logo Sign In

Star wars v.s Star trek — Page 2

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Didn't Kurtz get fired midway through production of ESB and replaced by Howard Kazanjian (who also did ROTJ)? Maybe we should change the name of this website to originalduology.com if people hate ROTJ so much.

Anyways, onto the topic. Even though I prefer SW, and I can see the appeal of Star Trek. TOS and TNG seem to be very enjoyable shows that have a few great episodes in them. DS9 I heard has a strong cult following, and Voyager and Enterprise are shows to be avoided. 

Author
Time

I don't hate ROTJ.  It disappoints me, sure, as there are a great many missed opportunities in it, and it doesn't feel like a continuation of what was set up in ESB ... but I still enjoy it, and watch it often (if not as often as SW and ESB).

Author
Time

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

Author
Time

In an ideal world only PSYCHO DAYV would be allowed to post in caps at least he gives his post a second glance before sending them.

Author
Time

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RTc32qBpAk

Author
Time

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Author
Time
 (Edited)

haljordan28 said:

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

KURTZ  NEVER GOT  FIRED  MUCH LESS HALF  WAY THRUGH   EPISODE 5.   HE LEFT   AFTER EMPIRE.   HE  WANTED NOTHING TO DO  WITH THE DIRECTIO   LUCAS  WAS TAKING THINGS.  THE SAME WAY  LAWERNCE  KASDAN  WANTED NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PREQUELS   AFER LUCAS GAVE HIM AN OUTLINE OF IT.

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

 I'll be honest, I don't care for the prequels. But can't everyone have their own opinions? And him posting a link to "Whambulance" isn't saying how he's a fan of the prequels, he's just tired of hearing your complaining about then...

Author
Time

haljordan28 said:

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Wow.  You're kind of a dick, huh?

Author
Time

ChainsawAsh said:

haljordan28 said:

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Wow.  You're kind of a dick, huh?

 Dick

Author
Time

ChainsawAsh said:

haljordan28 said:

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Wow.  You're kind of a dick, huh?

no, I just get sick and tired of prequel lovers doing anything and everything they can  which includes  bringing down the OT films and telling lies and defending lies told by lucas just  to try and not make their beloved prequels (JUNKQUELS)  not look like the pieces of shit that they are

Author
Time

I challenge you to find one person that could be described as a "prequel lover" on this site.  Hell, we have a whole section of the forum dedicated to people who are re-writing the prequels from scratch, as if the official versions never existed.  Not to mention all the fan edits of the existing versions.

Author
Time

Also, it bears mentioning that "junkquels" is not a very clever moniker. If you're going for satire, you'd be better off with something that either rhymes with prequels (like "freakquels") or something that is otherwise etymologically related to prequels (and I can't really think of an example for that one).

But really, either way, nothing will make that particular approach clever or admirable. It's about as silly and sophomoric as referring to George Lucas as "George Luca$" or using the oft-repeated "M$ Windows". It's just not clever. Or humorous. It's juvenile and it makes people less likely to take you seriously. So why bother taking the time to type the extra letters when you could focus that energy and time on improving your overall spelling and grammar?

Every 27th customer will get a ball-peen hammer, free!

Author
Time

ChainsawAsh said:

haljordan28 said:

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Wow.  You're kind of a dick, huh?

That's like saying the Leaning Tower of Pisa kind of leans.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Wee-Weequals or Pee-Peequals, Pooquals, Preschoolquals, Padmequals, Thickyprethickyqualthickies...etc

Author
Time

haljordan28 said:

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

 

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Between "Junkquels" and using "prequel lover" as a prejorative, I have to ask:

How old are you?

Author
Time

TheBoost said:

haljordan28 said:

Alexrd said:

haljordan28 said:

 

 

EVERYONE   HATED THE DIRECTION LUCAS TOOK THING...HAMIL,  FORD,   KURTZ,  KASDAN....EVERYONE.  AND WE ALL SEE WHY  CAUSE WE ALL SEE THEW OUTCOME OF THE  PREQUELS AKA  JUNKQUELS

No.

just another prequel fan in denial .  sorry if the truth hurts prequel lover.  but YES. everything  I just posted is fact  not my opinion

Between "Junkquels" and using "prequel lover" as a prejorative, I have to ask:

How old are you?

 GUY                    YOUR JST A PREQUEL LOVE          R! DON'T TY TO MADE A ARGUEMENT                     WITH ME, CAUSE YOR JUST A                   PREQUEL LOVER!

Author
Time

I am 36  and captsolo you need to watch star trek two the wrath of khan.  next o the empire strkes back its the best sci fi film ever made. great acting,.  great screenplay   great philosophy and drama.  the way empire is hearlded as the best  star wars   khan is  spoken of the same way in star trek circles.  it stands out  miles  above the rest. its almost not even a star trek film its so good.

Author
Time

haljordan28 said:

I am 36  and captsolo you need to watch star trek two the wrath of khan.  next o the empire strkes back its the best sci fi film ever made. great acting,.  great screenplay   great philosophy and drama.  the way empire is hearlded as the best  star wars   khan is  spoken of the same way in star trek circles.  it stands out  miles  above the rest. its almost not even a star trek film its so good.

 

Umm...the [second-] best sci fi film ever made? Are you serious??


 

Every 27th customer will get a ball-peen hammer, free!

Author
Time

I wouldn't consider Empire OR Khan to be in the top five best sci-fi films ever made, let alone the top two.  What about 2001?  Or Blade Runner? Children of MenMoonPlanet of the ApesThe Day the Earth Stood StillInvasion of the Body SnatchersAbre los ojosAlienThe Road?

I could go on, but I'll stop.  My point is, every one of those films is (in my mind) superior to both Empire and Wrath of Khan, at least as science fiction.

Author
Time

Star Wars isn't in any way Science Fiction it's Space Opera or Space Fantasy (Sinbad with laser swords).

Star Trek is almost Science Fiction but Wrath Of Khan is less so, it's essentially a submarine war film with phasers.

The Slow Motion Picture is the closest you get to a Science Fiction Star Trek film, it also the most cinematic of all the Trek films (TWOK is really a TV movie with a cinema release).

I love TWOK I'm not dissing it for one second but other than a little nod to terraforming it's Sci-Fi stripes are not exactly earned.