Sign In

Revenge of the Sith (The New Canon Cut) [DRAFT AVAILABLE] — Page 24

Author
Time

Could I have a link to this edit as well? I’ve heard amazing things about this cut and would love to see it as a massive fan of Star Wars

Author
Time

I am in the minority in that I simply am not a big fan of ROTS much at all and all of your changes pretty much articulate why, so even if this is unpolished, I’d love to see what you’ve done. And, yes, if you ever do go back to it – hey Kenobi seems to have inspired you a bit, it could be cool to revisit it.

So, pretty please hit me up with a link!

Author
Time

As someone who never liked the Clone Wars because of how disjointed it felt with ROTS, I finally gave it a chance with Eddie’s cut and have been enjoying! I know you said you aren’t planning on starting this edit up again anytime soon, but man just looking at the clips makes me hope to see it finished some day. If you still have a link to your old workprint, I’d love to check it out!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

The tragedy of this edit is that it was finished at one point but then I got too ambitious and made like five or six choices I want to take back. I would go back and fix them now, but I don’t have a lot of the old source files any more, which makes navigating the already nightmarishly disorganized project a living hell.

I can probably edit the last export and just replace the parts I want to change, but I haven’t found the motivation to do that, especially since it caps the project going forward at 720p. If I wanted to continue this at all, I would have liked the eventual endpoint to be 1080p, submittable to FE and all, you know? i also don’t like the color grading any more

oh btw i am sending it to people still, if it looks like im ignoring everyone in this thread i just use PMs

Author
Time
 (Edited)

NFBisms said:

The tragedy of this edit is that it was finished at one point but then I got too ambitious and made like five or six choices I want to take back. I would go back and fix them now, but I don’t have a lot of the old source files any more, which makes navigating the already nightmarishly disorganized project a living hell.

I can probably edit the last export and just replace the parts I want to change, but I haven’t found the motivation to do that, especially since it caps the project going forward at 720p. If I wanted to continue this at all, I would have liked the eventual endpoint to be 1080p, submittable to FE and all, you know? i also don’t like the color grading any more

oh btw i am sending it to people still, if it looks like im ignoring everyone in this thread i just use PMs

Oh I feel you on “missing source files”… lost a lot of older edits because of this exact same thing. Also losing motivation after putting so much work in to practically have to start all over again is something I’ve done quite a lot.

I would definitely attempt to go for the best quality (1080p) if you choose to edit this any further. No point in going through all the work to salvage something that isn’t the best version or quality you want to put out. Maybe once you’re done with your Obi-Wan movie, it will be a little motivator to dive back into the same era with ROTS.

Can’t wait to check out this version nonetheless!

Author
Time

Would love to watch this, NFBisms! If at all possible, of course 😃

Author
Time

NFBisms said:

The tragedy of this edit is that it was finished at one point but then I got too ambitious and made like five or six choices I want to take back. I would go back and fix them now, but I don’t have a lot of the old source files any more, which makes navigating the already nightmarishly disorganized project a living hell.

I can probably edit the last export and just replace the parts I want to change, but I haven’t found the motivation to do that, especially since it caps the project going forward at 720p. If I wanted to continue this at all, I would have liked the eventual endpoint to be 1080p, submittable to FE and all, you know? i also don’t like the color grading any more

oh btw i am sending it to people still, if it looks like im ignoring everyone in this thread i just use PMs

You have new audio options thanks to the Lego Star Wars the skywalker saga.

Author
Time

I’d love to grab a link to the edit as well please - heard lots of great things about this one!

Author
Time

Would you kindly send me a link to the edit? Sounds phenomenal, I’d love to see it.

Author
Time

I’d love to see this! Could I get a link? From what I’ve read it seems like it’s one of those things that you got so involved with and all you see is the flaws but other people, who don’t know what you have in your mind as the perfect edit, see it as a great work. So I’m intrigued to see it!

Author
Time

May I have a google drive link to this Edit please thanks