- Time
- Post link
how could you got it wrong everything i said?
I didn’t get it wrong. When you find it, show me and I’ll admit that I’m wrong.
The Best Fan Edits Ever? — Page 2
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
to match how jabba looks like in the later releases not how he looks like in 97
when i said the vhs versions i didn´t meant looking like the same quality i meant the changes that the vhs releases did in those films like c3po talking instead of being silence in the scene where it shows in the monitor where it is the tractor beam
- Time
- Post link
how could you got it wrong everything i said?
I didn’t get it wrong. When you find it, show me and I’ll admit that I’m wrong.
what you mean?i was talking about my comment
- Time
- Post link
lucas should have replaced puppet jabba and puppet yoda with cgi jabba and cgi yoda because it looks strange young kids seeing how yoda looks like in esb and rotj compared to the prequels and also looks strange kids seeing jabba in rotj after seeing him in a new hope and see how diferent he looks compared to how he is in rotj and if lucas didn´t do that because of the haters he should have not care that they would attack him and do that.a director should not listen to tooxic people with is why he shouldn´t have given jar jar a minor role because of those people specially since even after lucas did that nothing change those pieces of trash still attack him because of jar jar not to mentioned that is a stupid thing to criticize since he was made for the kids but this people think that star wars was allways for adults only
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
even though i talk about the original versions of the og trilogy i to like the special editions but i take the original versions as the canon versions and i consider episodes 1,2 and episode 3 fanedits of padme living at the end of rots as canon and i consider the canon events of the clone wars to be diferent events from both multimedia projects but i still consider canon anakin meeting red leader during the clone wars and the battle of alderaan and the reason for that is because if i consider fanedits of padme living canon than none of the multimedia projects fit since they are both canon with rots theatrical release and despite considering the original versions to be canon i still think that lucas should have replaced anakin jedi robes that he has at the end of rotj with the clotches he was wearing on mustafar with is the same clotches he was wearing in the ashoka show because it made more sense for him as a force ghost to wear those instead of the jedi robes
- Time
- Post link
Wicketthewarrick, honest question, how old are you?
i wasn´t trolling i was serious
- Time
- Post link
i have never been on fanedit org
- Time
- Post link
Equating those who are not in favor of George’s changes to the original trilogy to being toxic haters, on a site created and founded for advocating for the preservation of the original theatrical trilogy is not a good look , and if anything , is toxic behavior itself.
- Time
- Post link
Wicketthewarrick, honest question, how old are you?
i wasn´t trolling i was serious
So was I
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
i have never been on fanedit org
yes u are, is the same ideas and the way he writes stuff
idk
- Time
- Post link
i happen to write like him and have the same ideas so what?doesn´t prove im the same person many people write the same way as others and have the same ideas
- Time
- Post link
i happen to write like him and have the same ideas so what?doesn´t prove im the same person many people write the same way as others and have the same ideas
Yes, it does in fact prove you are him.
- Time
- Post link
i happen to write like him and have the same ideas so what?doesn´t prove im the same person many people write the same way as others and have the same ideas
Yes, it does in fact prove you are him.
indeed
idk
- Time
- Post link
wrong
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Equating those who are not in favor of George’s changes to the original trilogy to being toxic haters, on a site created and founded for advocating for the preservation of the original theatrical trilogy is not a good look , and if anything , is toxic behavior itself.
we can like both the original versions and the special editions
i never said i didn´t like the original versions
- Time
- Post link
Equating those who are not in favor of George’s changes to the original trilogy to being toxic haters, on a site created and founded for advocating for the preservation of the original theatrical trilogy is not a good look , and if anything , is toxic behavior itself.
we can like both the original versions and the special editions
i never said i didn´t like the original versions
- Time
- Post link
Equating those who are not in favor of George’s changes to the original trilogy to being toxic haters, on a site created and founded for advocating for the preservation of the original theatrical trilogy is not a good look , and if anything , is toxic behavior itself.
we can like both the original versions and the special editions
i never said i didn´t like the original versions but i am right george should not care what the haters think and replaced puppet yoda and jabba with cgi yoda and jabba if they are the reason why he didn´t do that
- Time
- Post link
I would like a fanedit of the original versions of the original trilogy (and I mean the versions that were released on VHS, and aired on TV, not the theatrical versions) that restores deleted scenes, and replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba, with AI Jabba and AI Yoda.
I wish Lucas did replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba from ROTJ with CGI Yoda and CGI Jabba, and made CGI Jabba in ROTJ look like how he looks like in ANH, because it looks weird for younger fans who watch the movies seeing how different Yoda looks like in the Original Trilogy, and how diferent Jabba looks like in ROTJ, after seeing him in ANH. Of course I want that fanedit to do what Adywan did with the Emperor in his ESB fanedit.Had to rewrite and decode this mess of a post to even understand what the first half meant.
