logo Sign In

The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread — Page 188

Author
Time

TML said:

One thing that has always bugged me about the Yoda and Palpatine duel in RotS is that when Yoda pushes Palps at the begining of the duel, his arms go up even before he goes flying towards his chair, and it just looks bad..... Is anyone else bothered by this?

One thing?  Lol.

And Nooooooooooo?   Noooooooooooooooooooo!

Author
Time

over the top Palpatine in that ROTS duel worked for me. at least in a so bad it was entertaining kind of way in an otherwise joyless film.

i think what detracts more from Palpatine is that line: "You can't kill him he's a SITH LORD!" and those other goofy moments when he was on the droid ship.

Author
Time

brash_stryker said:

Also, SSWR's Youtube channel has vanished. What's going on?

 Here's what I posted on my profile:

About Me:
 

Well, people, it's the end for now. I hope no one is too upset by me taking down my own edits. Lucasfilm didn't contact me or anything like that...I simply felt that they needed to come down for some personal reasons. I'll be around...just not as much. Thanks to everyone who supported my little edits! I've really appreciated all of the feedback and kind words.

SSWR’s YouTube channel

Attack of the Clones: Alternate Timeline Edit Thread:
https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/SSWRs-Attack-of-the-Clones-Alternate-Timeline-Edit/id/66888

Author
Time

I can understand you wanting to take a break from doing them but did you have to wipe them out...all of them?

Author
Time

Bingowings said:

I can understand you wanting to take a break from doing them but did you have to wipe them out...all of them?

 Well, I can understand maybe wanting to reference some of my videos for other ideas and whatnot... but again, for some personal reasons, I felt I needed to take them down. But I know there is plenty of creativity here to go around!  :D  I plan to still be around giving ideas and feedback...but it'll probably be even less than before.

SSWR’s YouTube channel

Attack of the Clones: Alternate Timeline Edit Thread:
https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/SSWRs-Attack-of-the-Clones-Alternate-Timeline-Edit/id/66888

Author
Time

Your Star Wars videos are a treasure trove of ingenious ideas.

I can't imagine what dreadful personal situation you are going through to drive you to take the videos down from Youtube but I hope you reconsider or archive them anonymously elsewhere.

At least stick them on a data disc and send them to someone like doubleofive so the wishlist has some examples of what you were trying to do.

Those videos must have taken ages to do and have lots of really clever decisions in them.

They are far too important to vanish.

Author
Time

Bingowings said:

Your Star Wars videos are a treasure trove of ingenious ideas.

I can't imagine what dreadful personal situation you are going through to drive you to take the videos down from Youtube but I hope you reconsider or archive them anonymously elsewhere.

At least stick them on a data disc and send them to someone like doubleofive so the wishlist has some examples of what you were trying to do.

Those videos must have taken ages to do and have lots of really clever decisions in them.

They are far too important to vanish.

I couldn't think of anything to add - Bingowings said everything I wanted to say.

Author
Time

Too bad you're "leaving" SSWR. BingoWings already said it all, but I too really enjoyed your ideas and videos. I hope everything is alright :)

Author
Time

Added this in a different thread, but it has *always* bugged me that in teh Prequels the Venator Stardestroyers fire BLUE lazers and not GREEN, like the Imperial Star Destroyers do.

Likewise the Clonetroopers should have RED lazers that match the look and feel of the Stormtroopers.

Both should have the same sound effects, which add so much in terms of consistency.

Author
Time

I've always associated blue with Ion cannons (thanks to the Xwing series of games) so it's never sat right with me either.

Author
Time

Mace Towani from the Ewok movies used a blaster that shot blue bolts.

Author
Time

This is interesting.. I was amazed that they managed to make the shots of scott pillgrim simpler from the original, using various techiques. Taking inspiration of how many live action shots of the whole PT can be worked out that way. Simplifiying them to a less fancy ones or altered if you ask me can give a desirable OT feel :)

Fingers Crossed for start knowing this process ;)

http://www.awn.com posted:

"For this preliminary design work, because it was only on stills, we worked almost exclusively in Photoshop. We took the original photographs and painted successive layers of removing more and more detail, flattening out colors and surfaces, until finally we arrived at the graphic style of the books.

Image
For Scott and Ramona's first date, the environment need a magical touch of winter applied. Image courtesy of Mr. X.

"In addition to the simplification, we also added CG snow piles, aerial snow and overall 'de-greening' of the environment. Most of the environment simplification shots were done with a 2.5D projected matte painting approach. We first matchmoved the shots using mostly PFTrack, but also some boujou and 3D Equalizer, and modeled stand-in geo for the shots in Maya, representing buildings, cars and roads. If the shot was locked off or otherwise essentially shot from a single perspective, we would paint a single layered painting that covered all the areas where simplification was required. If it was a moving camera, we would either create a larger oversized painting that encompassed the entire camera move (useful for mainly nodal pans), or select keyframes throughout the shot for a multiple painting approach. In Nuke, the various layers in the painting were projected onto the stand-in geo from the matchmove, and then everything was blended together in the final comp."

It will be interested seeing how this can work :D

 

-Angel, Berry and Blue

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time

I'd be more interested to see how it could produce some invasion damage to Theed.

At no point do you get a visual sense of that being a planet suffering in anyway.

The few people you do see seem to be well fed, healthy and placid and all the buildings look untouched and perfect.

Author
Time

But we're told everyone is dying.  What, you wanna see it too?

:p

Author
Time

You could just insert footage of Schindler's List.... Darn you, black and white footage!!!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

^Too soon!

TV's Frink said:

But we're told everyone is dying.  What, you wanna see it too?

:p

 

Author
Time

hey, just tint the Schindler's list footage blue, add some scan lines, and voila!  holographics!

Author
Time

I hope everyone realized I was joking about Schindler's List. lol