Sign In

Removing Han, Leia, Lando, Palpatine, and (most of) Luke Fixes the Sequels (3-in-1 WIP)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I have a viewable (just PM for it!) rough draft of a 3-in-1 that has substantially reworked the sequel trilogy by placing it a further generation into the future, changing the character arcs for Rey and Kylo, and removing nearly all of the legacy characters.

The thesis I was operating under is that the sequels deep-sixed the legacy of the OT trilogy characters by either resetting them to their ANH state, deconstructing them, or just plain adding them for the nostalgia. So I wanted to see if there was a story in there that didn’t rely on the OT characters and assumed they all got their happily ever after.

And there is!

It’s all pinned on Rey and Kylo get the biggest changes. Ben Solo doesn’t exist and Kylo is not related to Han and Leia, rather he’s a fallen Jedi and Vader fanboy. Rey is now Padawan Rey Solo (explains why she owns the Falcon), the only survivor of Kylo’s second Jedi Purge, Han and Leia’s granddaughter, and Kylo’s ex-lover. This provides the personal stakes for Rey and a central theme of loss and loneliness for my edit. On Kylo’s end, it provides some stakes as well since her continued existence is a problem for Supreme Leader Snoke.

Plot wise, the story revolves around Starkiller Base (which is now located on Exogal) and does away with the Sith fleet. One planet killing MacGuffin is all that’s required although the wayfinder is still in play. Jakku is now Tatooine where First Order defector Lor San Tekka meets with General Poe Dameron over stolen Starkiller Base plans while Rey is there looking for Luke’s hidden secret journal which she hopes can help her rebuild the Jedi.

The other major change is that Canto Bight has been completely recontextualized. Instead of Rose and Finn shutting down the tracker to the First Order fleet, they’re going to Exogal to shut down the planetary shields and allow the Resistance through. The climax brings all the characters to Exogal: Rey finding the location and facing off against Kylo (using the Death Star duel), Finn and Rose sneaking around the base to lower the shields (using the scenes from Snoke’s Destroyer), and both the starfighter battles from episode 7 and 9.

Still a lot of edges to smooth out and I need to film a single shot myself, but the core of the film’s narrative is complete.

Here’s the new crawl:

Rising from the ashes of the Empire, the FIRST ORDER strike from Starkiller Base, located on the Kyber rich world of Exogal, and annexed the Outer Rim.

As the NEW REPUBLIC gathers at Kijimi, Generals Poe Dameron and Chewbacca establish a RESISTANCE in enemy space near an abandoned Jedi temple. Contacted by a defector who stole classified plans, Poe travels to Tatooine to retrieve them.

Meanwhile, betrayed by her former lover who launched a second Jedi Purge, Padawan Rey Solo searches for the secret journal of Luke Skywalker who vanished decades prior, and hopes it will help restore the Jedi Order…

Here’s the full story:

PROLOGUE

  • Snoke berates Kylo Ren for having not killing all of the Jedi in a second Jedi Purge as padawan Rey Solo made it out alive. Snoke "The seed of the Jedi lives in her, as long as it does, hope lives in the galaxy.
  • As Kylo has his stitches taken out, he replays the slaughter and his fight against Rey in his head. Rey loses her saber.
  • Rey briefly watches the Jedi temple burn