Basically boils down to;
- Wants an edit using the 80s home video masters of the films (for some reason)
- Wants all deleted scenes back in
- Wants Yoda replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the prequels I think?)
- Wants Jabba replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the 97SE)
Any takers? Sounds like a simple task clearly.
i meant the changes the original versions that aired on tv and the vhs releases did to the movies not the quality of the vhs releases like c3po speaking instead of being silence like in the theatrical release in the scene where it shows in the monitor where it is the tractor beam
to match how jabba looks like in the later releases not how he looks like in 97
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
I would like a fanedit of the original versions of the original trilogy (and I mean the versions that were released on VHS, and aired on TV, not the theatrical versions) that restores deleted scenes, and replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba, with AI Jabba and AI Yoda.
I wish Lucas did replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba from ROTJ with CGI Yoda and CGI Jabba, and made CGI Jabba in ROTJ look like how he looks like in ANH, because it looks weird for younger fans who watch the movies seeing how different Yoda looks like in the Original Trilogy, and how diferent Jabba looks like in ROTJ, after seeing him in ANH. Of course I want that fanedit to do what Adywan did with the Emperor in his ESB fanedit.Had to rewrite and decode this mess of a post to even understand what the first half meant.
Basically boils down to;
- Wants an edit using the 80s home video masters of the films (for some reason)
- Wants all deleted scenes back in
- Wants Yoda replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the prequels I think?)
- Wants Jabba replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the 97SE)
Any takers? Sounds like a simple task clearly.
you think its a simple task but you think that my fanedit wish for the prequels is not.care to explain why?
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Wicketthewarrick, can you dial it down please? You might not realise it but the way you’re interacting with people here is coming off as pretty abrasive.
You’re welcome to your opinions but you’re arguing with everyone who challenges you, and then firstly not paying enough attention to understand what others are saying, and secondly not communicating clearly at all yourself. Please try to be more attentive to what people are saying to you, and maybe proofread your messages with an outsider’s perspective before hitting send, if you’d like to fit into the community better.
You’re also making a lot of requests for extremely specific fanedits. People rarely, if ever, make fanedits to order. In almost every case, fan edits either get made because an individual is passionate about their own specific ideas, or a community consensus arises around a well-thought-out idea that’s argued clearly and well. If you want specific edits which don’t already exist, I’d strongly advise you to either pick up the skills and put in the effort to make them yourself, or communicate your ideas far more clearly and see if they gain popular momentum.
If you read this post as criticism that you need to defend against, you’re taking the wrong message from it, and I’d advise you to breathe, take a minute, and read it again.
- Time
- Post link
Folks, I think Vladius may have the right idea about our new friend Wicketthewarrick.
This appears to be a very young indidual in need of some guidance like the way EddieDean demonstrated.
- Time
- Post link
I would like a fanedit of the original versions of the original trilogy (and I mean the versions that were released on VHS, and aired on TV, not the theatrical versions) that restores deleted scenes, and replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba, with AI Jabba and AI Yoda.
I wish Lucas did replaced puppet Yoda and puppet Jabba from ROTJ with CGI Yoda and CGI Jabba, and made CGI Jabba in ROTJ look like how he looks like in ANH, because it looks weird for younger fans who watch the movies seeing how different Yoda looks like in the Original Trilogy, and how diferent Jabba looks like in ROTJ, after seeing him in ANH. Of course I want that fanedit to do what Adywan did with the Emperor in his ESB fanedit.Had to rewrite and decode this mess of a post to even understand what the first half meant.
Basically boils down to;
- Wants an edit using the 80s home video masters of the films (for some reason)
- Wants all deleted scenes back in
- Wants Yoda replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the prequels I think?)
- Wants Jabba replaced with CGI or AI (to match what he looks like in the 97SE)
Any takers? Sounds like a simple task clearly.
i meant the changes the vhs releases did to the movies not the quality of the vhs releases.changes like c3po speaking instead of being silence like in the theatrical release in the scene where it shows in the monitor where it is the tractor beam but the fanedits of the original versions of 5 and 6 can be also the theatrical versions but episode 4 has to be the version that aired on tv and was released on vhs because the theatrical release cuts c3po speach.
to match how jabba looks like in the later releases not how he looks like in 97
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
i would like a tcw fanedit that replaces matt lanter voice with hayden voice in all episodes and movie including the chrystall crisis arc and i want the movie deleted scenes restored
- Time
- Post link
Well go do it then. There’s at least 2 extended version of the TCW film and several of the show, go sign up for one of those voice changing LLM sites and dub it yourself.
- Time
- Post link
Well go do it then. There’s at least 2 extended version of the TCW film and several of the show, go sign up for one of those voice changing LLM sites and dub it yourself.
okay