logo Sign In

The Rise Of Skywalker — Official Review and Opinions Thread — Page 4

Author
Time

krlozdac said:

When the tickets were first being sold, the runtime was said to be 2h 35m. It seems to me like they did a final squeeze in order to get more showtimes and get a more family friendly runtime. And, oh boy, can you tell. Particularly in the opening act.

If you’ve been following some of the leaked stuff then you know there was much more to this movie than what we got. Palpatine’s reveal was meant to build up throughout the first act instead of just being dropped in out of nowhere from the very beginning.

Lando was supposed to have a daughter that was kidnapped long ago to become a stormtrooper. The end was meant to imply that it was Jannah. But without that set up, you only get them randomly meeting without any idea of why they’re talking to each other. It even makes the exchange seem potentially creepy.

I really hope that we get the deleted stuff in the Bluray because I could feel a good film trying to burst out of the seams of what ended up feeling like a rushed, unearned mess.

I’m one of the ones that honestly loved the movie, but I do agree the pacing was insanely quick at the very start and a little towards the end. If this is really the case then I’m both bummed that the version I really like isn’t the entirety of the movie, but hopeful that we do get all those scenes in a bluray. I usually hate extended editions with a passion because they should always put the film as it is in theaters instead of shortening it to detract from the proper vision, but I wouldn’t mind getting an extended cut of Episode 9 officially released instead of fanedits throwing in the deleted scenes.

Author
Time

I thought Leia was handled very well actually (for the most part). I think what they did is a far better solution than writing her out entirely. And killing her off halfway through TLJ would have been an absolutely atrocious idea.

I don’t really have the energy to relitigate TFA or TLJ, which is seems like the discussion in this thread is. I also am not really passionate about TROS to argue much about it, so I probably won’t end up saying much. But I will say, the film, at least in my opinion, renders the whole ST essentially pointless, which plain sucks. Otherwise, I’m pretty mixed on the film.

I will say this though… not only does TROS not feature any shaky cam that I can remember, TFA didn’t either. So I’m not sure where people are getting their info from but that’s not something to worry about.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

This movie is too disorganized to have organized thoughts about it, was so sloppy I had to keep reminding myself I didn’t fall asleep through the middle, now I know what people meant by the plot is basically on a speedrun. What a gigantic waste even the ridiculousness of it all got old. Genuinely feel bad for all still invested up to this point. We’re going to be feeling this one for a while.

EDIT: Also the Carrie Fisher scenes played out like those old fake “interviews” Weird Al used to do.

“The ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the Force.” - DV

Author
Time

I also have no clue what people are talking about with the shaky cam. In the Poe/Finn Falcon clip that was released people were saying the shaky cam was god awful but I barely noticed until I saw a million posts complaining about JJ’s style, and even now it doesn’t bother me whatsoever.

Author
Time

I very much enjoyed this in the main.

It felt like the film could have easily gone on for another 10 to 15 minutes; maybe explaining some of the events a little better and not having a rushed feeling in some of the scenes?

It was a fun film and welcome finale to this Sequel Trilogy. It does not come close to the Original Trilogy in my mind, but is a welcome addition to the overall story (for me personally these were far more enjoyable than the Prequels).

Upon first viewing it is another fun Star Wars film - yes! 😃

Author
Time

Lesser said:

I also have no clue what people are talking about with the shaky cam. In the Poe/Finn Falcon clip that was released people were saying the shaky cam was god awful but I barely noticed until I saw a million posts complaining about JJ’s style, and even now it doesn’t bother me whatsoever.

Yeah I mean, there’s basically no shaky cam in that clip.

Author
Time

Lesser said:

I also have no clue what people are talking about with the shaky cam. In the Poe/Finn Falcon clip that was released people were saying the shaky cam was god awful but I barely noticed until I saw a million posts complaining about JJ’s style, and even now it doesn’t bother me whatsoever.

If you like shaky-cam that’s fine, but don’t say it isn’t there because it is. Shaky-cam is any shot that moves in more than one direction, unnecessarily, where it isn’t a tracking shot. For example a shot that moves left, then up, then right. It can be a shot that is vibrating, but it doesn’t have to be, it can also be anything that looks like unstable hand-held style shots. See this video for a comparison between shaky-cam and steady-cam. Almost the entire clip is shaky cam, this one tracking shot is the sole exception:

That’s a tracking shot. Although it’s not tracking anything, it’s just panning the camera down. Every other shot in that clip, without exception, is shaky cam. Some have more shaking, some have little, but not a single shot is a steady-cam/tracking shot. I respect your opinion to enjoy it, some people prefer it and their opinions are just as valid as mine, but I find it awful. Done in JJ’s style anyway, as I mentioned before it can be used effectively as in the T2 clip.

[ Scanning stuff since 2015 ]

Author
Time

RU.08 said:

If you like shaky-cam that’s fine, but don’t say it isn’t there because it is.

I know what shaky cam is and I definitely didn’t say it wasn’t there, I was meaning that I had no clue what people were talking about cause my mind just doesn’t register it I guess, then I watched the clip again and saw it, but it seemed too small for me to understand why some people would refuse to see an entire movie solely based on that.