A LONG TIME AGO IN A GALAXY FAR, FAR AWAY…

  • New scroll explains: the rise of the First Order, Starkiller Base located on Exogal, Generals Poe and Chewbacca starting a resistance behind enemy lines, Poe off to meet with a First Oder defector on Tatooine, and that Kylo was Rey’s lover and she’s now looking for the secret journal of Luke Skywalker to help her restart the Jedi Order
  • Poe arrives on Tatooine and retrieves some plans. This sequence is nearly identical to the beginning of TFA minus anything that relates to Ben Solo
  • Rey Solo arrives on Tatooine on the Millennium Falcon, landing just outside Niima outpost
  • Kylo gets the location of where the plans are hidden from Poe
  • Rey rents a speeder and travels out to the Skywalker homestead where she digs up Luke’s journal. She’s interrupted by a sound and finds BB8 being captured by a junk trader
  • Finn helps Poe escape
  • Finn makes it to Niima outpost where he bumps into Rey and they’re attacked by the First Order. They take the Millennium Falcon and escape Tatooine
  • Kylo receives the report that the droid escaped with Finn’s help… “What girl?” takes on a more ominous feel
  • Kylo and Hux talk to Snoke. Snoke says the droid is in the hands of Kylo’s lover, Rey Solo. Kylo: “she means nothing to me.”
  • They arrive on D’Qar where Finn reunites with Poe. Rey is called to a nearby Jedi temple where she finds a lightsaber and trains.
  • Rey then goes through Luke’s journal, passing by an image of a wayfinder
  • Threepio informs General Poe that the data is encrypted. He informs the resistance that they haven’t decrypted the information yet, but they know that the first order is building something on a world called Exogal. Rey recognizes that name from Luke’s journal and says she’ll find the wayfinder that leads to Exogal, starting where Luke’s trail went cold. Chewbacca goes with her (but not R2).
  • Meanwhile, Kylo meets with Snoke again. Snoke says there’s been an awakening and if he’s felt it. He responds with “Yes, she’ll never be a Jedi. I can turn her to the dark side.” Snoke: “If what you say about this girl is true, bring her to me.” Kylo knows what she needs and grabs the wayfinder from a First Order depot and uses it to travel to Starkiller Base on Exogal
  • Rey travels to Ahch-To but finds it empty. She notices an X-Wing in the water below.
  • Starkiller Base destroys the Republic capital on Kijimi
  • The resistance finishes decoding the data on the plans for Starkiller base. They come up with a plan to knock it out. Finn says he can take out the shield.
  • Ahch-To: Rey wakes up in the village and has the first connection with Kylo. She then trains with the lightsaber as a force ghost (whose face isn’t seen) watches over her. She turns to where it was and looks toward the top of the mountain. As she climbs it, she’s then pulled toward the tree. When she reaches for the books, she has a bit of a halucinatory vision where a voice explains the Jedi texts and Rey admits she’s afraid of herself.
  • Meanwhile, on the Raddus in D’Qar orbit, Finn along with Rose explain how to deactivate the shield but they can’t do it without getting past the shields first. Maz tells them where they can find a codebreaker to sneak them past
  • Ahch-To: At the top of the mountain, Rey meditates and has a vision of a place on the island. Her vision also shows her holding the wayfinder.
  • Kylo talks to Vader’s mask, telling it about feeling the pull to the light
  • Ahch-To: Chewbacca is having issues with the Porgs in the Falcon’s cockpit. Rey has a second connection with Kylo where he tries to explain why he destroyed the Jedi temple. Rey isn’t listening to him and says he is a monster and the connection fizzles out.
  • Kylo destroys his mask, angry at being called a monster by someone he obviously still has feelings for.
  • Rose and Finn land on Canto Bight and get arrested
  • Snoke speaks with Hux saying the Resistance must be destroyed. Hux says they’ve located the Resistance fleet. Snoke is pleased and tells Hux to go to him with Kylo Ren, it’s time to complete his training.
  • Kylo fixes the mask he smashed in rage
  • Ahch-To: Chewbacca has dinner. The third connection between Kylo and Rey is radically rewritten here using footage of Kylo in his quarters from TRoS. Kylo says “you still want to kill me.” Rey: “yes.” Kylo: “such pain, such anger.” Rey asks him why he killed them. Kylo says Snoke wanted her dead so he wanted to turn her to the dark side to keep her safe. He tries to rationalize them being together in the dark side and that her mother was the granddaughter of Vader.
  • Rey goes to the hole in the ground and touches the mirror where she has a few visions. One is when Kylo grabbed the wayfinder with a voice over “the only way you’re getting to Exogal is with me”. Another is her and Kylo kissing with a voice over from Kylo “I’ll never stop loving you” and them raising blue lightsabers together. The final one is her sitting on a throne and holding the red double saber with Kylo behind her. “Don’t be afraid of who you are” (Kylo also says “who you are”) There’s the brief saber battle with her dark reflection. The vision ends with a Kylo voice over “the dark side is in our nature, give in to it.”
  • Fourth force connection: Rey admits she’s never felt so alone. Kylo tells her she’s not alone. They touch hands and then heads off with Chewbacca to the First Order fleet.
  • The first order fleet arrives at D’Qar with Snoke’s destroyer. The battle begins.
  • Rey arrives and heads aboard using the escape pod.
  • The D’Qar battle is cross cut with Rey facing Supreme Leader Snoke who informers her it was him who bridged Kylo and Rey’s minds. He tortures her for the hell of it and then wants Kylo to finish her off.
  • Kylo kills the emperor and fights side by side with Rey against the guards. Meanwhile, Paige is the last bomber left.
  • After killing the royal guards, Kylo reaches out his hand and wants her to join him. She goes for the lightsaber instead. As the saber splits in half, Paige drops the payload and splits Snoke’s ship in two.
  • The resistance fleet escapes and Rey steals Kylo’s starfighter and leaves herself.
  • Kylo wakes up and has a chat with Hux. They know where the resistance are going.
  • Back on Canto Bight, Finn and Rose meet DJ and escape prison. They meet the kids and the fathiers scene plays out normally.
  • Ahch-To: Rey destroys Kylo’s ship and Luke emerges from it. He explains to her that facing fear is the destiny of the Jedi. He also explains that his sister, on her last night of training, put her saber down and said someone would complete her journey and gives Rey Leia’s saber to take to Exogal. Everything else plays out normally in this scene.
  • The Resistance arrives at an auxiliary staging point located on Ajan Kloss. Poe sends out a signal to the outer rim. R2 recieves a message from Luke’s starfighter and 3P0 tells General Poe. He communicates with Finn and Rose on the stolen yacht that they’re tracking an old ID, Finn says it has to be Rey showing them the way to Exogal. The Resistance sets off.
  • The First Order at Exogal track a lone fighter on approach. Kylo senses her and says “she’s mine.” The shields to the planet are lowered allowing Rey to land. The shields are raised again.
  • Meanwhile, Finn arrives, DJ gets them past the shield and they infiltrate the base.
  • Meanwhile, Poe is in his X-Wing leading the charge along the markers Rey left behind.
  • Rose gets the shields lowered. The Resistance fleet arrives and are immediately fired on by the First Order fleet. Poe says help is on the way.
  • Kylo confronts Rey in a watery junkyard of some kind on Exogal (heh).
  • Rose and Finn are captured. BB8 escapes and sabotages the oscillator, creating a hole.
  • As they try to reach the oscillator, they’re swarmed by TIE fighters. Meanwhile, Rey is starting to lose her saber duel and Finn and Rose are brought before Hux. Phasma orders their execution to hurt.
  • Poe thinks all hope is lost when he hears the sound of lightspeed ships arriving. Everyone arrives including Chewbacca who growls (as does a Porg). Poe heads to the oscilator as Kylo forces Rey down to her knees and the stormtroopers are about to decapitate Rose and Finn.
  • The oscilator explodes, drawing Kylo’s attention away for a moment and Rey strikes, stabbing him. The explosion also saves Rose and Finn. Finn faces off against Phasma as BB8 is operating a walker. The Resistance and the starships that have shown up are now taking down the First Order fleet.
  • Rey confesses to a dying Kylo that she did want to take his hand but leaves him to his fate.
  • Finn kills Phasma and escapes with BB8 and Rose aboard a shuttle. He signals to Poe that Red 5 is in the air and the fleet escapes Exogal as it explodes.
  • They celebrate on Ajan Kloss

