captainsolo said:
It's going to be September 20th 2004 all over again.
If a new soundmix is being made, then why reuse the 04 scans? Yes they were cleaned up by Lowry Digital, but have so many other issues that a new start would be extremely beneficial.
This assumes George Lucas is aware of any issues.
The reason there is a new sound mix is very probably because Blu Rays have 6 channel surround, or whatever it is, and not the 5.1 of 2004. So, Ben Burtt probably simply asked if he could do a new mix for the format. They probably have all the original elements from the 2004 mix still on-line there, so it's a pretty simple feat, very different from doing a brand new scan and DI from scratch. It's probably not an attempt to "fix" anything from the 2004 mix, although I wouldn't be surprised if they did smooth out some of the issues from the last mix simply because they are getting another crack at it.
If they simply would scan and release the 97s as-is there would be no problems with transfers! And isn't the digital footage already at 2K?
The footage was at 2K, but I'm not sure what if any of it was kept in the computer (remember, this was 1996 after all). There was no such thing as a DI, so the scans were printed back onto film and cut into the physical negative, maybe this is all there is to work with now.