Author
Time

Didn’t notice any shaky camera on the movie at all…
It’s all tracking and steady camera shots, quite conservative by modern standards.

Author
Time

Lesser said:

I know what shaky cam is and I definitely didn’t say it wasn’t there, I was meaning that I had no clue what people were talking about cause my mind just doesn’t register it I guess, then I watched the clip again and saw it, but it seemed too small for me to understand why some people would refuse to see an entire movie solely based on that.

Exactly right, you’ve hit the nail on the head, you don’t notice it. That’s perfectly fine. Some people don’t notice it, it doesn’t distract them - heck directors like JJ wouldn’t use it if they thought they would. Some people love the style.

Also I apologise for suggesting you said there wasn’t shaky-cam there, it was this comment that set me off:

DominicCobb said:

Yeah I mean, there’s basically no shaky cam in that clip.

Lesser I think your phrasing is a little off “refuse to see an entire movie …” I don’t see most motives that come out. Some don’t interest me in the slightest. Sometimes I’ve seen movies because I’ve gone with someone who wanted to see a particular film I never would have chosen to watch. I’m certainly not “refusing” to see it - if someone wanted me to see it with them I would, even if I have to pay twice as much to see it in their chosen cinema.

However in to answer you underlying question, yes I hate the style and I wish I knew about JJ’s style before going to see TFA because I was completely unprepared. It’s not just in action sequences, it’s in the whole TFA, which I don’t remember watching in full a second time. I am a little offended by your comment, I don’t begrudge anyone for enjoying it, all the better to you if you do. But it’s not for me, I know that for myself. It’s a 3D movie and not even being shown here in 3D which I see as pointless - not just because I like 3D, but all the framing decisions that are done for 3D are irrelevant to 2D, most of the time they don’t translate well. There’s no way I can see this movie here right now and appreciate the director’s intent, unfortunately.

[ Scanning stuff since 2015 ]

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Audience scores have released on RT.com at a surprising 86% after nearly 6700 reviews while the critic rating remains at 58% after now 291 reviews. Not an awesome rating from the audience but pretty good considering the initial bad signs due to the critics and initial reports. The audience rating could still swing a lot either way with it being pretty far off the near 300,000 reviews for TLJ.

Nonetheless it doesn’t change my views on the movie though it is interesting to basically see the ratings almost flipped compared to TLJ and it really just shows how out of touch the critics are with the actual audience.

Something else I also found interesting is what Roz Weston from ET Canada said regarding The Mandalorian basically taking away any anxiety he had going into TROS as Star Wars is already saved (by Mando and a particular character in it). This answers (at least from his perspective) a question asked in another thread here on whether Mando would affect your view / enjoyment of TROS and this seems like a pretty legitimate viewpoint that others may also share. This guy originally went to town on TLJ with his live review on mainstream TV (https://youtu.be/ZQ8ir66M5XU) but for TROS despite a number of noted issues he genuinely enjoyed it and left feeling satisfied.

Below is the quote regarding what he said about The Mandalorian and the video itself for his review of TROS. The quote does contain a minor spoiler for Mando though it’s been all over the internet for weeks now so I’m sure most are well aware of it but I’ve used spoiler tags all the same:

MANDALORIAN SPOILER

Around 8:35
“…I do think that my anxiety and expectations were much lower going into this (TROS) because I love The Mandalorian so much. This movie, TROS didn’t have to save Star Wars, because Baby Yoda already did that!”

https://youtu.be/wRJL46wWfUY

Author
Time

“Shaky cam” is just a colloquial synonym for “hand-held photography.”

Nobody’s actually shaking the camera, it’s just not stabilized on a dolly or tripod or steadicam machine.

It’s not in this movie, OR in The Force Awakens very much.

Author
Time

RU.08 said:
In the original trilogy, Darth Vader is never referred to as a Sith, he’s a Jedi that has been converted to the dark side (for example I’ve always understood “Your sad devotion to that ancient religion …” to be referring to him as a Jedi not Sith).

It is unfortunate, I think, that there is now so much convoluted garbage in the Star Wars franchise that modern fans don’t understand the original trilogy.

From the original 1976 script:

The awesome, seven-foot-tall Dark Lord of the SITH makes his way into the blinding light of the main passageway. This is Darth Vader, right hand of the Emperor.

Author
Time

So, after thinking I hated it the first time I saw it, I now think I actually really liked this movie. It rendered the rest of the ST pointless, sure, much like the ST had rendered the saga pointless for me before in TFA. The ending is ROTJ on steroids, and since they could make Episode VII from Episode VI, they sure can Episode X this Episode IX, make Palpatine clone someone again and have him be the big bad again in XII… wow this sounds so stupid when I type it or say it out loud. It’s also a shame since it’s exactly what Rian’s film went against. Oh well.

I’m not a fan of TFA at all (that was the movie that made everything else pointless to me, by rebooting the status quo and rendering every single accomplishment that came before pointless), but I appreciated what TLJ tried to do from there, despite disagreeing with it in the most part and thinking it had a very flawed execution at times. But I definitely respected it.

