- Time
- Post link
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
I call it The Special Definitive Collection (SDC) 
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
Star Wars Edit: DC/Faces audio + 2004 video Hybrid (Released)
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
- Time
- Post link
- Time
- Post link
There are so many edits, I thought everyone was already "edit tired" but I thought I could try and see if anyone was interested anyway. But since no one was I edited my original post
But now I had a problem authoring the dvd. I had everything encoded, all the multi angles and stuff but when I try to compile DVDMaestro starts bitching about the maximum bitrate being exceeded. But that's impossible...
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
What are your encoding specs and what did you encode with?
- Time
- Post link
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
Originally posted by: Karyudo
Hey, Arnie.d: if you figure it's worth doing, that's all that should really matter! I read your blurb the other day, and it sounded pretty cool. But I don't think I should be posting and making you feel like you had to do it. Though if you did it and put it up someplace, I'd download it.
Hey, Arnie.d: if you figure it's worth doing, that's all that should really matter! I read your blurb the other day, and it sounded pretty cool. But I don't think I should be posting and making you feel like you had to do it. Though if you did it and put it up someplace, I'd download it.
Oh, I'm doing the edit, no doubt about it. I want it for my personal use. Just wanted to see if it was worth sharing.
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
Originally posted by: Arnie.d
I used CCE SP v2.70. I selected the multi angle option with a maximum bitrate of 4100 (so 2 angles; 2 x 4100 + 1536 = 9736, shouldn't be too high). I tested the multi angle option in DVDMaestro (v2.9) with just the multi angle scenes + audio and there was no problem, it compiled ok, I burned it to dvd and it played fine. But when I try to compile the entire dvd I get an error about an VOBU exceeding the max bitrate of 8000. But I'm not sure if the program means 8000 with or without audio. But since the test with only the multi angle scenes went fine I don't know what all the trouble is about.
I used CCE SP v2.70. I selected the multi angle option with a maximum bitrate of 4100 (so 2 angles; 2 x 4100 + 1536 = 9736, shouldn't be too high). I tested the multi angle option in DVDMaestro (v2.9) with just the multi angle scenes + audio and there was no problem, it compiled ok, I burned it to dvd and it played fine. But when I try to compile the entire dvd I get an error about an VOBU exceeding the max bitrate of 8000. But I'm not sure if the program means 8000 with or without audio. But since the test with only the multi angle scenes went fine I don't know what all the trouble is about.
Hey Arnie,
Did a bit of a google search, and this came up over at Doom9:
http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=36724
Don't know if it's any help to you, although it looks like the Max bitrate for 2 angles is 7800Kbps...
A colleague of mine started authoring a multi-angle project in Spruce a few years back. Everything seemed to be working well, but then it just broke - he ended up re-authoring the entire project in Sonic DVD Creator. As I understand it, Spruce can get quite flakey with multi-angle. I would have said something along the lines of the number of angles, or having angle blocks that don't run for the entire movie, but by the sound of it, you had it working, it's just when you've added everything else in, it's gone wrong.
As an experiment, have you tried converting your PCM to Ac3 to see it that fixes the problem? Not something you want to do for your final project, but may be worth a punt.
- Time
- Post link
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
I believe the bitrate limitations is to help with the interleaving of the angle blocks.
With regards to you PCM, although the technical bitrate is 1536Kbps, I've always bit-budgeted for 1600-1700Kbps, just so that I have a little extra headroom - PCM can be a bit of a hog when it comes to resources.
HTH
- Time
- Post link
For instance, I when the GOUT was released I began to work on a DVD for "Star Wars" that would have multiple angles representing the two crawls (sourced from GOUT and Moth3r's version), and would use audio tracks representing the 1993 DC, the 1977 mono mix, the 1977 stereo mix, the 1985 mix, an isolated score, and finally, the DC commentary track, along with self created subtitles. After finalizing all menus, subtitle tracks and and audio tracks in DVDMaestro, I ran into trouble getting the multi-angle version of the dvd to compile properly.
Here I will explain the steps I used to create the final version of this DVD. The first step was to make sure that the portions of the film that were required to have two angles had the same GOP Structure. This was accomplished using DVD Decrypter, AVIsynth, and VirtualDub, with a final encode step using Nero Vision MPEG encoder. It was important for me to match the chapter points from the official GOUT DVD, so I made sure that the GOP structure was the same for the crawl portion of chapter 2 and for the first shot from chapter 3. These two sections were encoded separately. I then needed to create a short video that had very low bitrate (it won't work otherwise) that would cover the same number of frames as the first chapter, and a second low bitrate video to cover the single-angle first portion of chapter 2. I then used Cuttermaran to join these two files together with both of the newly created files for the first angle as well as the single-angle portion of chapter 3 (the last two frames must be re-encoded b/c they are B frame, if this is not done there will be a pause in the final DVD video) [this will be video file 1]. I then join the two files created to cover the second angle [video file 2], and create a third video file that covers only the reencoded first chapter and first part of the second chapter [video file 3]. I finalize the files by using 'Pulldown.exe' to enable pulldown flags (This was an NTSC project) and to ensure they will work in DVDMaestro.
This will cover the DVDMaestro creation of the disc.
First, I created a project in Maestro with full length audio tracks that I needed as well as all subtitles and menus, I then add video file 1 (from above) to angle 1. Next I add video file 3 from above to angle 2. This will end up with a multi angle portion covering the first chapter and the first part of chapter 2. Now add an angle change marker (create chapter point, but uncheck the chapter marker box) to the very end of the shorter angle 2 video clip. Now drag video file 2 from above to the timeline after video file 3. This will remove file 3 from the timeline and add file 2 at the correct position. The next step is to add another angle change marker at the end of video file 2 and add chapter points at the correct positions of chapter 2 and 3. You should now have a project in which the first angle covers chapters 1-3 entirely and angle two represents the 'Episode IV' crawl only. This project, with full-length audio tracks and full length subtitle tracks and all menus is ready to be compiled.
