
- Time
- Post link
Congratulations! You’ve put a ludicrous amount of time and effort into this project, and I look forward to watching it with my kids when they get just a little older.
Congratulations! You’ve put a ludicrous amount of time and effort into this project, and I look forward to watching it with my kids when they get just a little older.
😍 Damn man, that’s a lovely thing to hear! I really hope your family enjoy it!
And those last few episodes are now all uploaded. So-
Probably in this order:
That’s the whole end-to-end show, complete, fully polished, and available now.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=1Bix44C1EzY
Seriously, good job dude! You have done some amazing work turning this “diamond in the rough” series into a polished gem. I can’t wait to prepare my casual fan friends for the Ahsoka show using this edit.
My preferred Skywalker Saga experience:
I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX
Congratulations on finishing this, it’s very impressive and your parents must be very proud! (Couldn’t resist a Raimi line)
This is now my go to whenever I want to watch this show or any episodes, absolutely brilliant job and I look forward to any future edits you have planned.
Congratulations on finishing this and thank you for sharing, Eddie. This towers as one of the great achievements our little community has produced in my books, and it’s all thanks to your unstoppable efforts. Once again, congratulations and thank you.
Goddamn guys, that’s so delightful to hear. Thank you all so much - this means a huge amount to me. It’s absolutely been worth it. What a pleasure.
Since you’ve all been so lovely, how about-
Nothing too special here, I’ve just taken two Ahsoka episodes from Tales of the Jedi and turned them into content here - one that precedes this show and one that follows it. And while I was at it, they established some new standards I also applied to my existing Maul and Obi-Wan coda, which used content from Rebels.
Now, TCW:R really contains the full Clone Wars Ahsoka story (other than Rebels content) and the full Maul/Obi-Wan relationship.
Note the ‘B’ in the episode number.
This is one of two episodes from Tales of the Jedi which are particularly relevant to the story of the Clone Wars, in this case the introduction of Ahsoka and her discovery by the Jedi.
Notes:
This is one of two episodes from Tales of the Jedi which are particularly relevant to the story of the Clone Wars, in this case Ahsoka’s perspective on the aftermath of the war and the Republic’s transition into the Empire, and the rise of the Inquisition (their first canon appearance in video media!)
Notes:
This is a little extra, just to close out the Maul/Obi-Wan plotline that’s been such a key feature of this series and the prequel era. It’s intended for people who DON’T intend to watch the rest of the Star Wars Rebels animated show. To that end, I’ve removed all Rebels context, allowing the plot to focus on Maul and Obi-Wan, with Ezra just being a context-free tool of Maul - though he still has character. As to how he’s a force-sensitive with holocrons and knowledge of Maul and Obi-Wan, well, the viewer would have to watch more of Rebels for that.
Noteworthy changes:
Eddie, we are going to have to pour water on you because you are on fire!
[That will be the last corny joke of the day.]
In all seriousness,thanks for giving us more of Ahsoka. A truly great character who I hope will get her justice in the show coming up.
Eh, could I give a suggestion?
Why not intertwine the Ahsoka childhood episode with the RESOLVE coda? In the two arcs we see her dealing with family, dealing with a threat… We have good parallels here.
I’m suggesting this because her childhood episode is super boring. But making this related to their final “clone wars” moments would improve the memories of her past a ton. Besides that, nobody gives a f*ck about Ahsoka in the beginning of the series, so showing a slow and bland introduction of her as a season zero episode don’t give much sense to me, particularly.
In fact, I think that intertwining her childhood episode with the arc where she leaves the jedi order would be the best place to “deposit” these scenes of her as a child, because there is her true farewell to the series. It’s like saying “Hey, this is the last time you’re going to see this character, so let’s show you what’s left to know about her, which is her origin”. That would increase the strength of that arc EVEN MORE, making it even more emotional, in my opinion.
But maybe it’s a little weird to do that due to the difference in CW and TOTJ styles.
Anyway, I just think that the Life and Death episode works so much better being cut as flashback segments distributed in an already established episode/arc of Clone Wars/TOTJ than an episode as itself.
It’s a tricky one. You’re right that the episode isn’t super interesting, though it’s harmless enough. I think it’s in an odd place where you’d watch it if you cared about Ahsoka specifically, but it’s not vital to the Clone Wars.
Since it’s optional I worry that pairing it with other things might drag them down, especially since it’s so slow paced. Ahsoka’s Fall is such a perfect arc that I wouldn’t want to distract from it, whereas pairing it with Resolve (you’d call the episode ‘Birth and Rebirth’) is a genuinely decent idea. They’d benefit from having the same aesthetic, though the relevance (and jeopardy) might be lost at that placement in the chronology.
