logo Sign In

Is it just me or does the theatrical cut feel faster than SE?

Author
Time

May I explain? Recently, my brother and I binged the entire Original trilogy after years of not having seen the OT Star Wars films. Nice nostalgia for us. Also recently, I’ve finally gotten around to getting the theatrical cuts and for the past two days, we’ve been watching them. Now, we’ve only done ANH and ESB, so ROTJ has yet to be watched. Still, I couldn’t help but feel as if the theatrical cut is faster in pacing than the Special Edition. During the “These aren’t the droids you’re looking for” scene and most of Cloud City felt as if it was sped up by either 0.5 or 1.0. And don’t get me started on Kenobi’s and Vader’s duel, that was definitely faster, no question about it. Now, I personally have always appreciated the pacing as it added to the magic of Star Wars as well as the myth of which it aimed for. Every time Yoda delivered and the brief pause after let you soak in the magic which was being poured out. The swell of William’s score during the X-wing moment or the building suspense of Luke just walking up stairs to confront Vader, all of it perfect. Yet watching the theatrical cut feels like the pauses get only a fraction of their moments. I ain’t saying the theatrical cut is like super fast but the fact that it’s fast enough to not have any brief pause kills what makes Star Wars magical. I don’t want to have to feel like I need to watch the SE because it at least has good pacing (for example, how the wampa is handled in the theatrical is brilliant) but I’m not at ease with the theatrical if it really is sped up. So, I’m curious if anyone else has felt this way, is the theatrical sped up or am I crazy and need to rewatch the theatrical?

Author
Time

What was the source of the original theatrical versions you watched ? If it was an original laserdisc source , it may actually have been sped up a bit as the early ones were time compressed . For the original star wars, it does move faster in general without the added Jabba scene and expanded Mos Eisley scenes that pad out the run time , same with Empire in thd scene where Vader returns to his Star Destroyer, using outtakes from ROTJ as the hangar is actually Death Star 2 , and Moff Jerjerod is even standing there.

https://screamsinthevoid.deviantart.com/

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Where did you get your copies of the original theatrical cuts? I have 3 versions in laserdisc which I have captured but can’t seem to be able to enhance them as I would like to authors Blu rays

Author
Time

Yeah Screams in the Void is right they were time compressed. Only the early Japanese release of SW wasn’t time compressed on laserdisc. It wasn’t until the CAV release in 1985 also analog only audio that there was no time compression on the US release. And the first letterbox was the Japan Special Collection.

Television early on had time compressed versions. And early laserdisc as well. Pal speedup is also something that needs to spoken of if one is in Pal Standard region. Or perhaps Secam.

Author
Time

screams in the void said:

What was the source of the original theatrical versions you watched ? If it was an original laserdisc source , it may actually have been sped up a bit as the early ones were time compressed . For the original star wars, it does move faster in general without the added Jabba scene and expanded Mos Eisley scenes that pad out the run time , same with Empire in thd scene where Vader returns to his Star Destroyer, using outtakes from ROTJ as the hangar is actually Death Star 2 , and Moff Jerjerod is even standing there.

Uh the 4K projects, but I recently did a rewatch and turns out I must have been tripping as whatever the issue was that made it feel rushed the first watch is no longer present on rewatch. Thanks for helping though, that is interesting.