The first season of Supergirl has finally wrapped up. My final thoughts?
Melissa Benoist is good; David Harewood is good; the rest of the main cast is … passable. But the writing? The writing … how to phrase this …

I thought Smallville had sophomoric writing, but this show truly redefines the word. Even at its poorest, Smallville at least knew how to properly structure out a season-long storyarc and create a balance between the arc and the standalone episodes. The first season of Supergirl, however? It meanders about like a blind drunk in search of something – a something they keep forgotting about only to remember what it is fleetingly and only at the most inconvenient moments.
Before I forget, let me bring up this show’s particular take on the Superman family’s roster of supervillains. To be blunt, except for the Toyman, they were all weak or terrible interpretations. The Silver Banshee, in particular, was done godawful injustice; just think Venom from Spider-Man 3 with a sex change.
I’m not even going to talk about how Superman’s “cameos” in this series were handled. Just watch the last two episodes of this season and you’ll know everything you need to know.
Now, I don’t want to create the impression that I hate the show – I don’t. Like I said, I do really like Ms. Benoist as the titular character. However, the writing just isn’t up to her level – not at all – and it’s all very quite disappointing.
I’m hoping that come season 2, the writers will actually commit themselves to telling a good, clear, linear storyarc with good, properly-developed villains. If they don’t, neither will I; I will drop this series and they will have lost a viewer.