EPILOGUE

  • A small child on Canto Bight tells a story of Luke Skywalker to two other children before they’re yelled at to return to work. One child uses the force to grab a broom and begins to sweep. He stops when he hears footsteps on the cobblestone and looks up. A voice informs him: “I’m Rey” and we see her approach him. Rey is ready to restart the Jedi.
Author
Time

Just here to say that this sounds very interesting. May I have a link to the rough cut?

Author
Time

I’ve sent you a PM with a link! Hope you like it!

Author
Time

Sounds cool! It would be nice to see a written outline of the plot if you have one.

Check out my edit “THE END OF THE JEDI”. It’s a 2 in 1 edit of TLJ and ROS.

“To say that ‘if the Jedi die, the light dies’ is vanity, can you feel that?” -Luke

Author
Time

Peregrine said:

Sounds cool! It would be nice to see a written outline of the plot if you have one.

I’ll end up editing my post but here it goes.

PROLOGUE

  • Snoke berates Kylo Ren for having not killing all of the Jedi in a second Jedi Purge as padawan Rey Solo made it out alive. Snoke "The seed of the Jedi lives in her, as long as it does, hope lives in the galaxy.
  • As Kylo has his stitches taken out, he replays the slaughter and his fight against Rey in his head. Rey loses her saber.
  • Rey briefly watches the Jedi temple burn

