STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION — Page 376

Tatooine matte doesn't need to be replaced, but maybe a subtle cloud layer moving separately from the planet itself would help.

DS explosion is fine.  Remember the scale of what's going on.  Those "yellow particles" in scale ARE giant flaming chunks of the station.

No, leave the Emperor and Yoda out of ANH.  That's something Lucas would do, which is why he crammed Jabba and Fett into the SE in the first place.

My hope is that, unlike the official saga that is supposed to be 123456 but really only can be watched 456123, Revisited should be able to be watched 456123 or 123456. Having Yoda in ANH would be more of a "what the heck is that?!" moment for those watching 456123.

jonathan7 said:

The other suggestion, again some of you may not like, is having a different Death Star explosion... The original explosion just doesn't seem very realistic to me, there's very little debry just some yellow particles.

I'm for this. I've always felt the DS explosion was unsatisfying. It just sorta POP!'s.

Ziz said:

Tatooine matte doesn't need to be replaced, but maybe a subtle cloud layer moving separately from the planet itself would help.

DS explosion is fine.  Remember the scale of what's going on.  Those "yellow particles" in scale ARE giant flaming chunks of the station.

No, leave the Emperor and Yoda out of ANH.  That's something Lucas would do, which is why he crammed Jabba and Fett into the SE in the first place.

You are of course entitled to your opinion but I completely disagree, obviously it's upto Ady, and it's his POV that will count. The Tattoine matte does to me just look like a painting, rather than a planet, though I'd be open to seeing what a cloud layer would do.

However I even think the explosion in the SE's is better than the original one, the yellow particles don't look like flaming bits of degree they look like confetti :-p @rayafraid... Agreed.

jonathan7 said:

Some may stone me for this, but could Ady replace the Tatooine matte at the start with something new...

I think he could use some of the footage from TPM and/or AotC.

asterisk8 said:

CAUTION: keep watching his mouth.

I wonder what happens if we don't watch his mouth...

TheStarlightTrain said:

CAUTION: keep watching his mouth

asterisk8 said:

CAUTION: keep watching his mouth.

Now there are two of them!

When you're watching his mouth, don't move. Don't even blink. Blink, and you're dead.

Akwat Kbrana said:

When you're watching his mouth, don't move. Don't even blink. Blink, and you're dead.

TheStarlightTrain said:

Trey Callum's Mouth error 

hi it's me jarod mighty from facebook the one i add you as a friend i just wanna let you know that you've forgotten the character: Trey Callum from empire strikes back his mouth isn't moving i saw it because it was sync & a voice dub you have to edit and change it and let it follow the quote check it on youtube.

CAUTION: keep watching his mouth

Although the grammar is atrocious, and it's in the wrong thread, he has a point.

About 26 mins into Empire (just after we see AT-AT's through the binoculars, and just before a chunk of snow/ice falls on R2), while Trey says "Echo Station 3T8", his lips ain't looking right.

I decided to watch Revisited (don't know why, you'd think I'd be sick of that movie by now but I really feel like watching it - but maybe the different experience is the allure of watching ANH:R rather than the other versions right now) and I forgot how awesome Ady's menu's were on the DVD9! Incredible job,Ady! On par IMO with the 2004 DVD menus, which IMHO were some of the best menu work ever.

I don't know if this has been pointed out before but in this shot for some reason you can see through Owen's head:

could just be thinning hair...

Just to make it clear, this glitch only appears in ANH:R, not in the SE or OOT.

I was wondering if Adywan (or anyone, honestly) would be willing to create a new menu layout for this that matches the bluray set. I'm pleasantly surprised how well the DVD-9 is holding up to the bluray, and am replacing it in my box set. It would be nice to have uniformity.

Also, if anyone would be willing to make some disc cover art for me to match as well, that would be awesome. I tried to do it on my own, and while usable, I'd love something a little closer to perfection.