I think there’re two other options: Firstly, as a (long) opening flashback in the Christophsis episode, which wouldn’t be much different from just watching those episodes back to back; and secondly, dumped in to my ‘Tales from the Clone Wars’ anthology which takes content from a bunch of sources and just sticks them together, to bridge my seasons two and three. (A reminder: I plan to include the other Ahsoka episode from TOTJ, the one where she’s repeatedly trained against clones, in that episode too, kind of as a bridging story. She passes out a lot, which would help with the transitions, and it’d also help explain why the art style is all over the place.)
But yes, not sure. Open to further input here!
In other news, now that I’m all done, I started my rewatch from scratch. But since I was in a Tales of the Jedi mood, I watched all of Dooku’s TOTJ episodes first, and then my two prologues, then into TCW:R proper.
And I’ve gotta tell you, that ordering - chronological (minus Ahsoka’s intro), but skipping the two first prequel movies, really works. Benefits:
The only things really missing from watching it this way are seeing the Obi-Wan/Maul plot start (you could maybe watch TPM as a flashback before the nightsisters arc?) and more detail on the clones/Jango/Boba (you could maybe watch AOTC between seasons one and two, after we see Kamino but before we see Boba seeking revenge on Mace).
Anyway, it makes for interesting viewing!
Yeah, that does sound like a pretty neat way to watch the prequel material. Part of me wishes that the OT was labeled as “Episodes 1-3”, with no need for the prequels to be awkwardly forced into a trilogy format. Instead, we would get a full fledged live-action prequel TV series, structured pretty much exactly like how you suggest.
My preferred Skywalker Saga experience:
I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX
Eddie, so happy and proud of you for completing this. I have been following from the beginning and it crazy to see you finally complete it!
I feel like for a lot of people who will want to watch prequel content, they will probably just watch episodes 1 and 2 before starting TCW:R. I could see the benefit of letting TCW being people’s introduction rather than the prequels, though.
It would be interesting to see your thoughts for the future AOTC thread since it is basically the bridge into your TCW:R. I think you’ll have a nice perspective for some potential changes that could bring it more in-line with that.
Congratulations! I know that I haven’t given feedback for a few months, but I want to join in to affirm your excellent work and major accomplishment.
Regarding future efforts, I’d still really like to see an attempt at making 1x01 a better introduction to our new characters, even if it takes the focus off Anakin and ObiWan slightly. I think there’s a lot of potential with those young Ahsoka scenes from the new short, but also potential by blending in the Assassin episode with Ulani and Ventress as something that happens on the way to the planet, or even by using the Jedi investigating Grievous’ fortress in season 2 as an intro to his character in 1x01 or 1x02, leading into the Malevolence story.
Thank you both! It’s kind of wild that this started as a little idea that I just ran with.
Rogue, I’m not suggesting people watch TOTJ then TCW:R, and it’s not something I’ll roll into the plan for this show - it’s more just something I discovered that offers a fun perspective.
But yes, it might spawn some good AOTC thoughts. Since I’ve got an episodic hat on lately, I can see the merits in splitting the Anakin and Obi-Wan plots out entirely, for example, and not having Anakin at Geonosis.
Vranir, I agree. I think it might suit a movie more than episodes, but maybe this ordering could work:
RELEASED - S00E00b - Prologue: Life and Death (Ahsoka) (v2.0)
Just FYI: This prologue episode does not start until the 3:42 mark. You get a black silent screen until then.
RELEASED - S00E00b - Prologue: Life and Death (Ahsoka) (v2.0)
Just FYI: This prologue episode does not start until the 3:42 mark. You get a black silent screen until then.
Thanks, I’m on it!
RELEASED - S00E00b - Prologue: Life and Death (Ahsoka) (v2.0)
Just FYI: This prologue episode does not start until the 3:42 mark. You get a black silent screen until then.
Thanks, I’m on it!
Fixed!
Hi folks, now that this is complete and polished, I’m looking to launch it over on the fanedit.org forums. Threads from unapproved editors can get buried quite easily over there (and I’m still not approved) so I’d be extremely grateful if you could give the thread over there a bit of love - perhaps via a brief review, or a comment on the approach taken over here? Thanks in advance to anyone who helps give this edit a little buzz beyond our borders!
I know you’ve probably gotten this question plenty of times before, but have you given any thought to a Rebels: Refocused? Rebels is probably going to become much more relevant with the Ahsoka series on the horizon. Unfortunately, I think Rebels is harder to reshape because the progression is significantly more linear, but I’ve had friends that have complained that the first season in particular is hard to get through.