Sign In

Star Wars: A New Threat (TFA EDIT) — Page 4

Author
Time

TV’s Frink said:

Lord Haseo said:

Well the visual cut is pretty obvious. Are there not separate audio channels in which you can edit?

Sorry if I’m just confused (can’t watch right now) but it sounds like you’re mixing up audio and video again.

Am I?

Author
Time

May I ask what video editing program do you use?

Author
Time

Lord Haseo said:

TV’s Frink said:

Lord Haseo said:

Well the visual cut is pretty obvious. Are there not separate audio channels in which you can edit?

Sorry if I’m just confused (can’t watch right now) but it sounds like you’re mixing up audio and video again.

Am I?

Beats me, you said the visual cut is obvious and then asked about audio.

I read the follow up but I didn’t understand it.

Author
Time

The best and most underused birthday present I have ever received.

As it pertains to your V2 it’s much better in my opinion. A couple of audio quirks are better than noticeable video cuts any day of the week in my book

Author
Time

My issue isn’t with the actual editing but the idea of preserving the twist. Since almost everyone knows it and it’s not that big of a twist removing an entire conservation with Snoke, and Kylo saying Grandfather is too much to sacrifice for preserving a twist. The Vader helmet scene is improved with the “Grandfather” line because it shows you what Kylos misunderstanding is when it comes to the legacy of his lineage. And the Snoke scene further deepens the pressure on Kylo to not give in. It lets us know Snoke personally addresses that Kylo better not shy away from doing what’s necessary. (Killing Han)

Return of the Jedi: Remastered

Lord of the Rings: The Darth Rush Definitives

Author
Time

yeah I tried to get the audio as perfect as I could.

Author
Time

Ok, got it after watching the clip. Yeah, having that little jump in there screams “edit.”

Author
Time

darthrush said:

My issue isn’t with the actual editing but the idea of preserving the twist. Since almost everyone knows it and it’s not that big of a twist removing an entire conservation with Snoke, and Kylo saying Grandfather is too much to sacrifice for preserving a twist. The Vader helmet scene is improved with the “Grandfather” line because it shows you what Kylos misunderstanding is when it comes to the legacy of his lineage. And the Snoke scene further deepens the pressure on Kylo to not give in. It lets us know Snoke personally addresses that Kylo better not shy away from doing what’s necessary. (Killing Han)

True. I am going to see how it goes with the few people who will be testing the first draft and then decide from there.

Author
Time

TV’s Frink said:

Ok, got it after watching the clip. Yeah, having that little jump in there screams “edit.”

Check out the second version its not perfect but good for my first edit I think

Author
Time

darthrush said:

My issue isn’t with the actual editing but the idea of preserving the twist. Since almost everyone knows it and it’s not that big of a twist removing an entire conservation with Snoke, and Kylo saying Grandfather is too much to sacrifice for preserving a twist.

Especially considering the twist was known by everyone as soon as Adam Driver was announced to be playing Kylo Ren.

Author
Time

Well I am going to keep it how it is for now and see how it goes with the people previewing it and start changing from there.

Author
Time

Also I am not touching the ending with luke I find it perfect.

Author
Time

Yep, I really like that shot. I may try to make it a little less shaky

Author
Time

Exporting the first draft now. Says will take 12-14 hours

Author
Time

I have been thinking for more emotion for the han death to save the planet destruction until the end. I really want huxs speech though.

Author
Time

Also I have been working on some color corrections so my first draft has been delayed.

Author
Time

TK251 said:

I have been thinking for more emotion for the han death to save the planet destruction until the end. I really want huxs speech though.

The speech is nice but from a narrative perspective having the Hosnian System improves the film by a decent margin so it wouldn’t be that much of a loss in the grand scheme of things.

Author
Time

True, I am now exporting the first draft. Did some color correction and tweaked somethings