said it's the best out of the three. Maybe it wasn't loved at first because it wasn't as action oriented as Star Wars?
I love it because of the emotion with Yoda, Vader's reveal to Luke, the scenes in the astroid field and on Hoth, Boba Fett, and the towards the end it was SO VERY suspenseful. Overall it captured the most emotion, I think.
"I call Order 66!!" "Time to do a 360º"
Originally posted by: Seiji
I can't remember where I heard it, but Ben Burtt said that most people were not impressed and disappointed with Empire.
2004 DVD comentaries.
Originally posted by: Klingon_Jedi
It's still a tie between IV and V, and always will be.
After seeing Sith twice now, I have to say that the ONLY thing that keep it from being my favorite is that The Empire Strikes Back has Han Solo. Of course, in the grand scheme of things, Han Solo turned out to not be a major player, but he was still fun to watch, and my all-time favorite SW character. And how many guys can say that they attempted to kill their father-in-laws... only to have said father in law freeze your ass?
So, I'd have to say that my list is as follows:
1. Empire Strikes Back / Revenge of the Sith (tie)
2. A New Hope
3. Return of the Jedi
4. Phantom Menace / Attack of the Clones (tie)
Empire is, has and always will be the supreme ruler of the Star Wars films.
If perfection had a name, it would be The Empire Strikes Back.
Sith is another magic movie. A Return of the Jedi with a more interesting story. I actually cried for about 40% of the time the first time I watched it. Just gut wrenchingly ugly and tragic. So in short...
No offense to Jedi, but I feel it drags too much in the middle. Hopefully, Williams has been asked to compose some new stuff for A New Hope, because I think it's too detached to the overall story right now. Very impressed with the outcome of all the movies stringed together.
Originally posted by: Stampid
. Hopefully, Williams has been asked to compose some new stuff for A New Hope
SUPERBOWL LII CHAMPS!!!
2.) ANH - We would all love Star Wars even if this was the only film. 'Nuff said.
3.) ROTJ - Jabba scenes, death of Yoda, and the final battle outweigh Ewoks and the beginning of Lucas's downfall.
4.) TPM - Qui Gon and Darth Maul are fantastic. I still feel sad at the death of Qui Gon, maybe the only time I care about a character in the PT. Jake Lloyd, against all odds, the best Anakin in the PT (not saying much).
5.) AOTC - Rubbish, but didn't need to be as good as III had to be.
6.) ROTS - Maybe the most important film of the saga. Fails at all major/important plot tie-ups. Anakin's turn to Dark Side utterly unconvincing.