Info Wanted: GOUT - Anyone done an anamorphic version? aka which version to get?

After reading the fantastic website (http://secrethistoryofstarwars.com) “secrethistoryofstarwars.com)”) I’v decided to try and get an original copy of the ‘original films’ as best I can anyway. Why? Well mainly this website really drummed home how distorted the original films have become with not only new scenes being added but also the actual cinemtography of the films. Sure there’s some scenes which are kick ass, such as the space battle but I’m thinking that I’d prefer my children to watch the version that  I watched (near enough) when it comes time.

After checking on the screenshot comparisons it looks like the GOUT’s picture is a few shades under the actual DVD (although still looking very good) and so I was wondering if anyone has ever done a 5.1 anamorphic version of this?

If not, which is the best version to get really? I was thinking of the classic versions originally but now Im thinking more of some of the laser disc ports that are out if not the GOUT.

If anyone could confirm and advise it would be much appreciated,.

lol

(own the original first, dude)

This page...:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/The-NEW-official-Screenshots-thread/topic/4681/

...states that 5 fan made preservations are anamorphic.

But if you want the best preservation of Star Wars. I highly recommend OCPMovie's Classic Edition 2.0 Version:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Classic-Edition-2-0-NEW-from-Ocpmovie/topic/6935

and the Lucasfilm Pwnage Edition:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Classic-Edition-2-0-NEW-from-Ocpmovie/topic/6935

PaulisDead2221 is currently working on a Vintage edit which we don't know when it will be available:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-The-Vintage-Edit/topic/8069

ThiefCobbler4ever said:

But if you want the best preservation of Star Wars. I highly recommend OCPMovie's Classic Edition 2.0 Version:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Classic-Edition-2-0-NEW-from-Ocpmovie/topic/6935

I find the changes from the '04 footage to the LD footage too jarring on the OCP versions.  Personally I prefer dark_jedi's GOUT-sourced project, and as a bonus, they also include 5.1 sound.

I've never had any lucking find the Pwnage edition, personally...

It's the same as OCP's version.

ThiefCobbler4ever said:

But if you want the best preservation of Star Wars. I highly recommend OCPMovie's Classic Edition 2.0 Version:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Classic-Edition-2-0-NEW-from-Ocpmovie/topic/6935

and the Lucasfilm Pwnage Edition:

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Classic-Edition-2-0-NEW-from-Ocpmovie/topic/6935

lol

captainsolo said:

How does DarkJedi's GOUT project compare  to this?

DJ's version looks a bit better.  It is dual layer and has mono, 2.0 and 5.1. 

G-Force's version of ANH is astounding.  I cannot wait for ESB and ROTJ.  I'm looking forward to them more than ESB:R and the other AVCHDs, simply because I love to see the theatrical versions looking so good.

Chewtobacca said:

G-Force's version of ANH is astounding.

Sure would LOVE to see a sample or something of this,I just can't believe that this version would be SO much different than the one I did,and I used a way better encoder,but hey,to each their own right?

and if it is SO much better than the other scripts,why not let some of us see what we can do with the script with our own encoders and settings.

dark_jedi said:

Sure would LOVE to see a sample or something of this,I just can't believe that this version would be SO much different than the one I did,and I used a way better encoder,but hey,to each their own right?

and if it is SO much better than the other scripts,why not let some of us see what we can do with the script with our own encoders and settings.

I don't know.  I wasn't trying to belittle your versions, mate.  They were the first time I'd seen the proper original trilogy in true widescreen glory in ages, and I was absolutely delighted with them.

I just happened to put G-Force's on my television when I was doing something one day, and a number of other people came and watched and said it looked terrific, and it's only a single layer.   I thought G-Force was going to release the scripts.

Which encoder did G-Force use anyway?  HC Enc?

That is why I said "to each their own"but I really have a hard time buying it is exactly the same,my opinion only,doubtful.

Moth3r said:

I've read good things about HC Encoder from respectable members on the Doom9 forum; although I've not tried it myself as I am so used to CCE. Apparently it is slower than CCE but produces comparable quality. It is wrong to automatically assume that CCE is way better just because it's a commercial product.

Quite right.  I've read that too.  It is most definitely slower - I've used both - but I don't think there's much in it quality wise.  Even if it is almost as good, it is great that there is a free encoder for people to use that is so near the standard of a top commercial product such as CCE.

Cheers for the really kind replies guys. I'l be honest with you in that I don't own the recent re-issue of the DVD's with the OT on (although i do own the 2004 DVD as well as the OT in Pan and Scan and Widescreen.. But then this thread was about owning the OT in anamorphic format and as far as I am aware this is no available in an official capacity (unless you want the special edition)

Moth3r said:

We need to update the screenshots thread with these new versions - yes I know I've been saying this for ages now. In the meantime, there are a small number of shots comparing the GOUT with the Pwnage Edition here

The rapidshare link to its cover is dead. :(

I got this release and although I think the colours are much improved, I felt it was really over grainy, especially in comparison to dark_jedi's release (although I'm aware at times this release removed too much grain), and I'm a person who prefers grain in older films.

Still they're all better than what Lucasfilm has released so far.

Any plans to do Empire and Jedi in a pwnage edition?