tbird97 said:
dave88 said:
Why are you guys so keen on this release?
I don't mind to reply.
For me, this hits my Star Wars sweet spot. This was the last release of the movies before the Special Editions took more liberties with the movies.
I'm not interested in a "despecialized" or recreated experience (not knocking the effort that went into creating them). I want to recall the movies just as I grew up with them and liked them.
I've seen several people state they felt this was the best version (at least at the time) of the laserdisc transfers to DVD. It has uncompressed sound and a widescreen anamorphic picture. Other than making the picture anamorphic, it's my understanding this presents the definitive edition laserdiscs just as they appeared. I own the limited edition 2006 DVDs and watch them from time to time (I prefer them to my Blu-rays). I look forward to hearing the uncompressed audio on my home theater and watching the anamorphic picture and getting sucked into the movies all over again.
I now have two sons and I want to show them Star Wars as I first saw it and loved it. I can't speak for everyone, but that's the reason for my interest.
Thanks to all involved in these projects.
May the Force be with you.
I'm totally with you on most of that. Except that this is any kind of definitive release, there are many, many better LD transfers. In fact I would put this one in the lower part of the list. The main reason being the mpeg-2 artifacts and overall low image quality from such a low bitrate. It's hard enough as it is to fit a 2 hour movie on a single layer DVD without using more than 1/3 of the space for audio.
Since this release someone found a LD with a digital transfer of the 1977 stereo mix that is superb. So I wouldn't even give this the top spot for audio quality, though it may have held that honor when it was released?
If you want a very fine LD transfer I would suggest
_,,,^..^,,,_ 's OUT Rules 2.0
It's so much better looking than the old LD transfers, it's not even in the same ballpark. Any fan who hasn't seen it should check it out. It looks even better than any of the GOUT sourced releases imho.
It was upped to a.b.starwars 902 days ago. Unfortunately it is dead at myspleen though his 1.0 release still has seeders. I have not seen 1.0, but he considered 2.0 to be a significant upgrade:
- a bit more saturation than OUT 1.0 - NO color correction was applied
- the new sharpen/denoise script is less aggressive than the old one
- a proper color matrix is used this time for the final release (TV.709)
- proper levels used; PC -> TV, from captures to release
It really is stunning. I would go so far as to say it is the definitive LD transfer at this point.
http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-A-New-Hope-OUT-ruLes-20-AVCHD-BD-RELEASED/topic/15313/