STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW — Page 571

Not it wasnt :P

You harly see the reflection but its there.(ady will say: all these will be downgraded when the PT:R comes)

Besides the perspective in ESB is a bit weird so the reflection is not all the time in the glass. Vader is overlap most of the glass area too.(Ady will say: No need to add any reflection, the focus in on the characters and too much work.) :P

-Angel

These ideas are coming anyways Bingo. The question is if its more work to ady or how soon the fans want the edit. or both? :)

I know that ady keeps the things grounded so that thing held me back. But you know depend the mood of making these mockups.

Interaction make the effects more grounded and real.

dont see it as PT thoughts

anyways.

-Angel

rpvee said:

vaderios said:

Adding saber reflection to the glass?

-Angel

 Wow, that's cool!  But it should look more like Vader's saber is in front of Luke's in the reflection.

TV's Frink said:

I find the lightsaber reflections distracting, regardless of how much sense it makes.  I love the saber fix a few posts earlier, however.

Well, the problem is we can see Luke's leg and the floor panel reflected in the window - if the lightsabres aren't reflected, then all reflections should be taken out (unless the light from the sabres are g-g-g-g-ghosts!)

EDIT: got beaten to the punch!  You know, I'm surprised Ric didn't point this out before any of us.  Man, Ric, you're slipping!  "Hey, there's Luke reflected in the window... but WHERE ARE THE LIGHTSABRES?!"

vaderios said:

Angel, Do you do most of your work at the resolution that it is posted here? 

I do most of the mockup work at 1920x816 px

 

-Angel

 Sweet!  So, how does a one go about getting some hi-rez copies of some of the stuff you've posted here?

Well, i've  just looked at the whole sequence and that is the only shot where you may even see a reflection from the sabers. But upon a closer inspection the most you may even see would be the tip of Vader's blade. Here's a very quick sketch of the reflection

As you can see, Lukes stance is leaning forward and tracing the line of the leg that we can see , the line of the floor light and his other foot which is off the side of the floor light there is no way you would see Luke's blade at all. So, is it worth adding just the tip, even though you may not even see it anyway? I don't think it's worth it

 Sweet!  So, how does a one go about getting some hi-rez copies of some of the stuff you've posted here?

Not a chance? :P

Well, i've  just looked at the whole sequence and that is the only shot where you may even see a reflection from the sabers. But upon a closer inspection the most you may even see would be the tip of Vader's blade.

I like that i chose the frame that it shows the reflection and ady chose the one that isnt. anyways whatever :P

If you intend for this version to be as definitive as ANH:R, then I would say that means adding even that little bit of reflection,

Well..yes :D

-Angel

vaderios said:

Well, i've  just looked at the whole sequence and that is the only shot where you may even see a reflection from the sabers. But upon a closer inspection the most you may even see would be the tip of Vader's blade.

I like that i chose the frame that it shows the reflection and ady chose the one that isnt. anyways whatever :P

Same frame from my point of view, Angel.  :-P

Same here.

vaderios said:

Well, i've  just looked at the whole sequence and that is the only shot where you may even see a reflection from the sabers. But upon a closer inspection the most you may even see would be the tip of Vader's blade.

I like that i chose the frame that it shows the reflection and ady chose the one that isnt. anyways whatever :P

Well actually Angel, i chose the frame where Luke's position is the furthest back which shows more of the reflection and is the only frame where the tip of the sabre may have been visible. Also it is only 2 frames after your pic.  In your frame there is no chance there would be any reflection from the sabers.

rpvee said:

mrbenja0618 said:

But is that really a fix? Or is it Ady pleasing the fans? I think Ady's right in this case... It's not needed.

 If there should logically be a reflection there when there isn't one, no matter how small, then yes, it would indeed be a fix.

So should i add just the smallest tip of Vaders lightsaber to just 1 frame? Because thats the sum total of frames where you may even see it

Agreed agreed! :P

I will find something else to put to the debate table :)

-Angel

The only thing that i did like about the reflections of the lightsabers was to make the window actually look more window like than just a frame, i know the glass smashes later on in the scene lol, maybe someone might add a slight shine or reflection of the interior where they are fighting to make the window look more realistic?

rpvee said:

adywan said:

rpvee said:

mrbenja0618 said:

But is that really a fix? Or is it Ady pleasing the fans? I think Ady's right in this case... It's not needed.

 If there should logically be a reflection there when there isn't one, no matter how small, then yes, it would indeed be a fix.

So should i add just the smallest tip of Vaders lightsaber to just 1 frame? Because thats the sum total of frames where you may even see it

 If you want your edit to be complete and definitive in terms of fixes (something that I believe you started Revisted to do in the first place), then absolutely, you should add that tip to that one frame, and anywhere else it might be needed.

 

I like that idea about reflecting light in those tubes behind Luke, too, but I'm just starting to become a frequent poster here and I don't want Adywan to hate me, lol.

 well considering that on average i think cameras work at 25 frames per second its worthless doing, it would literally be that quick you probably wouldnt see it.

No idea what that tool does. whatever it does make it better :)

-Angel