TROS, on the other hand, seemingly embraces with open arms the idea that the ST is nothing more than fan fiction, and I loved it since that’s also what I consider the ST to be. I mean, most story points may as well come from YouTube theorists. The crawl seemed like something 12 year old me would come up with, much like the story. But man, it was extremely enjoyable. Sometimes it seemed like they weren’t giving a fuck, like: have Palpatine use force lightning in hundreds of ships. That was just so ridiculous, much like when he was sucking “force life” out of Rey and Ben. But who cares. It’s so stupid and ridiculous it’s fun.

And that was great for me. I wasn’t sure how IX could save the ST for me, and it did in the most fun way possible: by making everything look silly. I won’t rewatch the ST whenever I rewatch the saga, but I might rewatch it for fun every once in a while. But, man, I do feel bad for Rian. He tried to make something serious and deep out of TFA only for Abrams to literally retcon every one of the major decisions Rian took. A shame. But whatever, I’m happy.

I was surprised by how well they handled Carrie, I thought it would be much worse, and it definitely could’ve been. The one scene I think stood out was the one where she says “be optimist” or whatever. The others work very well.

Author
Time

Broom Kid said:

“Shaky cam” is just a colloquial synonym for “hand-held photography.”

Nobody’s actually shaking the camera, it’s just not stabilized on a dolly or tripod or steadicam machine.

It’s not in this movie, OR in The Force Awakens very much.

This. Shaky cam doesn’t mean moving camera. It’s means handheld photography. And it’s almost entirely absent in the film. In that clip, not a single live action shot is handheld.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

What shall I say? I utterly enjoyed this movie and couldn’t stop smiling.
But the story had some flaws that really annoy me. First of all I was disappointed that they ignored TLJ almost completely. The is seemingly no hope in the galaxy, although reestablishing hope was one of the main themes from TLJ. Poe is still struggling to be a leader. Rey is still obsessed with the past. The portrayal of the Jedi has shifted back to the picture we got from the prequels and Rose got sidelined for Jannah, who serves basically no purpose, although her character could have been a set up for a big stormtrooper mutiny, which would have suited Fin’s character well.
But these are merely details, what really bugged me the most was their reluctance to move beyond the almost tiring good vs. evil showdown. Luke’s sacrifice from TLJ had left me with hope that the Jedi may finally become true peacekeepers and actual pacifist and Rey had the opportunity to do so. It may sound cheesy, in fact it is a horrible idealistic approach, plaese don’t crucify me 😃

Instead of fighting the guards, when Palpatine wanted her to kill and replace him, she should have embraced him, her literal evil grandpa. Think about it, the dark side feeds of hate, how is fighting fire with fire supposed to help anything? Acknowledging the evil, disempowering it by recognition and locking the pitiable, hateful creature up in a forgotten temple in a system, literally no-one knew it existed, would have been a far more powerful climax then the one we got.

This would have been the actual Jedi way. Instead of killing the dark side, she should have healed it. (remember she has already healed two monsters in the very same movie)

“Vader! Hologram, now!”

Author
Time

Oh, dear. At this point this may be the least favourite Star Wars ‘anything’ I’ve experienced. Everything I expected from a JJA film that followed the reaction to TLJ and so on, and so forth - only… nightmarishly worse? The prequels seem somewhat quaint compared to this lifeless husk.

Author
Time

Audience reactions have appeared on Rotten Tomatoes. Instead of the 58% the 309 critics have given it, 9628 audience reactions rate it at 86%. So right now it is critically panned but loved by the audience.

Author
Time

I enjoy the film very much - and had a good Star Wars feeling to it.

It is not close to the quality of Original Trilogy, but is good on its own terms, and also a good ending for the Sequel Trilogy.

I am glad that Kylo and Rey were given good screen time and story. I wish that other characters were given more time too but think we did not need new characters such as the man from Lost - Charlie?, Jannah and D0 - maybe more screentime and lines for Rose, Connix, Maz, Wedge or R2! 😃

A little strange we did not see more familiar worlds in the Galaxy celebrating at the end - or rising up to fight too. Yub-Nub!

I will look forward to seeing it again soon 😃

R4

Author
Time

The one thought i had throughout this film was “This is a childrens movie. How is a child supposed to enjoy this?”

Not as good as TLJ.

Far too much movie even for its massive runtime, just too many setpeices. But there were parts that I absolutely loved, so its a generous 7/10 for me.

Seeing it again on Monday but I feel that might be too soon.

Author
Time

I just got out of the theater about an hour ago. I did go into the film with some spoilers from the leaks, not all (i.e. force healing, Rey Palpatine, Rey’s yellow lightsaber).

On paper I thought a lot of the plot details sounded pretty bad and seeing the RT score made me think that this would be a terrible film. But after seeing film, I found most of the plot points that I already knew about was fulfilling and entertaining. So the moral of the story is go see this movie and form your own opinion about it 😃

I think that this movie would benefit from being longer since it is trying to do so much within its runtime, but I still enjoyed it nonetheless. My ranking for the Sequel Trilogy as of right now is TROS, TFA, TLJ.

The user formerly known as “Trillary Dump” (it was the 2016 election…)