Sign In

STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - AVAILABLE NOW — Page 214

Author
Time

Well the whole visible hull isnt bad idea at all. But we have to think from what point of view is the camera to be visible.

A quick snapshot from force unleashed ( dont count it as canon or whatever) still it shows a good idea when is visible and not ( the hull)

 

later :)

-Angel

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Those screenshots are consistent with that I would imagine the viewing angle would have to be for one to see the hull out the windows. From the usual "back of the room forward" view, we would only see the area above the hull, not the hull itself. Since in the OT there were never (as far as I remember) many shots on a SD or SSD bridge closer to the windows, the hull does not need to be added in, as cool as it would be.

Author
Time
 (Edited)
seven said:

While looking out the front windows of the bridge of the Star Destroyer we should (shouldn't we?) see the main hull of the ship (the nose), but we don't. On the Executor as well, we should most definitely see the hull through the windows since it is much longer.

 

I'd have to absolutely agree with Siliconmaster483 (and vaderios too, if he is making the same point) on this one seven.  Every time we see 'Bridge' shots of inside either the 'Avenger' or 'Executor' sets in 'Empire' and 'Jedi', the camera angle is fixed at a certain low enough, straight-on 'point-of-view' so that we just wouldn't see any of the hulls in those particular shots. 

This goes for the shots of Vader on the 'Executor's' Bridge when we first see him on it, as well as when we last see him on it, even though his ship has a very long hull.  We just aren't positioned at enough of an angle to see any of it in these shots, so no extra work for Adywan necessary. 

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a115/doubleofive/IF-SD/SD2-009.jpg

Author
Time
gavin77 said:

Some type of clip......some type of clip.........ppppppppllllllllleeeeeeeaaaaaassssssss!!!!!

 

 watch fan trailers on youtube or go to sites that involve fan edits. to bad you can't be in hypersleep 'til it releases or the trailer shows.

Author
Time
 (Edited)
gavin77 said:

Some type of clip......some type of clip.........ppppppppllllllllleeeeeeeaaaaaassssssss!!!!!

 

 watch fan trailers on youtube or go to sites that involve fan edits. to bad you can't be in hypersleep 'til it releases or the trailer shows. just think, we'll be doing the same thing when he starts up ROTJ Revisited.

Author
Time

I don't know if I can say double post, hmmm.

The person your searching for simply does not exist

Author
Time

He probably confused "edit" with "reply with quote".

My outlook on life - we’re all on the Hindenburg anyway…no point fighting over the window seat.

Author
Time

Is it me or have the forums become a tad bitchy of late? I have noticed especially in the last six to eight months that if someone says something wrong or out of agreement with other members, that certain forum members go to town with bitching and (dare I say it?) bullying the member in question into submission.

It is not funny! it is cruel.

So what if someone has put up a double post! so what if someone says something that you do not agree with. If you feel that it is wrong say it in an intelligent manner and don't rip someone to shreds!

This is an online forum for fans of Adywan and his amazing edits. Lets keep our bitchy comments to ourselves and stop this bullying and bitching nonsense.

It detracts from why we are really here.

I am a kite dancing in a hurricane …
https://twitter.com/ActivistFangirl

Author
Time
ladyferry said:

Is it me or have the forums become a tad bitchy of late? I have noticed especially in the last six to eight months that if someone says something wrong or out of agreement with other members, that certain forum members go to town with bitching and (dare I say it?) bullying the member in question into submission.

It is not funny! it is cruel.

So what if someone has put up a double post! so what if someone says something that you do not agree with. If you feel that it is wrong say it in an intelligent manner and don't rip someone to shreds!

This is an online forum for fans of Adywan and his amazing edits. Lets keep our bitchy comments to ourselves and stop this bullying and bitching nonsense.

It detracts from why we are really here.

My feelings as well. The kneejerk reactions and condescending posturing are tiring. Adywan has always been able to effectively guide the conversation here when someone was confused or off base. No need for everyone to become self-proclaimed lieutenants. Let's keep it constructive.

Ady, great work on the Falcon/Destroyer shots! Awesome color and starfield! Can't wait to see it all together!

 

"I turned it off! I don't wanna talk to her!"
Author
Time

I did not think I was coming across that way, just a little confused ;]

But I do know what you mean, It can get heated up a little in hear with so many cooks in the kitchen. Maybe this will help http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fAH1oEPaILw

The person your searching for simply does not exist

Author
Time
 (Edited)
nohandluke said:
ladyferry said:

Is it me or have the forums become a tad bitchy of late? I have noticed especially in the last six to eight months that if someone says something wrong or out of agreement with other members, that certain forum members go to town with bitching and (dare I say it?) bullying the member in question into submission.

It is not funny! it is cruel.

So what if someone has put up a double post! so what if someone says something that you do not agree with. If you feel that it is wrong say it in an intelligent manner and don't rip someone to shreds!

This is an online forum for fans of Adywan and his amazing edits. Lets keep our bitchy comments to ourselves and stop this bullying and bitching nonsense.

It detracts from why we are really here.