A LONG TIME AGO IN A GALAXY FAR, FAR AWAY…

  • New scroll explains: the rise of the First Order, Starkiller Base located on Exogal, Generals Poe and Chewbacca starting a resistance behind enemy lines, Poe off to meet with a First Oder defector on Tatooine, and that Kylo was Rey’s lover and she’s now looking for the secret journal of Luke Skywalker to help her restart the Jedi Order
  • Poe arrives on Tatooine and retrieves some plans. This sequence is nearly identical to the beginning of TFA minus anything that relates to Ben Solo
  • Rey Solo arrives on Tatooine on the Millennium Falcon, landing just outside Niima outpost
  • Kylo gets the location of where the plans are hidden from Poe
  • Rey rents a speeder and travels out to the Skywalker homestead where she digs up Luke’s journal. She’s interrupted by a sound and finds BB8 being captured by a junk trader
  • Finn helps Poe escape
  • Finn makes it to Niima outpost where he bumps into Rey and they’re attacked by the First Order. They take the Millennium Falcon and escape Tatooine
  • Kylo receives the report that the droid escaped with Finn’s help… “What girl?” takes on a more ominous feel
  • Kylo and Hux talk to Snoke. Snoke says the droid is in the hands of Kylo’s lover, Rey Solo. Kylo: “she means nothing to me.”
  • They arrive on D’Qar where Finn reunites with Poe. Rey is called to a nearby Jedi temple where she finds a lightsaber and trains.
  • Rey then goes through Luke’s journal, passing by an image of a wayfinder
  • Threepio informs General Poe that the data is encrypted. He informs the resistance that they haven’t decrypted the information yet, but they know that the first order is building something on a world called Exogal. Rey recognizes that name from Luke’s journal and says she’ll find the wayfinder that leads to Exogal, starting where Luke’s trail went cold. Chewbacca goes with her (but not R2).
  • Meanwhile, Kylo meets with Snoke again. Snoke says there’s been an awakening and if he’s felt it. He responds with “Yes, she’ll never be a Jedi. I can turn her to the dark side.” Snoke: “If what you say about this girl is true, bring her to me.” Kylo knows what she needs and grabs the wayfinder from a First Order depot and uses it to travel to Starkiller Base on Exogal
  • Rey travels to Ahch-To but finds it empty. She notices an X-Wing in the water below.
  • Starkiller Base destroys the Republic capital on Kijimi
  • The resistance finishes decoding the data on the plans for Starkiller base. They come up with a plan to knock it out. Finn says he can take out the shield.
  • Ahch-To: Rey wakes up in the village and has the first connection with Kylo. She then trains with the lightsaber as a force ghost (whose face isn’t seen) watches over her. She turns to where it was and looks toward the top of the mountain. As she climbs it, she’s then pulled toward the tree. When she reaches for the books, she has a bit of a halucinatory vision where a voice explains the Jedi texts and Rey admits she’s afraid of herself.
  • Meanwhile, on the Raddus in D’Qar orbit, Finn along with Rose explain how to deactivate the shield but they can’t do it without getting past the shields first. Maz tells them where they can find a codebreaker to sneak them past
  • Ahch-To: At the top of the mountain, Rey meditates and has a vision of a place on the island. Her vision also shows her holding the wayfinder.
  • Kylo talks to Vader’s mask, telling it about feeling the pull to the light
  • Ahch-To: Chewbacca is having issues with the Porgs in the Falcon’s cockpit. Rey has a second connection with Kylo where he tries to explain why he destroyed the Jedi temple. Rey isn’t listening to him and says he is a monster and the connection fizzles out.
  • Kylo destroys his mask, angry at being called a monster by someone he obviously still has feelings for.
  • Rose and Finn land on Canto Bight and get arrested
  • Snoke speaks with Hux saying the Resistance must be destroyed. Hux says they’ve located the Resistance fleet. Snoke is pleased and tells Hux to go to him with Kylo Ren, it’s time to complete his training.
  • Kylo fixes the mask he smashed in rage
  • Ahch-To: Chewbacca has dinner. The third connection between Kylo and Rey is radically rewritten here using footage of Kylo in his quarters from TRoS. Kylo says “you still want to kill me.” Rey: “yes.” Kylo: “such pain, such anger.” Rey asks him why he killed them. Kylo says Snoke wanted her dead so he wanted to turn her to the dark side to keep her safe. He tries to rationalize them being together in the dark side and that her mother was the granddaughter of Vader.
