Sign In

STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - AVAILABLE NOW — Page 117

Author
Time

Adywan is not on a, Lets change It Spree, because we need the vewier to know the Precise thing that is going to happen. No, This a "What the Special Edition could have been" End qoute(DVD Cover, ADYWAN, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED(c) BAH BLAH)

 

So you see... Don Touch Meh Moviez!

The person your searching for simply does not exist

Author
Time
 (Edited)

its arguments like this where I stop paying attention to this thread lol...

 

hard to keep up with people are just opining. it's all irrelevent to an extent... no offence guys but... it's up to ady.. the only thing we can do is suggest and if he says "no," he says no..

 

all the opinions are kinda irrelevent in that light because all that matters is ady's...

 

And to be honest, saying something as vague as "the intereiors look boring. Add things like in the prequels," frankly... confuses me... I have NO idea what you're talking about to begin with... and seconly ... like what? What do you add to the interior of Hoth?


Is it not sad that in this time, we are more surprised by acts of love than acts of hate?
-Me

Author
Time

EXACTLY GoodMusician! I salute you!

"I turned it off! I don't wanna talk to her!"
Author
Time

AND I TOO!

(No, Darth Solo, It not me ths time.)

The person your searching for simply does not exist

Author
Time

This is an attempt to reedit the final scene in The Empire Strikes Back with the final shot being Luke, Leia, 3P0 & R2 looking out the window instead of the ship taking off. This has been done to match the other endings for the Star Wars films. The edits are a little jarring and I know the transition used to begin the credits in played in reverse.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbaup8Kd-Gk

Author
Time
cas_tanje said:

1 - He could speed up the parts where they fight, and keep the original speed when it slows down and they talk. In that way it keeps its emotional ebb and it would be so much more intense.
What about adding 'Battle of the Heroes' then (or another good song)? Adywan is considering it :D I hope he does add it!

 

 

 Dude, just... no.  In ESB, Luke is still a rookie, and his fight with Vader shows that he's greatly unmatched at this point.  Making it into some gradious battle just wouldn't make sense.  Maybe by the end of ROTJ, but not at this point.  Gotta keep it simple; the way it was originally is perfect.

Author
Time

Darrell, your edit ain't half bad!  It's mostly because it uses one of my favorite SW music pieces.

A Goon in a Gaggle of 'em

Author
Time

Not to continue the "change-a-thon" but most certainly, I've always been annoyed at the scene in TESB when the falcon does a flip around the cloud and heads back to get Luke, the cloud in the fore ground wasn't matted properly and the falcon is in front of the cloud when it actually should be behind it.

Anyone remember or notice what I'm talking about?

  • Todd

STAR WARS: Symphony for a Saga

Author
Time

I don't think this was mentioned before, so I'll say it:

After the droid attaches Luke's new hand, the next shot you see it in, it's turned off. It just seems kind of weird that he is just turned off at that point. Maybe make his eyes dim gradually until they are off during that shot so it won't be so abrupt.

Author
Time

The one with R2 and 3PO looking out the window, yea... it shows it turned off. I think it's a pickup shot. It looks COMPLETELY different than the other shots... like... different quality...

 

Almost like how in ROTJ, certain shots look lamost like they were recorded on an old cam-corder, and not a camera...all grainy and out of focus.

 

As for the cloud, I made a suggestion that the cloud as the falcon spins around it have a whisp come off and go with the falcon... I could just ammend the suggestion to mention that too


Is it not sad that in this time, we are more surprised by acts of love than acts of hate?
-Me

Author
Time
GoodMusician said:

Almost like how in ROTJ, certain shots look lamost like they were recorded on an old cam-corder, and not a camera...all grainy and out of focus.

I've always wondered about that. It's so strange and stands out like a sore thumb! But it was obviously a conscious decision, right? Right? :p

 

My crazy vinyl LP blog

My dumberer blog

My Retro blog

Author
Time

I'm fine with this coming out as late as May of 2010, it would be nice to have it come out the 30th aniversary of ESB.

Author
Time
sbassen said:
cas_tanje said:

1 - He could speed up the parts where they fight, and keep the original speed when it slows down and they talk. In that way it keeps its emotional ebb and it would be so much more intense.
What about adding 'Battle of the Heroes' then (or another good song)? Adywan is considering it :D I hope he does add it!

