This thread is for people who haven’t yet seen the movie who want to see what those in the forum who have seen the new movie think of it. DO NOT POST REVIEWS OF THE MOVIE HERE. Simply give the movie a rating somewhere between 100(the best movie ever) and 0(the worst movie ever). Remember, no details, no spoilers, no nothing except a rating.

UPDATE: This thread is now for rating The Last Jedi. The same rules above apply. Just give the movie a rating between 100(the best movie ever) and 0(the worst movie ever). Remember, no details, no spoilers, no nothing except a rating.

NO SPOILERS ALLOWED!

Best movie ever is 100? I’m not sure what would be 100, but I wouldn’t rate a SW movie that and I love the damn things.

At the moment, I’ll say 82.

Wouldn’t a 1/10 rating be simpler?

but less exacting.

86.1139

In relation to the other Star Wars movies, eighty something. In relation to every movie ever, seventy something.

TFA is the fourth best SW movie. Probably the best fan film that could possibly be made.

generalfrevious said:

TFA is the fourth best SW movie. Probably the best fan film that could possibly be made.

Well if this isn’t the most glowing review Eeyore could possible give, I don’t know what is. I can’t wait to see it tomorrow!

Haha, I have to say his review excited me more than just about all the other ones!

To be fair, TFA is tied, maybe even better than Jedi, and light years ahead of the prequels.

After the initial viewing I’d give it a ‘meh’ out of ‘whatever’.

Predictably unremarkable. Hopefully the next one will be better. I’m stunned I didn’t end up being hyped for it or enjoying it more.

6/10. TV guide 2.5 out of 4 stars. Take your pick.

My rating :
TPM - 3/10
AOTC - 4/10
ROTS - 0/10
SW/ANH - 9/10
TESB - 10/10
ROTJ - 5/10
TFA - 6/10

um, how can ROTJ get both 0/10 AND 5/10 at the same time? Is that your way of rating ROTJ 2.5/10?

Jay said:

5/10.

Meh.

is it any better that the PT movies?

TPM 4/10
AOTC 2/10
ROTS 3/10
ANH 9/10
ESB 10/10
ROTJ 8/10
TFA 7/10

Warbler said:

um, how can ROTJ get both 0/10 AND 5/10 at the same time? Is that your way of rating ROTJ 2.5/10?

Because the first ROTJ was supposed to be ROTS of course 😃