  • Rey goes to the hole in the ground and touches the mirror where she has a few visions. One is when Kylo grabbed the wayfinder with a voice over “the only way you’re getting to Exogal is with me”. Another is her and Kylo kissing with a voice over from Kylo “I’ll never stop loving you” and them raising blue lightsabers together. The final one is her sitting on a throne and holding the red double saber with Kylo behind her. “Don’t be afraid of who you are” (Kylo also says “who you are”) There’s the brief saber battle with her dark reflection. The vision ends with a Kylo voice over “the dark side is in our nature, give in to it.”
  • Fourth force connection: Rey admits she’s never felt so alone. Kylo tells her she’s not alone. They touch hands and then heads off with Chewbacca to the First Order fleet.
  • The first order fleet arrives at D’Qar with Snoke’s destroyer. The battle begins.
  • Rey arrives and heads aboard using the escape pod.
  • The D’Qar battle is cross cut with Rey facing Supreme Leader Snoke who informers her it was him who bridged Kylo and Rey’s minds. He tortures her for the hell of it and then wants Kylo to finish her off.
  • Kylo kills the emperor and fights side by side with Rey against the guards. Meanwhile, Paige is the last bomber left.
  • After killing the royal guards, Kylo reaches out his hand and wants her to join him. She goes for the lightsaber instead. As the saber splits in half, Paige drops the payload and splits Snoke’s ship in two.
  • The resistance fleet escapes and Rey steals Kylo’s starfighter and leaves herself.
  • Kylo wakes up and has a chat with Hux. They know where the resistance are going.
  • Back on Canto Bight, Finn and Rose meet DJ and escape prison. They meet the kids and the fathiers scene plays out normally.
  • Ahch-To: Rey destroys Kylo’s ship and Luke emerges from it. He explains to her that facing fear is the destiny of the Jedi. He also explains that his sister, on her last night of training, put her saber down and said someone would complete her journey and gives Rey Leia’s saber to take to Exogal. Everything else plays out normally in this scene.
  • The Resistance arrives at an auxiliary staging point located on Ajan Kloss. Poe sends out a signal to the outer rim. R2 recieves a message from Luke’s starfighter and 3P0 tells General Poe. He communicates with Finn and Rose on the stolen yacht that they’re tracking an old ID, Finn says it has to be Rey showing them the way to Exogal. The Resistance sets off.
  • The First Order at Exogal track a lone fighter on approach. Kylo senses her and says “she’s mine.” The shields to the planet are lowered allowing Rey to land. The shields are raised again.
  • Meanwhile, Finn arrives, DJ gets them past the shield and they infiltrate the base.
  • Meanwhile, Poe is in his X-Wing leading the charge along the markers Rey left behind.
  • Rose gets the shields lowered. The Resistance fleet arrives and are immediately fired on by the First Order fleet. Poe says help is on the way.
  • Kylo confronts Rey in a watery junkyard of some kind on Exogal (heh).
  • Rose and Finn are captured. BB8 escapes and sabotages the oscillator, creating a hole.
  • As they try to reach the oscillator, they’re swarmed by TIE fighters. Meanwhile, Rey is starting to lose her saber duel and Finn and Rose are brought before Hux. Phasma orders their execution to hurt.
  • Poe thinks all hope is lost when he hears the sound of lightspeed ships arriving. Everyone arrives including Chewbacca who growls (as does a Porg). Poe heads to the oscilator as Kylo forces Rey down to her knees and the stormtroopers are about to decapitate Rose and Finn.
  • The oscilator explodes, drawing Kylo’s attention away for a moment and Rey strikes, stabbing him. The explosion also saves Rose and Finn. Finn faces off against Phasma as BB8 is operating a walker. The Resistance and the starships that have shown up are now taking down the First Order fleet.
  • Rey confesses to a dying Kylo that she did want to take his hand but leaves him to his fate.
  • Finn kills Phasma and escapes with BB8 and Rose aboard a shuttle. He signals to Poe that Red 5 is in the air and the fleet escapes Exogal as it explodes.
  • They celebrate on Ajan Kloss

