BmB said:
And your result is emotionally out of tune with the rest of the battle. As I said before, it's about small but shining victories in the middle of overwhelming defeat, not about frustration.
I'm sorry, but your interpretation is very flawed. I'm sorry if I come off as rude, but it's hard not to when everyone explodes in my face for expressing my opinion.
EDIT:
In fact, the whole movie is like that. Nowhere is there any frustration or half victories in the whole movie. Either the empire is totally owning our heroes, or they're having one of their small but shining victories. But every time they do, save the very end, the empire is always right back on their tail.
I'm sorry but if all you are going to do is try and put me down I'd prefer if you didn't post. I'm trying to have a debate on this, and you're contributing nothing.
Don't make it so hard and be a little more accepting of conflicting views will you? Not to try and be offensive or anything, but most of you are just patting ady on the back, ady is left to defend his point of view on his own and a few others are vaguely chipping in on the controversy apparently in fear of the mindless pat-on-back horde jumping to the defense of anything that isn't flat out praise.
I like what he's doing, most of it is a massive improvement from what I've seen so far.
But some things are just going overboard, ultimately the mass of small (but impressive) fixes are outweighed by messing with the integrity of the film for no other reason than to be different. Or worse, as I have come to suspect now, simply misinterpreting the intent. So far this is the only such point of contention I have noticed, which is a damn shame.
You see , this is it. It is just YOUR interpretation. But you are coming across that your interpretation is gospel. My interpretation of the scene is not "very flawed" as you put it, at all. And that statement and ones like it is why you are coming across as plain arrogant. Everyone else has their own interpretations of certain scenes and events, but they don't start spouting crap like i am ruining the whole movie. And no one "exploded in you face" as you put it. You started saying things like how "incredibly fake" the scene looks just because you didn't want any changes to that scene. At that point all someone had asked was what scene you were talking about in your first post. And now you're saying that i'm "messing with the integrity of the movie of the film for no other reason than to be different". I clearly spelled out my reasoning for the new additions and provided a logical reason as to why it was added so why come out with crap like that?
Nowhere am i messing with the integrity of the movie. You see it as one way and i see it as another. But please get off your high horse that you are the only one that is right about that scene. And to tell people not to post because they disagree with you? WTF? And you aren't trying to have a debate at all. All you are doing is saying you're right and i'm wrong, nothing more. Funnily this scene was released over a year ago and yet it comes up now.
Have you actually stopped to think that maybe it is you're interpretation of the scene that is very flawed? When more people are interpreting the scene the way i have, not just here but on other sites too, then maybe you have got it wrong.
And that is the last i'm going to say on this subject. It was finished and added to the movie over a year ago and I have better things to do than continue a pointless argument and obviously this isn't going to be the edit for you so maybe you should just drop it now.