My feelings as well. The kneejerk reactions and condescending posturing are tiring. Adywan has always been able to effectively guide the conversation here when someone was confused or off base. No need for everyone to become self-proclaimed lieutenants. Let's keep it constructive.

Ady, great work on the Falcon/Destroyer shots! Awesome color and starfield! Can't wait to see it all together!

 

Well said! I just worry that some of the forum members who are being bullied may be youngsters or new to being on a forum, and inexperienced with the torrents of abuse they have to endure! it may put them off in future for their voices to be heard, and that spoils the reason as to why we all participate in this forum.

We are all here for Adywan full stop, so a message to those people who are being bullies is to be kind and respect your forum members regardless of what they say.

 

I am a kite dancing in a hurricane …
https://twitter.com/ActivistFangirl

Author
Time

I ve played with some old 3d models of stardestroyer and executor to caculate in the hull is vissible and i discover that:

In the ordinary SD there is no way to have the hull onscreen when the camera is in the bridge.

But the interesting is in Executor, is a possibility to see something because of the length it has.

Here some screencaps from where the hull possible is visible:

From the side at least we can see some detail...

Also i forgot to mention that a possible spot can be when we see vader to see the stars in the executor reveal.

 

-Angel

 

PS: offtopic a bit but in ROTJ camera angles in the executor bridge allows the hull to be visible.

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time

Can you take those 3D models and put the camera in the same positions as in the film and post those shots?  Let's see the comparison.

My outlook on life - we’re all on the Hindenburg anyway…no point fighting over the window seat.

Author
Time
 (Edited)






 

 

vaderios, after digging around a little, it does seem that as far as some of the 'Executor' Bridge 'interior' shots are concerned, that it is a little tricky to work out if there should be a little of the hull showing through the 'windows' or not.

As the shots above show, the hull is certainly wide on either side of the Bridge Tower....but I still think that the way the hull is 'angled' downwards, combined with the 'eye-level', close-up camera angles through the 'windows' you've shown, allows for us not to see any of it.  I don't know if that's the case with any 'JEDI' angles though, without seeing a screenshot of where you mean.

On the other hand, you could be right, as from what I can gather, it seems the positioning of the actual 'Executor' Bridge is a little unclear according to some of the info. in the link below.  I'll be interested to see what Adywan decides on this himself, eventually. 

This resource has masses of photos and details, and I've only gone through a fraction of it, so I'm not sure how much is speculation.  There seems to be a lot of interesting stuff here though, for anyone that wades through it -

http://www.theforce.net/swtc/ssd.html

 

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Yes I considered that.

@Ziz i can't make proper renders. for some reason the bridge model and the SD models are not behave well.

@ImpFighter,

here:

You can see not only the death star surface ( so the hull should be there) but the hell bad copy paste of the spaceships (-1)

and here:

Just Ignore completely the red box (!) You can see the camera angle is a bit in top so the hull should be there :)

But these are ROTJ so an other time

Cheers

-Angel

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Thanks for those vaderios.  I'll 'bookmark' them, and get back to you when it's 'JEDI's' turn, about why I reckon these could be okay as well.

I meant to say about the top 'Executor' shot that I posted there -  I really hope Adywan picked up on the good spot by someone (sorry, can't remember who) ages ago, who noted the orange 'glow' from the enginess wrongly overlaps part of it's rear hull there....

Author
Time
 (Edited)

The only request I'd have is make my lightsabre red, I shit myself when I took off my mask and I noticed George Lucas turned it pink.

Author
Time
TheHelmetDork said:

The only request I'd have is make my lightsabre red, I shit myself when I took off my mask and I noticed George Lucas turned it pink.

 

 Adywan will be doing this.

 

 

Ady, what are you working on now?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

It seems ImpFighter that the Executor has enough big ass to be a bit on screen :)

First i tryied to be closest the the angle/camera/position with the render of this shot:

You can see it,

and secondly i find something interesting...( maybe wrong)

it seems that Mr vader isnt standing in one position during the falcon pursuit.

The window that he is talking to luke is the no 3 in this^ image

so i assume that when he sees the falcon enters to hyperspace we see him in the center window, so he was walking during this conv.

 

Fingers crossed :)

 

-Angel

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time

With the success of Star Wars Revisited, is that a surprise?

Author
Time
ladyferry said:

Is it me or have the forums become a tad bitchy of late? I have noticed especially in the last six to eight months that if someone says something wrong or out of agreement with other members, that certain forum members go to town with bitching and (dare I say it?) bullying the member in question into submission.

It is not funny! it is cruel.

So what if someone has put up a double post! so what if someone says something that you do not agree with. If you feel that it is wrong say it in an intelligent manner and don't rip someone to shreds!

This is an online forum for fans of Adywan and his amazing edits. Lets keep our bitchy comments to ourselves and stop this bullying and bitching nonsense.

It detracts from why we are really here.

 

 i didn't take it as offensive. thx for standing up for me though. besides, i've been bullied here before and prolly won't be the last time. i can get over it. and the double post, i pressed edit because i hadn't finished and acidently hit the post button. i guess it posted both anyways.