EPILOGUE

  • A small child on Canto Bight tells a story of Luke Skywalker to two other children before they’re yelled at to return to work. One child uses the force to grab a broom and begins to sweep. He stops when he hears footsteps on the cobblestone and looks up. A voice informs him: “I’m Rey” and we see her approach him. Rey is ready to restart the Jedi.
Author
Time
 (Edited)

I think this is a solid attempt at a 3 in 1, and I can tell you put a lot of work into this edit. That being said, it didn’t totally work for me. It was sometimes hard to watch because of rough edits (but it is a rough cut). I think it’s just hard to pull off this approach of removing all the legacy characters and completely changing the setup of who Rey and Kylo are. But you’ve done a great job with the idea!

Here’s a bunch of recommendations. Hopefully some of them are helpful.

My biggest advice would be to simplify. Anything that is not necessary to the plot should be removed. Anything that is necessary should have as few changes as possible, to preserve the original flow of the editing. Every change you make removes some believability from the film, because even subtle changes can be detected and all these little things add up.

In general, the scene transitions need more attention. Establishing shots could be used in many places.

35:53 is where you started to lose me. She just randomly finds luke’s saber and then it cuts to her training it a totally different place, then she is reading a book. It’s really hard to tell what is going on here, possibly due to how the scenes transition. Maybe move the training sequence earlier in the film to show she is already a Jedi right off the bat. Or maybe just remove it because it doesn’t seem to fit well anywhere. I think It will be clear she is a Jedi when she practices with her saber on Ach-to.

36:53 is where a lot of heavy exposition is shoved into like a minute. It is really hard to tell what data BB-8 provided. And the pacing makes this exposition really hard to digest. Any establishing shots or shots of random resistance people would be really helpful here to slow down this scene so we can digest the plot that is being setup.

When poe is explaining the intel:
“They’ve been building something for years” … “on a world called exegol”
Maybe insert something like “a planetkiller”.

Rough scene transition at 43:43
Rough scene transition at 45:34

Why would Kylo need a wayfinder to get to exegol? Isn’t that his own base?

Trim down the canto bight scene to focus on finding the codebreaker. Anything else is just filler.

The dream sequence in the cave on Ach-to is hard to understand. Is it real or not? Is she actually finding a wayfinder? why is kylo there? why is dark rey there? why did she go down there? Is this scene necessary?

Especially towards the end there are too many scene changes in the middle of a scene. I think there is too many transitions in between existing scenes (For example 1:36:00)

It is hard to tell where BB-8 is before he destroys the shield generator. He should blow it up right after they are captured so we don’t forget that he didn’t get captured along with them.

Rey killing kylo is pretty rough and distracting, losing the emotional weight because of the weird edits. Maybe give him a good reason to drop his saber so the original edit can be used? Or just improve it some more. Also, Rey crying after she stabs Kylo should immediately follow that moment so it doesn’t break the emotional flow of the scene.

In the second half of the movie it’s hard to understand where things are happening. We are on a ship, a planet and an ocean at the same time. I get that it’s supposed to all be the same planet but it’s hard to believe. Anything that can be done to include more establishing shots, or connect the locations would be helpful.

I would add some dialog before the lightsaber duel because it’s feels strange to have them just jump into fighting.

Less cutting between scenes would improve the flow. The more time we can spend in one location the more invested we can become in that part of the story. For example there are like 5 times where we cut away from Kylo and Rey’s lightsaber duel and in the original film it’s all one scene, so it really isn’t meant to be broken up. This gives it a choppy feeling.

Definitely lots of cool ideas and edits. Very bold approach. The plot could use some simplification to make it easier to follow what is going on. And the scene transitions need work to make the overall film easier to watch. Best of luck!

Check out my edit “THE END OF THE JEDI”. It’s a 2 in 1 edit of TLJ and ROS.

“To say that ‘if the Jedi die, the light dies’ is vanity, can you feel that?” -Luke

Author
Time

Some good suggestions in there (especially some that address things I wasn’t sure about). The finding of the lightsaber was a work around for me to explain why she didn’t use it on Tatooine… in retrospect, I don’t think that needs explaining especially with the scene on Ahch-To. Other suggestions are actually what many other people think are a strength of the edit.

Ultimately, thank you for the feedback! I’ll definitely be using some of the suggestions!