 

 

 Dude, just... no.  In ESB, Luke is still a rookie, and his fight with Vader shows that he's greatly unmatched at this point.  Making it into some gradious battle just wouldn't make sense.  Maybe by the end of ROTJ, but not at this point.  Gotta keep it simple; the way it was originally is perfect.

 

 Ok, I'm convinced because he's outmatched. But it will still be great if he added some music (Battle of the Heroes) :)

Author
Time
GoodMusician said:

And to be honest, saying something as vague as "the intereiors look boring. Add things like in the prequels," frankly... confuses me... I have NO idea what you're talking about to begin with... and seconly ... like what? What do you add to the interior of Hoth?

 

 I'm talking about the interiors of the ships, not the interiors of Hoth...

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Why would you reuse prequel music AGAIN???

The ESB soundtrack is the best one, don't change things that work.

And what would you change in the ships? All you get to see are walls and a display that shows a shield generator... the display looks fine to me and I don't think the walls looked that much different in the prequels either...

Author
Time

i agree here. the silence of lightsaber fights hightens the tension, especially as the music is the hum of the sabers. i did try putting the music from the throne room from ROTJ in there on movie maker and it worked well, but not as well as it being quiet.

 

im hoping that in adys prequel edits he trys having the musicless lightsaber fights, would be interesting.:)

Author
Time

I already brought up the adding music stuff to ESB when this thread started, Ady clearly stated he only added the music to the Obi/Vader fight as a way of bridging the prequels and that he would not add any to Empire. Really,I do wish some people would read the thread a bit before tossing out ideas, especially the ones that lead to unnecessary arguments.

Oh cant wait for updates from Ady, please let them arrive soon... : )

_________________

In the Works - TMNT:Return to New York -

robduenas.deviantart.com

sketchrob.com

 

 

Author
Time
sketchrob said:

I already brought up the adding music stuff to ESB when this thread started, Ady clearly stated he only added the music to the Obi/Vader fight as a way of bridging the prequels and that he would not add any to Empire. Really,I do wish some people would read the thread a bit before tossing out ideas, especially the ones that lead to unnecessary arguments.

Oh cant wait for updates from Ady, please let them arrive soon... : )

Yeah, I'm starting to feel like this thread is filling up with suggestions just for the sake of saying something, not because it would be a real improvement.  Empire needs the least amount of cleanup, and what changes it does need are more technical than artistic.

My outlook on life - we’re all on the Hindenburg anyway…no point fighting over the window seat.

Author
Time
Ziz said:
sketchrob said:

I already brought up the adding music stuff to ESB when this thread started, Ady clearly stated he only added the music to the Obi/Vader fight as a way of bridging the prequels and that he would not add any to Empire. Really,I do wish some people would read the thread a bit before tossing out ideas, especially the ones that lead to unnecessary arguments.

Oh cant wait for updates from Ady, please let them arrive soon... : )

Yeah, I'm starting to feel like this thread is filling up with suggestions just for the sake of saying something, not because it would be a real improvement.  Empire needs the least amount of cleanup, and what changes it does need are more technical than artistic.

Agreed, well said : ) I await Ady's return with new goodies but other than that the real "how-to-fix" stuff wont come till Jedi.

 

_________________

In the Works - TMNT:Return to New York -

robduenas.deviantart.com

sketchrob.com

 

 

Author
Time

just in defence of my point, i was just throwing out the idea that the PT lightsaber should not have music like the OT, so we dont need to suggest adding music as it may not be different by the time we see PT:Revisited!

 

i agree that the same things seem to get recycled which gets a tad annoying.

Author
Time
Ripplin said:
GoodMusician said:

Almost like how in ROTJ, certain shots look lamost like they were recorded on an old cam-corder, and not a camera...all grainy and out of focus.

I've always wondered about that. It's so strange and stands out like a sore thumb! But it was obviously a conscious decision, right? Right? :p

 

When was that? I never noticed anything like that.

 

Author
Time

could it be zoomed in footage? like shrinking in on what was already filmed?