Next I create a new DVD project with only one video track (the full bitrate MPEG rip of the GOUT DVD, use 'ReStream.exe' to remove sequence end codes) and all audio and subtitle tracks. To this I add all necessary chapter points as well as markers at the beginning and end of the multi-angle areas. I then author this DVD.
Using PGCedit I open the first authored DVD and add blank cells and chapters until I reach the total number desired for the final dvd, in this case 50 chapters plus 1 15 frame chapter at the end (51 total chapters, make sure all new cells have VOB ID 5 and Cell ID 1). I then add entry points for all chapters to the main title (this is only necessary if you have chapter menus, you can copy coding from the second DVD you compiled). I then open the VTS_01_0.ifo in IFOedit and open the VTS_PGCITI portion and then open VTS_PGC_1. You can scroll to the bottom of this list to find a list of the VOB ID and Cell ID for each cell in the main movie. The VOB ID for all newly created cells should already be set to a value of 5 to match the last original cell. Then number all new cells starting at 1 fro the last original cell and up to 49 for the last cell in the title. Save this ifo and replace the .bup file, then open this DVD in VOBlanker. Make sure that even though this is a multi-angle dvd, the main movie is processed. I then blank all cells in the title except those in the multi-angle portions of the film. This includes all newly added cells and the first two cells (low bitrate chapter 1 and first part of chapter 2). Also, you will get better results if you do not blank out the second half of chapter 3 (the single angle section of chapter 3).
Next I open the second DVD in VOBLanker and extract all cells in the main title to multiple files. When this is complete I open the blanked version of the first DVD and replace all single angle chapters with the extracted vobs from the second DVD (Replace the low bitrate version of the first two cells with the higher bit rate version, also make sure not to replace any multi-angle portions of the movie). Finally, the ifo files must be updated in IFOedit and PGCedit. First, open the VIDEO_TS.ifo file in IFOedit. Change the number of angles for Title_1 under the VMG_PTT_SRPT section from 1 to 2 and save (replace .bup). Then open this DVD in PGCedit and edit the PGC for the main movie title. VOBlanker changes the cell flags for all of the cells and these must be fixed. The first cell/chapter should have a default value of two for the first flag. All single angle chapter cells, except for cells immediately after multi-angle cells, should have a value of 8 for 'seamless playback' joint. For this example, the first cell is set to a value of 2, the second cell, (the single angle portion of chapter 2) is set to a value of 8, the third cell (the first angle of the second part of chapter 2) is set to a value of 95, the fourth cell (the second angle of the second part of chapter 2) is set to a value of 223, the fifth cell (the first angle portion of the first part of chapter 3) is set to a value of 93, the sixth cell (the second angle of the first part of chapter 3) is set to 221, the seventh cell (the single-angle second portion of chapter 3) is set to a value of 10, and all other single-angle cells are set to a value of 8. Finally, make any other desired changes in PGCedit (like correcting stream numbers) and save. The DVD is now finalized with two angles and as many chapters as are necessary. Additionally, It will play seamlessly.
Please PM me for more details if necessary as I have done a few other multi-angle dvds in DVD Maestro.
If I had some gum, I’d chew a hole into the sun…
- Time
- Post link
Thanks for the effort to try and explain how I can make the multiple angle compile work. I'll try and see if it works for me.
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
- Time
- Post link
Seamless branching is different from multi angle because you can basically make a playlist of chapters and play them in any order you want (so no same size, Same GOPs etc.). But to make a playlist play seamless you have to order the info in such a way it plays seamless. And that's difficult. But I've been playing around with it and I think I can make almost any playlist play seamless, jumping gaps of multiple gigabytes. It's not true seamless branching offcourse, it's semi seamless branching but it plays seamless. I have to do more testing, but it would be so cool if you could for instance in the dvd menu choose between an all digital Battle of Yavin or an all original models Battle of Yavin.
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
I basically replaced the video of the theatrical edition of Star Wars with 2004 video.
- The crawl and fly-over are from the theatrical version because I didn't like the 2004 video (Star Wars logo disappears to fast and the lasers are almost invisible).
- The weird lizard is now wolfman again.
- Everything else is 2004 video.
- The audio is the DC/Faces PCM from Belbucus. A few gaps were filled using the 2004 audio (thanks to Darth Mallwalker) because the video didn't match the audio otherwise (like some lasers in the battle of Yavin or some Falcon engine sounds).
- The Biggs scene is in.
- I painted Luke's green saber blue again. Well sort of. I'm not a photoshop expert but you can only improve those scenes, I'm happy with the results. The original "flicker" is still intact.
- I slightly lowered the saturation and upped the brightness a bit.
That's about it.
Oh I used the 2006 PAL release but the edit is in NTSC format (dual layer).
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
It'll take 2 days to upload.
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
Originally posted by: Arnie.d
Uploading went well, but now I get errors. This is my first post so I have no idea what it means. Can anyone help me?
Uploading went well, but now I get errors. This is my first post so I have no idea what it means. Can anyone help me?
Did you include par files to repair it?
It looks like some of the rar's are incomplete unless you are still uploading
- Time
- Post link
Edit: I think the program can't connect to the server or something
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.
- Time
- Post link
- Time
- Post link
4 - 5 - 3 - 1 - 6 - 2
Discuss…
- Time
- Post link
Hyde: Fezzy, man, it's Star Wars.